General & Others WCI or Wano?

Which arc is better?


  • Total voters
    100
#2
Second half of WCI was the reason I started to dislike One Piece but as bad as WCI was it doesn't come close to Wano. Oda discarded literally over 25+ plot threads. Wano was just a gigantic story of filler. I can safely tell new readers that they can skip the entirety of Wano and they will lose zero relevant information.
 
#4
Second half of WCI was the reason I started to dislike One Piece but as bad as WCI was it doesn't come close to Wano. Oda discarded literally over 25+ plot threads. Wano was just a gigantic story of filler. I can safely tell new readers that they can skip the entirety of Wano and they will lose zero relevant information.
I still don't understand why we couldn't start timeskip with Wano

just meet Kinemon in Wano and literally everything plays out the same. The smile problem will be solved by loli plotdevice
Doffy just Kaido's ally in Wano for Law to fight.

Every build up to Wano was such a filler
 
#7
I still don't understand why we couldn't start timeskip with Wano

just meet Kinemon in Wano and literally everything plays out the same. The smile problem will be solved by loli plotdevice
Doffy just Kaido's ally in Wano for Law to fight.

Every build up to Wano was such a filler

Yep, just have Doflamingo be the villain for Fishman Island while Jinbei fights Hody Jones since there is more connection between the two. Then since Luffy defeated Doflamingo we can easily travel to Wano after FMI and we can easily skip Punk Hazard, Dressrosa and WCI. Then Elbaf can occur after Wano with Big Mom. We would have easily saved about 8 years worth of content and ~250+ chapters lol.
 
Last edited:
#14
Whole Cake Island was at the very least, a self contained mess. Everything I disliked about WCI only affected my enjoyment of WCI itself.

Wano however is such an absolute, disgusting dumpster fire that it retroactively shits on the whole series and it affects my enjoyment of One Piece as a whole.

The Whitebeard Pirates were reduced to being absolute bitches, all of the Yonko and legendary pirates (bar Roger) of the previous age were reduced to lackeys of some generic big bad with a name that looks like it went through a randomized word generator, the World Government looked absolutely fucking stupid over the Nika Fruit nonsense and of course, the retroactive middle finger that is the Nika Fruit itself.

So based on this, WCI is the better arc since it didn't derail the whole damn story.
Wano was the biggest shit show I’ve ever seen. It’s impossible for another story arc to ever again be as abysmal as Wano.
Tis best not to tempt both fate and Oda. :believe:
 
#17
I thought thing cant be worse than WCI. Clearly Oda proved me wrong
Only because your zoro wank didn't work
Lol typical fanboy
Post automatically merged:

I and others warned you guys singe WCI arc 4-5 years ago that Wano wouldn't be better than WCI but your love for zoro and hate for BM clouded your minds to see through

WCI despite wedding cake chase and other stuff in Second half, it was still better overall than Wano

Wano has fanservices that are meh, lack or destruction of characterisations, dragged plots, wasted potentials ,....everything that's bad
 
#19
Only because your zoro wank didn't work
Lol typical fanboy
Post automatically merged:

I and others warned you guys singe WCI arc 4-5 years ago that Wano wouldn't be better than WCI but your love for zoro and hate for BM clouded your minds to see through

WCI despite wedding cake chase and other stuff in Second half, it was still better overall than Wano

Wano has fanservices that are meh, lack or destruction of characterisations, dragged plots, wasted potentials ,....everything that's bad
lol, even if Zoro wanks work, my statement will gonna be "I prefer Wano because of my favorite character, Zoro". However, Wano in general without favorism is just a shit show.
 

KonyaruIchi

👑𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓟𝓲𝓻𝓪𝓽𝓮 𝓠𝓾𝓮𝓮𝓷👑
#20
Wano had higher highs but was generally way more inconsistent in terms of quality than WCI for me
This. Wano had some really good highs but the low's were pretty bad, with my biggest issues coming from the pacing. WCI's highs don't hit as hard for me, but at least it was mostly consistent in quality
 
Top