Versus Battle Jinbe vs Gigantomachia

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    4

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#10
Because Jinbe really doesn’t have phenomenal AP at Gigantomachia shrugged off Dabi’s flame like it was nothing. Tough to scale the two to each other but Jinbe has never had great AP.
Jimbe is strong, and being strong in One piece means being a monster in MHA. And Vagabond drill and fishman karate is hax and powerful
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#11
Because Jinbe really doesn’t have phenomenal AP at Gigantomachia shrugged off Dabi’s flame like it was nothing. Tough to scale the two to each other but Jinbe has never had great AP.
I know Machia looks tough and all but his biggest advantage is his size which isn't a problem for someone on Jinbe level. He's barely taller than normal Giants from OP meaning he'd get dwarfed by the likes of Numbers, Oars.Jr and Oars forget about Wadatsumi whose puffed version was sent by Jinbe. And let's not forget the fact that Jinbe can deal internal damage with water based attacks. Jinbe obliterates Machi.

EDIT: Jinbe did not send Wadatsumi flying. He was rolling around after getting hit though.

Gigantomachia also has quirks to keep him fighting and make him immune to pain IiRC
He can fight for a little over 24 hours without taking breaks irrc.
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
#12
Jinbe obliterates Machia.
When the dude has literally taken 0 damage on panel and has fought guys with more dangerous offenses than Jinbe like Dabi and Shiggy, this is a pretty audacious claim.

Jinbe in OP is what? A low high tier? That shouldn’t be out of range of MHA top tiers.
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#13
When the dude has literally taken 0 damage on panel and has fought guys with more dangerous offenses than Jinbe like Dabi and Shiggy, this is a pretty audacious claim.

Jinbe in OP is what? A low high tier? That shouldn’t be out of range of MHA top tiers.
Jinbe can't hurt Gigantomachia because he was never damaged on panel by the people who're scrubs to him? You know as well as I do why "No one ever managed to hurt him so he can't be hurt" argument doesn't work.That's some Yonko-fanboy level shit right there. Shiggy fought Machia not to kill him but to make him acknowledge him. If he was going for the kill, he'd have done it during one of Machia's sleeping sessions but that's besides the point. Dabi and Shiggy may have more dangerous abilities than Jinbe but he is far stronger. Dabi and Shiggy have more dangerous ability than Enji too. Do they get a better shot at hurting AFO's over-sized bodyguard than him? Remember Jinbe fought a fire user who can engulf towns in fire for five days.

It doesn't matter how low Jinbe ranks in OP as long as he's strong enough to beat Machina. While it's true Machina is crazy durable, his size is his greatest asset and Jinbe damaged someone 5-8 times larger than him. Just to give you a heads up, Gigantomachina is estimated to be around 25m while Wadatsumi is normally 80m tall with his puffed version being around 3 times larger. I gave you an answer to how Jinbe would deal with Machina's durability btw. Jinbe can damage him regardless of the composition of his body as long as it's made of water.
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
#17
"No one ever managed to hurt him so he can't be hurt" argument doesn't work.That's some Yonko-fanboy level shit right there.
That’s not my argument and you know it lol. My argument is that characters with offensive capability above Jinbe could not hurt Machia. More below:

Dabi and Shiggy have more dangerous ability than Enji too. Do they get a better shot at hurting AFO's over-sized bodyguard than him?
Dabi does, yes. His firepower was stated to be above Endeavor’s by Endeavor himself. Gigantomachia is far superior to Endeavor.

his size is his greatest asset and Jinbe damaged someone 5-8 times larger than him.
“Size” is not the issue, durability is. Gigantomachia is simply far too durable/resilient to be injured by Jinbe.

Jinbe can damage him regardless of the composition of his body as long as it's made of water.
There is literally no way for you to prove this.
 

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
#18
That’s not my argument and you know it lol. My argument is that characters with offensive capability above Jinbe could not hurt Machia. More below:
Dabi does, yes. His firepower was stated to be above Endeavor’s by Endeavor himself. Gigantomachia is far superior to Endeavor.

“Size” is not the issue, durability is. Gigantomachia is simply far too durable/resilient to be injured by Jinbe.

There is literally no way for you to prove this.
Aight you persistent bastard.:pepeke: I don't have the energy to type walls of text so I give up.

Dabi does, yes. His firepower was stated to be above Endeavor’s by Endeavor himself.
This statement though; I can't seem to recall it. Can you remind me where Enji says this?
 
Last edited:
Top