Speculations Powerscaling isn't accurate

#1
I am going to explain a situation where powerscaling is supposed to apply.

1) Two Adcoc users fight. Who wins?

2) Powerscaling suggests because both of them are capable of adcoc they are on equal terms based on feats.

3) The next powerscaling suggestion is that if both of them are capable of the above then it comes down to portrayal.

I don't believe "portrayal" actually solves it because portrayal is subject to narrative which is subjective.

It's a framework that relies on static elements rather than changing dynamics.
 
#2
If Tashigi suddenly showed adcoc, people would be saying it's setting her up to fight Zoro or Mihawk.

For real? Lol

Her "portrayal" is what? She has a backstory that aligns with Kuina's and Zoro always got his ass kicked by Kuina, so if Tashigi suddenly min/maxes Adcoc she's going to defeat Zoro?
 
Top