Theory Koby is the last straw hat

#1
As it seems, the blackbeard arc/saga is going to be a Koby rescue arc.

Almost every single straw hat focused arc has involved Luffy saving said straw hat from the big bad of the arc. Luffy saved zoro from morgans, Sanji from Krieg, Nami from Arlong, etc.

So if this arc is going to be Luffy fighting blackbeard to save Koby, I think there's a decent chance Koby could become a straw hat. Unlike past contenders, such as Yamato and Carrot, Koby is a long running character. Someone who we have known since chapter 2 of the story. A character who is close friends with Luffy, and someone that has a dream which parallels those of the straw hats.

Furthermore, I think that its suspicious that Oda made Koby a member of SWORD. I mean what importance does SWORD actually have? Apart from Drake and Koby, there aren't any other SWORD members who are particularly notable. The one notable thing about SWORD is the fact that they carry out undercover operations.
What if the reason why Koby is a member of SWORD is because Oda intends for him to be an undercover agent on Luffy's crew. He sails with Luffy to raftel, all the while secretly hiding his allegiance to the WG. Then he learns the true history of the world, realizes the WG is evil, changes sides, and becomes Luffy's double agent.

I think this could potentially even parallel what shanks did in the roger pirates. We don't know the full story, but I think the theory that shanks poisoned roger has some credibility, especially with film red hinting that shanks is a CD.

In any case, due to how long Koby has been in the series and the amount of development he has had, in addition to the fact that he is a major character in this up coming saga, which is only just beginning, I think he at the very least deserves some recognition as a potential SH contender. At the very least, he has a better chance than a character like Yamato who was introduced in the third act of wano and didn't even meet the SHs until after the war.
 
#5
As it seems, the blackbeard arc/saga is going to be a Koby rescue arc.

Almost every single straw hat focused arc has involved Luffy saving said straw hat from the big bad of the arc. Luffy saved zoro from morgans, Sanji from Krieg, Nami from Arlong, etc.

So if this arc is going to be Luffy fighting blackbeard to save Koby, I think there's a decent chance Koby could become a straw hat. Unlike past contenders, such as Yamato and Carrot, Koby is a long running character. Someone who we have known since chapter 2 of the story. A character who is close friends with Luffy, and someone that has a dream which parallels those of the straw hats.

Furthermore, I think that its suspicious that Oda made Koby a member of SWORD. I mean what importance does SWORD actually have? Apart from Drake and Koby, there aren't any other SWORD members who are particularly notable. The one notable thing about SWORD is the fact that they carry out undercover operations.
What if the reason why Koby is a member of SWORD is because Oda intends for him to be an undercover agent on Luffy's crew. He sails with Luffy to raftel, all the while secretly hiding his allegiance to the WG. Then he learns the true history of the world, realizes the WG is evil, changes sides, and becomes Luffy's double agent.

I think this could potentially even parallel what shanks did in the roger pirates. We don't know the full story, but I think the theory that shanks poisoned roger has some credibility, especially with film red hinting that shanks is a CD.

In any case, due to how long Koby has been in the series and the amount of development he has had, in addition to the fact that he is a major character in this up coming saga, which is only just beginning, I think he at the very least deserves some recognition as a potential SH contender. At the very least, he has a better chance than a character like Yamato who was introduced in the third act of wano and didn't even meet the SHs until after the war.
Smoker is more logical than Koby (even tho I didn't see any chance for Smoker). It's just Koby's dream is to "defend justice???" And pirate can't never do that in the eye of commoner. At least Marine has to restart from the roots in the end of manga and I can see Koby is one of few who started the new era for marine.
 
#12
Koby would be a terrible addition... and might make me drop the manga

Putting aside that his character is just to be a Luffy fanboy, there are already so many crew members that Oda has to dedicate time to
 
#13
#15
Being a Straw Hat means you're a pirate. You can't be both a pirate and a marine (unless it were a double informant type of thing, I guess) and Koby's wanted to be a marine since the very beginning of the series.

He won't be the last Straw Hat. He will just be their friend.
 
#17
his character dream is to be an admiral tho
now he may fight the last commander
but he will not throw his dream away to become a strawhat pirate.


an important aspect of every crewmember joining is the fact that their goals/ dream align or can be accomplished with the rest of the crew.
Post automatically merged:

just read your op
still not buying it cause coby respects luffy as a pirate ( relayed that to xdrake as well)
the idea of infiltrating his crew to dig out anything just seems farfetched
 

Rej

Holy Simp
#18
Nah lmao

You then could argue that Garp could have been a Roger Pirate, which really never was the case, seeing how he tried to push luffy towards becomming a marine.
 
Top