General & Others The way of the Samurai and Completion in Death

#1
I think we've reached the point in Kaido's characterisation where we can piece together some of his prominent traits, both good and bad.

Kaido says he admires the Way of the samurai and sees death as the completion of a man. It's assumed his admiration for the way of the samurai, Bushido, includes the death practices in it. Such as Seppuku or 1v1 honorable duels or death in Grand battles immortalising a Samurai's legacy. Kaido is introduced trying to commit suicide so you could say it's Seppuku. He's applauded as the undisputed king of "1v1 battles". And he's obsessed with going out in a blaze of glory in a a great world war.

So Kaido is Japanophile weeb right? No. He's wrong. Because of course he is. He's the villain. He's supposed to be wrong. Oden and the Vassals follow Bushido so their enemy can't also be following Bushido or else we would have a way more complicated conflict.

Kaido romanticises the Final part of Bushido, the dying, without caring about everything else. He doesn't care about honor, or justice or self mastery (I means he's an alcoholic for god sake) self discipline, meditation, and everything else that makes Bushido an entire life philosophy and NOT just a death code.

Kaido's the equivalent of the guy who reads about Musashi Miyamoto and his legendary duels and his fame thousands of years after his death and doesn't recognise that Miyamoto had a whole life outside of just the legends and his immortality after death. And that whole life is also encompassed by Bushido. It's an entire life philosophy and kaido only sees the death part because it supposedly cements everlasting legacy.

I first saw an idea that Kaido is focusing on death instead of life from Mr Morj's video about Kaido wanting a Roger like legacy without actually putting in the leg work to be like Roger. This latest chapter makes it even more clear, Kaido probably literally CANNOT do it.

Kaido was denied a big honorable 1v1 duel against Oden when Higarashi interfered and kaido 20 years ago was too scared to try fighting Oden again so he executed him. Now though he's entirely full of regret because he believes there cannot be a more worthy enemy to have died to than Oden (including the Emperors).

Kaido is an alcoholic so already he cannot pull off self discipline at all (Note that Zoro is a heavy drinker but Not an alcoholic, he's never even been shown actually drunk before).

Kaido is also a pirate and he can't stop being one so already honor and justice are out of the window since his form of piracy is clearly incompatible with such things.

Kaido cannot become a samurai even though he admires them so he just cheats and jumps to great Legacies in death that Samurai achieve even though it's impossible to get the legacy without the actual Way of Samurai itself.

It's even interesting that Ryuma, a samurai, exists as one of the oldest characters known by name in the verse because his legacy was so great yet Rocks, Kaidos's former captain, from just 40 years ago is practically an unknown in the verse. Interestingly, Ryuma is not only remembered for his strength but his sense of justice in protecting Wano while Rocks could've easily been the strongest in the verse but his supposed heinous crimes were so severe they were wiped from history. And this isn't even just a World government thing, Joyboy still has a legacy despite the government trying to silence him too so if Rocks was really worthy, he would've had a real legacy as well. But he wasn't (Even Teach who supposedly carries this legacy WILL FAIL because it's a bad legacy from a bad man). He was an unjust man so when the government silenced him, he was truly silenced. Unlike just men like Ryuma, Joyboy or Roger.

This is a very interesting idea Oda is doing with New world villains. Giving them seemingly great ambitions but giving them severe character flaws that make their ambitions impossible. Big mom wants Racial equality but ONLY through her eyes. Hody wants to stop fishman oppression but by race wars. Doffy wants to destroy the celestial dragons but by killing everyone so the celestials have no one to rule. Kaido wants Great Legacies in the deaths of Good men but he's a bad man and doesn't realise bad men don't get great Legacies in this verse. (Even the supposed final villain Imu, DOES NOT have a legacy at all, he/she is completely unknown because that's the only way Injustice can thrive, being hidden)
 
#3
only few knows judt like joyboy.
It's assumed the entire Will of d and even the one piece ties to joy boy given Roger talks about joy boy on Raftel.

So you could easily say all that is Joyboy's legacy.

So far ONLY blackbeard has even been hinted to be pursuing Rock's will and the problem is that he'll fail. He's a villain and villains fail.

There are no "bad" inherited wills in this story. The closest to that in this series is Big mom and Mother caramel and even then you can clearly see how messed up that is compared to something as simple as let's say Zoro inheriting kuina's will.

Stuff like Bellamy trying to follow under Doffy never works out because Doffy is a bad guy and bad guys don't create ideologies that just stand on their on

Even guys like Hody we first thought got thir racism from somewhere but nope. Turns oy Hody is jus a psychopath.
 
#4
It's assumed the entire Will of d and even the one piece ties to joy boy given Roger talks about joy boy on Raftel.

So you could easily say all that is Joyboy's legacy.

So far ONLY blackbeard has even been hinted to be pursuing Rock's will and the problem is that he'll fail. He's a villain and villains fail.

There are no "bad" inherited wills in this story. The closest to that in this series is Big mom and Mother caramel and even then you can clearly see how messed up that is compared to something as simple as let's say Zoro inheriting kuina's will.

Stuff like Bellamy trying to follow under Doffy never works out because Doffy is a bad guy and bad guys don't create ideologies that just stand on their on

Even guys like Hody we first thought got thir racism from somewhere but nope. Turns oy Hody is jus a psychopath.
Will just means your legacy lives on. People been failing for 800 years
 
#5
Will just means your legacy lives on. People been failing for 800 years
But will Rocks will survive after blackbeard fails?

I was wrong about one thing. Let me explain

I think the problem with bad ideologies is that they always seem so contained.

For example the Duffy family follows Doffy because he's the one providing for them and they work directly under him so his ideology naturally sips into them. Like Senior Pink got validated for wearing baby clothes when Doffy decided to kill everyone who laughed at him. But what would've happened if Doffy wasn't there?

Like what if Pink went out with his baby clothes on a whole other island. It's possible that he'll get empathy like from Franky or he'll get laughed at. But in the end he'll have to decide on his own how to react. He"ll decide whether to take that empathy or ridicule and deal with the consequences. Whereas when he's under Doffy, Doffy decides for him how the situation is handled. Doffy decided you die for laughing at him so Pink just took that as the truth.

That's why Bellamy having gone to sky island was completely changed. His ideas of Doffy were the only ones different from every other follower because he wasn't just inside Dpffy's orbit all the time. He left and saw the world and decided that he couldn't just kill Luffy despite Doffy's orders.

That's the thing with bad ideologies turning into legacies. They always require this close mindedness. Kaido cannot see past death that maybe the rest of Bushido is worth striving for. Momma can't see past her own self importance when trying to end racism. And so the followers of momma and kaido pick up their beliefs by being in the vicinity of these people and the close mindedness spreads to everyone making it seem like they are inheriting a will but instead they are being brainwashed.

I was wrong when I said there are no bad inherited wills in the story. There's one. It's the Celestial dragons. They are entirely of the belief that they are gods and have thought that for 800 years.

But that's where the brainwashing comes in. They have to be isolated and completely free from consequences and laws so that they can never question anything. They are more so brainwashed than them inheriting a strong will. And that's why Mjorsgard having ONE genuine interaction with a fishman completely change his world view. The moment he was shown out of the brainwashing circle, it was over.

I think that's what separates inherited will from these bad ideologies. People can fail at both but only inherited will passes on even further because they are good ideologies that can stand without brainwashing.

There's nothing that can break Zoro's promise to Kuina even fighting and losing to mihawk yet one punch from Luffy and a trip to skypiea changed Bellamy completely
 
Top