General & Others Rate Every One Piece Arc Post Timeskip so far

[pg13]

0=Trash/Worst Arc in The Series
5=Mid/Mediocre/Avg
10=Perfect/Peak/Best Arc in The Series

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 4.5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 7/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 6.7/10
Wano Arc - 7.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

Elbaf - TBD but so far 8.1/10


Drop Your Ratings Below

 

[ZenZu]

Fishman Island - 4/10
Punk Hazard - 5/10
Dressrosa - 5/10
Zou - 7/10
Wholecake Island - 3/10
Wano Arc - 2/10
Egghead - 6.5/10

 

[MUUGEN]

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 4.5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 7/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 6.7/10
Wano Arc - 7.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

Elbaf - TBD but so far 8.1/10

FMI 2/5
PH 3.5/5
DR 3/5
Zou 2.5/5
WCI 3.75/5
Wano 3/5
EH 4/5
Elbaf 5/5

 

[Franosuke]

@lee33

 

[Fn Lucci]

For reference: East Blue, Alabasta, Jaya/Skypiea, and DBF/Water Seven would be at 10 as the kind of arcs that make the series.

Fishman Island Arc - 6/10
Punk Hazard Arc - 7/10
Dressrosa Arc - 8/10
Zou- 8.5/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7/10
Wano Arc - 6/10
Egghead Island Arc - 6/10

Overall still pretty good but so many particularly shitty spots. Elbaf is kinda ass

 

[NikaInParis]

Fishman Island Arc - 3/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 5/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 10/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7/10
Wano Arc - 5.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 8/10

 

[Wanderer]

Fishman Island Arc - 4/10 (just bad and boring acr, but atleast have a great flashback and good art)
Punk Hazzard Arc - 6/10 (could be hier, but too long, too tedious, to much Law and to little SH)
Dressrosa Arc - 7,5/10
Zou- 8,5/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 9/10
Wano Arc - 7/10
Egghead Island Arc - 0/10 (not trash, but worst arc in the series)

Elbaf - TBD but so far 5,5/10 (Rocks flashback is saving the day, the rest is really bad)

 

[Yakyu]

Fishman Island - 5/10 (great for lore, flashback and Luffy/Jimbe scene, but the worst group of enemies and pacing were pure pain)
Punk Hazard - 6/10
Dressrosa - 6/10
Zou - 8/10
Wholecake Island - 7/10 (wedding cake shit hurt this arc so freaking much bro)
Wano Arc - 7/10 (Oda stalled WAY more than any other arc and we had the whole "I'm Oden" shit from Yamato)
Egghead - 8/10

 

[MonsterKaido]

Fishman Island Arc - 2/10
Punk Hazzard Arc - 8/10
Dressrosa Arc - 6/10
Zou- 10/10
Wholecake Island Arc - 7/10
Wano Arc - 6.5/10
Egghead Island Arc - 9/10

Elbaf - 10/10 so far

 

[Uncle Van]

Fishman Island
Thematic Storytelling 8/10
Characters 2/10
Execution 4/10
Overall 4.5/10

Punk Hazard
Thematic Storytelling 4/10
Characters 7/10
Execution 7/10
Overall 6/10

Dressrosa
Thematic Storytelling 10/10
Characters 3/10
Execution 6/10
Overall 6.5/10

Zou
Thematic Storytelling 7/10
Characters 8/10
Execution 10/10
Overall 8/10

Whole Cake Island
Thematic Storytelling 8/10
Characters 8/10
Execution 4/10
Overall 7/10

Wano
Thematic Storytelling 10/10
Characters 4/10
Execution 2/10
Overall 5/10

Egghead
Thematic Storytelling 6/10
Characters 5/10
Execution 1/10
Overall 4/10

 

[Sir Yasheen]

FMI - 5/10
Punk Hazard - 5/10
Dressrosa - 7/10
Zou - 7/10
WCI - 8/10
Wano - 3/10
Egghead - 6/10

 

[Senfret]

Overall One piece is an 8.9 in my opinion