Speculations The balance of powers is the reason why the World Government exists

#1
With the revelation of Imu and the Gorosei's strength, as well as characters such as the holy knights, a lot of fans are coming to the realization that the balance of powers is fake. Yes, the yonko never stood a chance against the WG. However, the balance of powers was never about the dynamic between the Yonko and the WG. No, it was about the balance between the Yonko and the Marines.

For as long as we have known about the balance, we have known that the WG was much stronger. This is evident by the fact that forces like Cipher Pol and the armies of the WG kingdoms are not included in the balance of powers. So why is the balance of powers important?

A lot of people have came to the conclusion that the WG allows the yonko to exist because the existence of the yonko prevents any single power from obtaining the 4 road poneglyphs and becoming Pirate King. While there might be some truth to this, this isn't the full truth.

The fact of the matter is, the balance of powers is quintessential to the survival of the world government. It is a core part of the WG's "business model" so to speak.

The existence of piracy forces nations to continue to pay the heavenly tribute in exchange for protection under the world government, protection dealt out by the marines. If there was no balance of powers, if Imu and the Gorosei came down and killed all of the yonko, then there would no longer be a reason for any country to pay the heavenly tribute. If the world was at peace, there would be no need for a world government.

The balance of powers is essentially an eternal war between the forces of the marines and the pirates. The pirates are just dangerous enough for the nations to continue paying the heavenly tribute, and the marines are just strong enough to maintain the people's trust in the WG.

But with Luffy actively destroying the yonko, he is threatening Imu's rule by taking away the pressures that force nations to subordinate themselves to the WG.
 
#2
Ehhh, that may sound nice. But not really the case based on statements from the Gorosei themselves. The purpose of the 3 powers balance is to keep stability. Stability allows control. And control allows you to reign supreme. The creation of the 3 powers balance was a result of what Roger did with starting the Great Era of Piracy, which made the seas chaotic.

Thee World Government doesn't really need to create any extra threat to get the heavenly tribute. They literally bully nations into paying them that. And if you don't pay it, then GG you're fucked by the WG itself. Countries have collapsed due to the Heavenly Tribute. Kings kill their own citizens if they fail to pay the Heavenly Tribute.



More detailed explanation:

The seas all around the world were fucked up after Whitebeard's death due to his words. Pirates and criminals were raiding everywhere on the seas. So much as that the Marine HQ didn't even have the top dogs there to address Luffy/Ray/Jinbei coming there. Countries Albasta were getting raided. Goa Kingdom was getting raided. It was pure Chaos.



As a reaction to that Chaos, Saint Ethan Baron says that the Three Great Powers cannot be depended on any longer. Why? Cause the world went to shit despite them.


So what is the World Government's counter? Granting the Marines the unprecedented of the World Military Draft. Which led to the Marine HQ being FAR MORE POWERFUL than ever before.



And the 2nd counter to that Chaos due to the Three Great Powers not being dependable was...The Seraphim project.


3rd counter to the chaos due to the 3powers not being dependable was.... the one we just found out about this chapter, that they had been working on.


Hence why Saint Shepard and Saint Ethan Baron talk about how the above weapon would allow them to essentially put an instant end to any protracted conflict.


3 Power Balance = Result of the Chaos of Great Age of Piracy.

Seraphim/Big Weapon/World Draft = Result of the Chaos from the MF war's impact.


It's a tool that's there to prevent Chaos on the seas and allow better control over them. Because... taking a scene from KINGDOM here. Just as Ouki told Shin to take General Fuuki's head among the chaos that would be there due to the clash between Fuuki's army & the left Qin army....


It makes it easier for somebody to go after the OP and thus then go after the CD themselves if there is Chaos on the seas and the CD are dealing with fuck ton of things. It would give somebody like Luffy's father the perfect opportunity to hit em.

But.... the 3 powers balance prevented that Chaos around the world.... until Marineford War that is.
 
Last edited:
#4
Pirate is controlled opposition. WG make pirate and Marine fight each other with classic divide and conquer. So that wg can rule the world by taking advantage of this eternal divide. Look at real world. Black vs white. Woman vs man. Country vs country The government use this great distraction so that people don't question their corruption and such
 
Top