Questions & Mysteries Joyboy is Luffy, but Luffy is not Joyboy

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Just had a few thoughts reading 1043, and after reading so many people talk about the whole Joy boy situation.
In my opinion, Joyboy did actually exist in the void century and did whatever he did, promised what he wanted to promise and whatnot.
Luffy is Luffy, and Oda as an author has always showed an undeniable love for the character and his ideals. (The best example is when he refuses to know what the one piece is, but there are countless others.)
This said, the only point I want to make is that when Zunisha refers to Joyboy returning, he is of course referring to Luffy, but not to the fact that they are the same person, but just that they carry the same "spirit" or using the word of One Piece, Luffy carries Joy boys ideals.
I don't think that the whole reincarnation really will prove true, because I don't see Oda sacrificing 100 volumes of Luffy wanking for a twist.

 

[Pooth]

Luffy is Luffy, and Oda as an author has always showed an undeniable love for the character and his ideals.

🤣😂🤣😂

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

🤣😂🤣😂

Love to see Naruto fan showing their usual argumentative capabilities
Don't you have your bait threads to spam in?

 

[Ravagerblade]

Love to see Naruto fan showing their usual argumentative capabilities
Don't you have your bait threads to spam in?

Pooth is a small time clown. Ignore him or make fun of him.

As for joyboy, there was always somebody destined to carry the hopes and wishes of the people or whatever of 800 years ago on their backs.

 

[Pooth]

Love to see Naruto fan showing their usual argumentative capabilities
Don't you have your bait threads to spam in?

Only op fans would think luffy has ideals and character progression

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Only op fans would think luffy has ideals and character progression

Obito was truly the coolest guy, forget about world war and mass extermination. How do Naruto fan cope with their eternal delusion?

My answer is that they are actually illiterate and only look at the pictures. One example is this guy mentioning character progression when I never mentioned it in the first place! I guess I shouldn't be that surprised but yeah, Naruto fans!
:cheers:

 

[Pooth]

Obito was truly the coolest guy, forget about world war and mass extermination. How do Naruto fan cope with their eternal delusion?

An exceptional ninja too.

My answer is that they are actually illiterate and only look at the pictures. One example is this guy mentioning character progression when I never mentioned it in the first place! I guess I shouldn't be that surprised but yeah, Naruto fans!

 

[Finalbeta]

I think Luffy is not the same Joy Boy who lived hundreds of years ago, he is a reincarnation perhaps but not exactly the same individual.

There's a chance Joy Boy possessed Luffy because he is the Gomu itself, but that looks a more far fetched scenario at the moment. 🧐

 

[Ravagerblade]

Luffy is Luffy, whether he grows up or not.
Luffy may carry the history on his back and act accordingly, if that is similar to the Joyboy of the past so be it. That does not make him the past Joyboy but somebody new who has similar "Ideals" or a will.

 

[Rottkins]

I like the thought of the taking the torch of mind to the next gen of joyboys here, if you know what I mean. I think there's no such thing as reincarnation in one piece, as many people hope so and there is more like silent communication between past and present person of the same message...??? As we saw there were personas before who people think might have been past forms of a present character but I more see it as protoplasts.

Tho I clown myself all the time, if I will be wrong I will change my avi on something else what ev,,,

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

True.