Current Events Rank the Alliance members from most important to least important on the battlefield

#5
I'm interested in how people believe Sanji's performance hold up to Marco's,Killer's or Yamato's
Sure Sanji who defeated a Calamity and armies of Headliners and Gifters, saved Momonoskuke,Chopper....and reinstalled the samurai faith has worse performance than Killer who did nothing but defeat Hawkins. Yamato....whos done nothing. And Marco....who just stalled.

Marco literally called Sanji the star. This is sad
 
#9
Sure Sanji who defeated a Calamity and armies of Headliners and Gifters, saved Momonoskuke,Chopper....and reinstalled the samurai faith has worse performance than Killer who did nothing but defeat Hawkins. Yamato....whos done nothing. And Marco....who just stalled.

Marco literally called Sanji the star. This is sad
I think it's an interesting debate which is why I made the thread.
Yamato did stall Kaido alone for 15 chapters, Marco did stall King&Queen and later King for around 25 chapters, Killer did fight on the Rooftop and enable Kid and Law to take out BM.
 
#11
I'm interested in how people believe Sanji's performance hold up to Marco's,Killer's or Yamato's
Cook is probably the fourth most relevant out of the group that did not make it to the rooftop, but his biggest contribution is really saving Momoron in the beginning of the raid.

Cook's relevancy is obviously below the Supernova Captains's, which automatically means it is below Zoro's. We can agree that Killer beating Hawkins directly improved Kidd and Law's chances of taking down Big Mom, which outweighs Cook beating Queen, since Queen was harmless by himself after 997, as evidenced by losing too many soldiers via betraying them, and is really only relevant because King hard carried him on the live floor. This means Chopper is, too, more relevant than Cook.

Lolda wanked Otameh and Momoron endlessly, so Cook is not as relevant as they are, sadly. Also, Marco held the floor better and longer than Cook did.

So:

1. Zoro (obvious)
2. Luffy
3. Law
4. Kidd
5. Killer
6. Yamato
7. Marco
8. Otameh
9. Chopper
10. Momoron
11. Cook

:cheers:
 
#14
I think it's an interesting debate which is why I made the thread.
Yamato did stall Kaido alone for 15 chapters, Marco did stall King&Queen and later King for around 25 chapters, Killer did fight on the Rooftop and enable Kid and Law to take out BM.
Stalling is worthless. She didnt do any damage. Same with Marco.

At the very least Sanji saved important allaince members, and took down Queen.....who is probably the bigggest threat to te allaince after the Yonkos.

Killer literally did nothing at all. I dont even know why hes in this argument. Saving Midd, who was practically useless ismt anything.
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#15
It's unarguably zoro
Zoro saved everyone if zoro get the antidote of apoo
All of Marco and choppers work after is useless as well as a lot of tamas dango and a load of people would be dead

If queen still had his plague gun he could have spread more plagues

Zoro on the roof

Saved all 4 of the others so what ever they do after is thanks to zoro
Especially luffy who he saved multiple times

Once again if not for zoro

King and queen who already beat Marco and sanji would have massacred everyone in the live floor and eventually helped meme kill kidd and law when they got to the live floor
 
#16
Not narratively
Just in term of war contribution

Here are notable names

-Luffy
-Zoro
-Kid
-Law
-Killer
-Yamato
-Marco
-Sanji
-Jinbe
-Chopper (antidote)
-Tama (hax power)
Pretty much this order but would switch Kid for Law, he's up there with Zoro would say in contribution. Remember he switched them away also from hakai as well, otherwise Zoro stalling the attack wouldn't matter they would get bodied regardless, and an immense contribution at bringing down BM's defenses.
 
#17
Momonosuke (if he dies the War ends, also saving onigashima from blowing)
Luffy (without him now there wouldn't be any chances of defeating Kaido, as It was said in the manga if Kaido would have been capable of reaching the live floor now they would all be dead)
Law/Kidd (Defeating a Yonko, nothing more to say. Without them Luffy wouldn't have been able to focus on Kaido)
Yamato (stalled Kaido, as I said before if this didn't happen then her father would have reached the live floor and murder everyone).
Zoro (protected Luffy, took the medicine, defeated a calamity, could be placed higher, especially if he stalls Evil Sanji :cheers:)
Sanji (saved Momonosuke, protected Luffy alongside Jinbe until rooftop, saved Zoro, defeated the Calamity Queen)
Marco (stalled Big Mom, stalled King and Queen until Zoro recovered)
Killer (helped Kidd, defeated Hawkins)
Robin (saved Sanji, defeated a Tobi roppo)
Jinbe (helped Luffy to reach rooftop alongside Sanji, defeated a Tobi roppo)
Chopper (for obvious reasons)
 

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
#20
Zoro >
Without zoro they wouldn't get the antidote the live floor would be decimated
Queen would still have his plague gun
Everyone on the roof dies to hakai
Luffy dies multiple times
Live floor gets massacred by king and queen


Marco and law have done bits too
TBF without Chopper, that antidote cures one person and the live floor dies. And without Marco, Chopper might not make it either.
 
Top