General & Others Keep It a Buck: Which Fight was Better? Yonko Vs SN or Oars Vs SH Fight?

Which Fight was Better?


  • Total voters
    29
#2
Oars vs Straw hats is one of my favorite fights in one piece because of one reason: everyone was important

And not just power wise, but the combination of their abilities and intelligence was such a nice thing.

Like Chopper being able to use his medical knowledge -> Franky Usopp Brook Nami and Usopp creating a lightning arrow with brooks body from a giant slingshot -> the final attack coming down to a culmination of the straw hats strengths to break Oars’ back

The fight was a great celebration of the straw hats.

Yonko vs Supernova is cool, but it didn’t feel like a team fight as much as it felt like an NBA slam dunk contest
 
#4
Supernovas vs Yonko is better despite suffering from shit lower floor chapters interrupting it and a bit of stand around and watch individuals fight i.e. 4 supernova watching the other one use their move.

If Oda has stuck to that narrative and have the Supernova defeated 1 by 1 till it's Luffy vs Kaido the arc would have had a much better flow and end.
 
#7
SHPs vs Oars just because all the SHPs were involved in doing something meaningful (not necessarily everybody launching their strongest attacks) and that they were able to beat the enemy.

SN vs Yonko was just the Luffy and Zoro show (no complaints) but they also failed to beat the enemy.
 
#14
I think Supernova vs Yonko would be superb if:

- Oda wouldn't have off screened the important portions of their fight, like hybrid Kaido and BM, implied attacks landed on them off screen and them not being able to overcome them. I wanna see what made them think that because before that Kaido was simply eating attacks 80% of the time while the supernovas were avoiding them one way or the other. What made them think that they def need to split them. Hakai attack came afterwards.

- That opportunity could have been used to extend the fight instead of the moment they split Luffy falls down and we got what we got after that - waste of time panels.
 
#15
Oars fight was better.

Supernova vs Kaido was really a long stretch of individual cool moments without anything much in the way of choreography. It was like a turnbased battle. Also, Big Mom was weirdly ignored for most of it as everyone attacked Kaido.

Oars fight had everyone involved, was fun, had decent tactics and choreography. like Franky building a stair, Zoro’s pillarswords, the jenga towers, freezing Oars, Sanji’s chain.
 
C

CensoredbyWG

#17
Oars vs Straw hats is one of my favorite fights in one piece because of one reason: everyone was important

And not just power wise, but the combination of their abilities and intelligence was such a nice thing.

Like Chopper being able to use his medical knowledge -> Franky Usopp Brook Nami and Usopp creating a lightning arrow with brooks body from a giant slingshot -> the final attack coming down to a culmination of the straw hats strengths to break Oars’ back

The fight was a great celebration of the straw hats.

Yonko vs Supernova is cool, but it didn’t feel like a team fight as much as it felt like an NBA slam dunk contest
 
Top