Questions & Mysteries Something about Kaidou is not consistent, plot hole?

[stealthblack]

So he kld all crew of moria and broke him and now we got to wano and see that he lets everyone survive and and offers them to join his crew. and even if they don't want to, he keeps them in prison to break their will until they give up and join his crew. so why was oda not consistent with this?
ì

even now after he defeated zolo and luffy on the roof, he offered all 7000 allies to join him

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Because now he is going to war against the marines and the WG, it's better to have some more allies than to lose some men which will happen if the fights goes on.
There are a bunch of capable men on the alliance, to have them on his side would be a good thing for him.

Many years ago, he had different plans, he was starting to settle down in Wano.

 

[Finalbeta]

Yeah it perfectly sticks with the idea of the Smile Factory Doffy was generating for him

 

[Fn Lucci]

Because this manpower is on the table. At the time he was severely set back himself, without the foothold in Wano he now has or an ally in Linlin.

 

[Master OF Haki]

So he kld all crew of moria and broke him and now we got to wano and see that he lets everyone survive and and offers them to join his crew. and even if they don't want to, he keeps them in prison to break their will until they give up and join his crew. so why was oda not consistent with this?
ì

even now after he defeated zolo and luffy on the roof, he offered all 7000 allies to join him

Because this time he's fighting against the main characters, so the plot armor stops Kaido from killing them all.

 

[mugiwalaw]

to break people spirit is Queen's job not Kaido, as we can see in Udon, if those prisoners are not obeying then death pinalty awaits, we almost got Luffy, Hyo, Kid and Killer being killed by Queens game.

 

[Celestial D. Dragon]

Or, Moriah and his crew refused to join Kaido, and Kaido couldn't break Moriah's spirit, so Kaido killed his crew?

 

[Roo]

plot armor

 

[Herrera95]

Lot of things in One Piece are inconsistent. This is just another one.

 

[serkeara]

Kaido is just a tsundere.

Outside: I will smash his head, break his will, kill him, and show the world how brutal I am Worororo!

Inside: OMG I LOVE LUFFY SO MUCH. I NEED TO SEND HIM TO TRAIN MORE SO WE CAN HAVE SOME MORE FUN LIKE FATHER AND SON, AND MAYBE HE DON'T WANT TO LEAVE ME.

 

[Finalbeta]

Kaido is just a tsundere.

Outside: I will smash his head, break his will, kill him, and show the world how brutal I am Worororo!

Inside: OMG I LOVE LUFFY SO MUCH. I NEED TO SEND HIM TO TRAIN MORE SO WE CAN HAVE SOME MORE FUN LIKE FATHER AND SON, AND MAYBE HE DON'T WANT TO LEAVE ME.

 

[Roo]

I don’t get why Oda couldn’t just kill off Kid’s crew. Aside from Killer they don’t do anything and you could just have more people join his crew after the war

 

[KiriNigiri]

Kaido prefers to break the wills of those he finds worthy. I imagine Moria was the only one he was interested in recruiting, so he killed his crew to make him compliant.

 

[Formerly Seth]

So he kld all crew of moria and broke him and now we got to wano and see that he lets everyone survive and and offers them to join his crew. and even if they don't want to, he keeps them in prison to break their will until they give up and join his crew. so why was oda not consistent with this?
ì

even now after he defeated zolo and luffy on the roof, he offered all 7000 allies to join him

Flashbacks have different logic to them, you must understand this.

Action that takes place without Straw Hats either in the past or the present has almost a 100% chance to be more brutal and radical.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

He probably saw no potential in moriahs crew and killed them in hopes of breaking Moriah.