Character Discussion Strawhat Pirates vs Red Hair Pirates

#1
I think at this point Oda created a very strong similarity between Roger Pirates, Red Hair Pirates and Strawhat Pirates.
All three these crew share having relatively small numbers (low quantity for high quality), their captain owning the famed (and fated?) straw hat, their first mate being a strong badass motherfucker who is close to his captain in both strength and behaviors.

The parallel between Roger Pirates and Strawhats is well known (Roger -> Luffy, Rayleigh -> Zoro, Oden -> Yamato, Gaban -> Sanji, Sunbell -> Jinbe, Seagull -> Franky, Crocus -> Chopper and so on).
After the latest movie we have official confirmed infos and elements to make a parallel between Red Hair Pirates and Strawhats as well.



Shanks -> Luffy

Obvious. Same role as the crew's captain. Very similar behavior (except Shanks's mysterious and ambiguous side, they act the same, being jovial and casual in every situation but becoming demons when their friends are threatened). Conqueror Haki. The hat and what not.







Benn Beckman -> Zoro

Obvious as well. Same as the close and trusted captain's right-hand man with a Sun/Moon dynamic. Same stoic behavior. Both have immensely powerful attack power and Haki (does Benn have CoC and Adv CoC as well?).
They are canonically paired together many times, between the latest movie and other issues.









Lucky Loo -> Sanji

I mean could Oda be more obvious than this? Both cooks. Both strong legs. Both are not good with women despite being interested in them.





Yasopp -> Usopp

Father and son. Sniper and sniper. CoO talent and CoO talent. Nothing else to say, the parallel is just blatant.
Well, if not for the fact that Yasopp is very strong and the third strongest in Red Hair Pirates, while Usopp is relatively weak and basically the weakest member of the Strawhats...







Monster -> Chopper

You could literally copy paste Monster's description to Chopper as animals who behave as humans and wounded with them, and it would still work perfectly. And the opposite as well.



@Finalbeta @T.D.A @Zowo @yorosenpai @ConquistadoR @Fenaker @The White Crane @kumae @Geo @Sentinel @Orojackson Refugee @Peroroncino @Redboy776 @Rekien @Sword God Ryuma @nik87 @Manos. AsuraZoro @bennbeckman @mly90 @Akagami Law @style @Sanji D Goat @Marimo_420 @Shishi @Geo @Money D Malio @ShadowStyle369 @matt245
 
#2
being a cook doesn't matter much for fighting. i think sanji's counterpart will be the tenth redhair officer. wait, they have only 9! yes, someone else will join: marco. i made a video about it:
 
#3
First of all as of now i cant find a reason that they will fight.

Second the main crew of RHP portrayed much stronger than the likes of nami,chopper,brook,usopp.

Third i cant imagine Usopp going for the "kill" against his father and even if lets say fight and manage to defeat him i cant buy it because Yasopp has been portrayed as strong guy overall and that he is not depends only in his rifles. Usopp on the other hand after 25 fucking years is portaryed as a weakling thanks to Oda.
 
#4
being a cook doesn't matter much for fighting. i think sanji's counterpart will be the tenth redhair officer. wait, they have only 9! yes, someone else will join: marco. i made a video about it:
Well being the third strongest and a cook who has strong legs and fails with woman really seems the perfect match up for Sanji
This description literally copypastes Sanji's

Also Marco is definitely too powerful to be compared with Sanjj... maybe at EoS but not now

First of all as of now i cant find a reason that they will fight.

Second the main crew of RHP portrayed much stronger than the likes of nami,chopper,brook,usopp.

Third i cant imagine Usopp going for the "kill" against his father and even if lets say fight and manage to defeat him i cant buy it because Yasopp has been portrayed as strong guy overall and that he is not depends only in his rifles. Usopp on the other hand after 25 fucking years is portaryed as a weakling thanks to Oda.
I didn't say they have to fight
Just that they compare

Also they could fight for a Davy Back Fight
Another reason they could fight is that Shanks is seemingly interested in competing for the One Piece

Agree that the gap between Yasopp and Usopp is abysmal
 
#5
Well being the third strongest and a cook who has strong legs and fails with woman really seems the perfect match up for Sanji
This description literally copypastes Sanji's

Also Marco is definitely too powerful to be compared with Sanjj... maybe at EoS but not now
i don't think he is the third strongest. at marineford, anime only, the match ups between rhp and bbp were shown, ordered from weakest to strongest. limejuice came before beckman.

lucky roux is goofy, uses his whole body and eats alot. franky is goofy, uses his whole enhanced body and drinks alot of cola.
 
#6
Zoro - Ben Beckman - Coby
Jinbei - Lucky Roo - Helmeppo
Everyone knows that Coby and Helmeppo are flying through the marines ranks because they're the Chinese version of Luffy and Zoro, these 2 trios were shown together in the movie.
 
#8
Oda already foreshadow zoro vs beckman when he fought the gunman in skypia he is #2 like zoro and was portrayed with him in the film
 
Top