Theory What if Silhouette man is Roger’s son?

#1
There’s no reason why Ace should have been Roger’s only son.

The dude was a pirate. He could have had dozens of bastards.

In any case, we have no idea what happened to Roger’s sword, Ace. But it does look quite similar to silhouette man’s sword.
 
#4
There’s no reason why Ace should have been Roger’s only son.

The dude was a pirate. He could have had dozens of bastards.

In any case, we have no idea what happened to Roger’s sword, Ace. But it does look quite similar to silhouette man’s sword.
The WG went after anyone that associated with Roger. Those hypothetical bastards probably got murdered. Also, why would the Gorosei have a D. directly under them?
 

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
#7
There’s no reason why Ace should have been Roger’s only son.

The dude was a pirate. He could have had dozens of bastards.

In any case, we have no idea what happened to Roger’s sword, Ace. But it does look quite similar to silhouette man’s sword.
they were purdged the same way that the barratheon bastards were.
 

Yoho

Ruthlessness is Mercy upon yourself
#16
Tbf he didn't mention Weevil until post ts
True but in the grand scheme of things Weevil isn't all that important

This character seems to be shaping up to be a very important character

And when they thought he could possibly have a kid they began to test and kill anyone who could possibly have been the mother, the only reason Rouge and Ace where over looked is because she held his big headed ass for 20 months Ace was damn near 2 when he was born (no wonder Rouge died) I highly doubt anyone else had that same level of feat

You could say a long lost son was born before Roger was infamous but even then introducing someone with a blood relation to Roger and Ace this late in the series without a single hint or forshadow doesn't seem like something Oda would do
 

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
#17
True but in the grand scheme of things Weevil isn't all that important

This character seems to be shaping up to be a very important character

And when they thought he could possibly have a kid they began to test and kill anyone who could possibly have been the mother, the only reason Rouge and Ace where over looked is because she held his big headed ass for 20 months Ace was damn near 2 when he was born (no wonder Rouge died) I highly doubt anyone else had that same level of feat

You could say a long lost son was born before Roger was infamous but even then introducing someone with a blood relation to Roger and Ace this late in the series without a single hint or forshadow doesn't seem like something Oda would do
honestly he was written for fan services and was forgotten about as soon as he was introduced.
 
Top