Questions & Mysteries Was God Valley cake walk for Roger? Were Rocks pirates that trash?

[kurwa]

In film red we see 1 year old Shanks' POV, meaning at least Rayleigh and Scopper were with Roger in God Valley:

Notice how they all all are basically 100% clean. Only Rayleigh has few scuff marks

Then we get volume 4billion confirmation that Shanks was from God Valley incident:

1-year-old Shanks was found in a treasure chest that was stolen by Roger when God Valley incident happened

Meaning that this is most likely Roger, Rayleigh and Scopper after God Valley incident. And they still look fresh after all that fighting.
Were Rocks pirates that trash? They couldn't injure anyone?

There is a small chance that this is them during God Valley incident, but that would also raise a question as to how they are so chill during Rocks fighting that they steal and look at treasure chests. Rocks pirates can't even get their attention?

 

[SakazOuki]

Garp was beating the shit out of Rocks while Roger and his lackeys protected the celestial dragons, we know Garp would never do that.

 

[style]

You're for sure exaggerating but I agree that Rocks incident is a bit overrated.

If you think about nobody was at his prime. WB wasn't, BM wasn't, Shiki wasn't. Kaido wasn't.

 

[kurwa]

f you think about nobody was at his prime. WB wasn't, BM wasn't

Why not?
They are basically the same age as Roger and Rayleigh. They should be the same peak strength as Roger and Rayleigh were at that time

 

[ShiShiShi]

We don’t know much of anything about the God Valley incident besides the fact the Roger and Garp teamed up to take down Rocks. I think Shanks was supposedly found in a treasure chest there too, but that might not be canon.

Roger was powerful, but he wasn’t WORLD BREAKING powerful. He and his crew seemed to be on par with Whitebeard when they fought for a few days, so it can be assumed that he was around Whitebeard’s strength at the time.

This is amazing, because Roger was a fruitless pirate who has only been shown to use his sword Ace and Haki, so to be on par with Whitebeard and overpower Oden with just one strike is on a whole other level.

But was God Valley a cake walk? No, probably not. We don’t know how powerful Rocks was, but considering how much of a mysterious figure he is it‘s only logical to say he was incredibly strong.

He was the captain of the Rocks Pirates, which had three future Yonko as crew members and other unknown members. He wouldn’t be the captain of such powerful figures if he wasn’t one himself.

God Valley was probably an incredibly difficult fight. I’d say Luffy vs. Kaido difficult if not even harder. Can you imagine that? I sure can’t at the moment.

 

[Seatonnes]

Roger beats Xebec
Garp beats Whitebeard
Rayleigh beats Big Mom
Gaban beats Shiki
Bogard beats Kaido

 

[Welkin]

The only way God Valley would make any sense to me is if in some twist of fate WB switched sides

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

We don't know how long the battle last for. And makes you assume that they got Shanks after they fought Rocks?

 

[Warine]

In film red we see 1 year old Shanks' POV, meaning at least Rayleigh and Scopper were with Roger in God Valley:

Notice how they all all are basically 100% clean. Only Rayleigh has few scuff marks

Then we get volume 4billion confirmation that Shanks was from God Valley incident:

Meaning that this is most likely Roger, Rayleigh and Scopper after God Valley incident. And they still look fresh after all that fighting.
Were Rocks pirates that trash? They couldn't injure anyone?

There is a small chance that this is them during God Valley incident, but that would also raise a question as to how they are so chill during Rocks fighting that they steal and look at treasure chests. Rocks pirates can't even get their attention?

There is zero context to this moment, it might be before the fight for all we know, and most importantly, no point in gassing them up if they got lowdiffed

 

[LANJI CUCKSMOKE]

garp carried as per
while roger takes the glory
smh

 

[Mathias]

You know, they may have partied at God Valley after the fight and spent days there recovering. That's what the SHs do every time !

 

[Rmstorm]

Roger was at his peak and healthy during God Valley.

Meaning Roger at God Valley was = to Current Luffy level WITH HIS GEAR 5 AWAKENING Mastered.

This is why Gif Valley was not a struggle for Roger.

Read One Piece magazine 9. Whitebeard caught up to Roger 2 years after God Valley.

Current Luffy has not mastered Gear 5 yet.

Post automatically merged: Oct 9, 2022

Why not?
They are basically the same age as Roger and Rayleigh. They should be the same peak strength as Roger and Rayleigh were at that time

We know for a fact Roger was AT HIS PEAK during God Valley.

Roger had already finished his journey when God Valley took place. He had already reached the end of the New World.

One Piece magazine 9 talks about Whitebeard growing to his peak 2 years after God Valley.