I never make the decisions...tough look for you here. Your characterization feels off as well. So your basing it on amount of fluff and timing of seriousness? That can vary for many different reasons lol
If you want another reason, he just had a super role madness game where he lived to the end i think (as town?), had only 40 posts the entire game, game had 6800. He is already at 31 today. This is abnormal extreme activity lol
If I were to argue in bad faith, I'd ask you this: You're scum reading AM because he's different from last game and don't seem to care about the reasons for it, why should I care about the reasons you feel different here?