Speculations Predicting the SHs vs BPs matchups

#1
Luffy vs BB - the captains, and extremely obvious
Zoro vs Shiryu - swordsmen, also extremely obvious
Nami vs Lafitte - navigators, and also noble burglar vs corrupt cop
Usopp vs Van Augur - snipers, also extremely obvious
Sanji vs 10th Titanic Captain - no one else really fits with Sanji for now. The 10th Captain should be really strong in order to justify the mystery around him
Chopper vs Doc Q - doctors, and also extremely obvious
Robin vs San Juan Wolf - we don’t know Wolf’s role in the crew iirc, but Robin being able to create giant versions of herself means that she could be the best fit to take on the giant
Franky vs Avalo Pizarro - we don’t know Pizarro’s role in the crew, but iirc he does some have mechanical gauntlets on him.
Brook vs Vasco Shot - no one else really fits for Brook right now
Jinbe vs Burgess - both helmsmen, and also martial artist vs wrestler
Yamato vs Catarina Devon - women
 
#2
Luffy vs teach:Captains
Zoro vs Shiryu:He is oden's BB,strongest commander
Nami vs Devon:smart vs trick
Ussop vs Auger:snipers
Sanji vs Burguess:he is 1st commander,but second stronger,besides his relation with shiryu doesn't seem well cause shiryu called him idiot after Dressrosa
Chopper vs Doc q:Doctors
Robin vs Wolf:big giant and fat,i wonder how robin will deal with him maybe "demonio"is not enough
Franky vs Vasco
Brook vs laffite:both can create music,both from the west,sheriff demon vs death
Yamato vs Pizarro:if he has a cat fruit
 
#5
I agree with most of OP

Katarina prolly fights Nami imo. Katarina is a serial killer who disfigures pretty women. Robin and Yamato r by no means ugly, but neither have had beauty mentioned as much as Nami. Also both r much more fighters than Nami, the psychological torture of Catarina trying to disfigure them wont hit as hard as against Nami.

Avalo likely has a cat DF, that alone sets up the Dog/Cat dynamic between him and Yamato. Less likely but still possible is him him being Jack's predecessor.

Latiff and Brook share a similar motif and fighting styles.

Vasco being with Franky is the weakest link rn. Both r brawlers. Maybe he uses alcohol similar to Franky's cola?
 

Finalbeta

Science Nerd 🌌 🌍 🧬 ⚛️
#6
Luffy vs BB - the captains, and extremely obvious
Zoro vs Shiryu - swordsmen, also extremely obvious
Nami vs Lafitte - navigators, and also noble burglar vs corrupt cop
Usopp vs Van Augur - snipers, also extremely obvious
Sanji vs 10th Titanic Captain - no one else really fits with Sanji for now. The 10th Captain should be really strong in order to justify the mystery around him
Chopper vs Doc Q - doctors, and also extremely obvious
Robin vs San Juan Wolf - we don’t know Wolf’s role in the crew iirc, but Robin being able to create giant versions of herself means that she could be the best fit to take on the giant
Franky vs Avalo Pizarro - we don’t know Pizarro’s role in the crew, but iirc he does some have mechanical gauntlets on him.
Brook vs Vasco Shot - no one else really fits for Brook right now
Jinbe vs Burgess - both helmsmen, and also martial artist vs wrestler
Yamato vs Catarina Devon - women
Yamato vs Catarina is also a match up fitting Catarina's portrayal as one of the strongest women around I guess.

By the way perhaps Lafitte will be tackled by Brook because it really does swiftly fit their fighting style.
 
#7
Luffy vs BB - the captains, and extremely obvious
Zoro vs Shiryu - swordsmen, also extremely obvious
Nami vs Lafitte - navigators, and also noble burglar vs corrupt cop
Usopp vs Van Augur - snipers, also extremely obvious
Sanji vs 10th Titanic Captain - no one else really fits with Sanji for now. The 10th Captain should be really strong in order to justify the mystery around him
Chopper vs Doc Q - doctors, and also extremely obvious
Robin vs San Juan Wolf - we don’t know Wolf’s role in the crew iirc, but Robin being able to create giant versions of herself means that she could be the best fit to take on the giant
Franky vs Avalo Pizarro - we don’t know Pizarro’s role in the crew, but iirc he does some have mechanical gauntlets on him.
Brook vs Vasco Shot - no one else really fits for Brook right now
Jinbe vs Burgess - both helmsmen, and also martial artist vs wrestler
Yamato vs Catarina Devon - women
Don’t really believe it but just to put different opinion out there:
Luffy vs BB
Smoker vs Aokiji
Sabo vs Burgess
Zoro vs Shiryu
Usopp vs Van Augur
Nami vs Avalo Pizarro
Sanji vs Lafitte
Franky vs Sanjuan Wolf
Robin vs Catarina Devon
Brook vs Vasco Shot
Chopper vs Doc Q
Vivi vs Crocodile the tenth titanic captain
Yamato vs Moriah
Jinbe vs Whitebeard Jr.

Bring it on
 
Last edited:
#8
I agree with most of OP

Katarina prolly fights Nami imo. Katarina is a serial killer who disfigures pretty women. Robin and Yamato r by no means ugly, but neither have had beauty mentioned as much as Nami. Also both r much more fighters than Nami, the psychological torture of Catarina trying to disfigure them wont hit as hard as against Nami.

Avalo likely has a cat DF, that alone sets up the Dog/Cat dynamic between him and Yamato. Less likely but still possible is him him being Jack's predecessor.

Latiff and Brook share a similar motif and fighting styles.

Vasco being with Franky is the weakest link rn. Both r brawlers. Maybe he uses alcohol similar to Franky's cola?
Devon makes a lot of sense for Nami, but I favor Lafitte more because it would make sense for Oda to pair the characters who have the same role in the crew, and also Lafitte was described as being a corrupt cop in the past, which juxtaposes with Nami being a noble burglar prior to becoming a SH. Also, Lafitte has been treated as one of the most prominent BBPs, and Nami is one of the most prominent SHs, with Oda describing her, Luffy, and Zoro as the pillars of OP
Post automatically merged:

Devon and Yamato also both have mythical Dog Zoans
 

Sanji D Goat

𝔓𝔯𝔦𝔫𝔠𝔢𝔰𝔰
#10
The only way for me to accept Sanji vs 10th Titanic Captain is if he's Gin. Other than that, I don't see why Sanji would fight the 10th when guys like Lafitte or Avalo is around.
 
#14
Lafitte and Shiryu seem to be a duo, like King and Queen and Jabra and Kaku. Pizarro is a former North Blue King, Oda could easily write a plotline that connects Pizarro and the Vinsmokes.

10th Captain will fight Yamato.
Yamato vs Devon makes too much sense. Both females, and mythical Dog Zoan vs mythical Dog Zoan. Yamato also has an identity crisis, while Devon can turn into literally anyone
 
#17
Luffy vs Blackbeard
Zoro vs Shiryu
Sanji vs Avalo Pizzaro (North Blue king Germa connection, Level 6 Prisoner so likely one of the stronger fighters)
Jinbei vs Vasco Shot (Stronger/Dangerous enough to be a level 6 Prisoner) can also see Jinbei vs Sanjuan Wolf with Wadatsumi vibes)
Franky vs Burgess (Macho man matchup, it shocks me so little see this)
Brook vs Laffite (Skinny Musician vs Skinny tap dancer sword vs cane will be a fan favorite fight for sure)
Nami vs Catarina Devon (Devon steals the faces of beautiful women, Nami should spark her interest, girl fight)
Chopper vs Doc Q (The good Doctor vs the Doctor who poisons patients)
Usopp vs Van Auger (Sniper battle, another fan favorite)
Yamato or Carrot + Momonosuke vs San Juan Wolf (New young Member tag team duo vs the big guy) Also maybe Vasco Shot instead
Robin vs Aokiji (Not really a fight more of a I can't allow BB to get his hands on you exchange/conversation about trusting Luffy

Other potential matchups

Jinbei vs Weevil
Smoker vs Vasco Shot or Tenth Titanic Captain
Carrot or Yamato vs Tenth Titanic Captain
 
#18
Luffy vs BB
Zoro vs Aokiji
Sanji vs Jesus diamond df or Avalo
Yamato vs Shiryu
Jinbe vs Vasco
Ribin vs San Juan Wolf Or Catarina
Brook vs Lafite
Franky vs Jesus no df or Avalo
Usopp vs Auger
Chopper vs Doc Q
Nami vs San Juan Wolf Or Catarina
 
#19
Luffy vs BB
Zoro vs Aokiji
Sanji vs Jesus diamond df or Avalo
Yamato vs Shiryu
Jinbe vs Vasco
Ribin vs San Juan Wolf Or Catarina
Brook vs Lafite
Franky vs Jesus no df or Avalo
Usopp vs Auger
Chopper vs Doc Q
Nami vs San Juan Wolf Or Catarina
Aokiji is not an official member of the BB pirates.:kobeha:

He's only affliated with them for unknown reasons.




Besides, Zoro has no beef with Kuzan and Kuzan expressed himself multiple times that he doesnt wanna fight the Strawhats.
 
#20
Aokiji is not an official member of the BB pirates.:kobeha:

He's only affliated with them for unknown reasons.




Besides, Zoro has no beef with Kuzan and Kuzan expressed himself multiple times that he doesnt wanna fight the Strawhats.
Can’t wait for Smoker vs Kuzan!
Luffy becoming the strongest pirate and Smoker becoming the strongest marine at the same time!
 
Top