Speculations Which island do the SHs go to next after Elbaf?

Which island is next?


  • Total voters
    23
#1
Imo there is only 3 islands max left for the SHs to visit. Hachinosu, Lodestar, and Laugh Tale. If Oda wants to get the story done quick, then Hachinosu and Lodestar can be skipped and the SHs can head to Laugh Tale after getting the 4th RP from Gaban if he is the burn scar man (I’d prefer it to be someone else, but it being Gaban is would be the quickest route for Oda to take).

I think the SHs will go to Lodestar since it’s an island Oda bothered to introduce despite it being not touched on at all yet, so it must have some sort of role in the story. Maybe it’s where SHs vs RHPs could happen.

Hachinosu is the one I’m most unsure of since BB would logically be the main villain there, but BB being taken out in the next arc seems too early. If they are to go to Hachinosu though, it would have to be the next arc since we already know Lodestar is the very last island you can get to via Log Pose, and it was already shown at the end of Wano that Hachinosu is close to Elbaf.
 
#5
God Valley is all the way in the West Blue, and I don’t think Gaban is the BSM. He have no hints of him having an all black ship or any whirlpool abilities, and it would be anticlimactic if Luffy basically got the last RP handed to him on a silver platter
GV not in the west blue anymore.

Gaban has a scar in the shape of flame, told Luffy to meet him when he’s leaving Elbaf, and confirmed still sails the seas.

It’s him.
 
#7
GV not in the west blue anymore.

Gaban has a scar in the shape of flame, told Luffy to meet him when he’s leaving Elbaf, and confirmed still sails the seas.

It’s him.
If it’s Gaban, then idk how the world wouldn’t be aware of the BSM’s identity. Gaban is known by nearly everyone, just like Ray and Roger. And if it is Gaban, then the all-black ship would presumably the the Oro Jackson, which would make you wonder how no one recognizes it is such (even if it did get a black paint job) since it’s the most famous ship in the world.

Imo the BSM is Rocks D. Xebec. The fact that Oda is keeping it ambiguous if he died at GV or not means he almost certainly is still alive
 
#8
If it’s Gaban, then idk how the world wouldn’t be aware of the BSM’s identity. Gaban is known by nearly everyone, just like Ray and Roger. And if it is Gaban, then the all-black ship would presumably the the Oro Jackson, which would make you wonder how no one recognizes it is such (even if it did get a black paint job) since it’s the most famous ship in the world.

Imo the BSM is Rocks D. Xebec. The fact that Oda is keeping it ambiguous if he died at GV or not means he almost certainly is still alive
Ehhh it'd be weird if Rocks is still alive when BB is supposed to be him but better
 
#9
If it’s Gaban, then idk how the world wouldn’t be aware of the BSM’s identity. Gaban is known by nearly everyone, just like Ray and Roger. And if it is Gaban, then the all-black ship would presumably the the Oro Jackson, which would make you wonder how no one recognizes it is such (even if it did get a black paint job) since it’s the most famous ship in the world.

Imo the BSM is Rocks D. Xebec. The fact that Oda is keeping it ambiguous if he died at GV or not means he almost certainly is still alive
Loki said Rocks was killed by the government last chap
 
#10
If it’s Gaban, then idk how the world wouldn’t be aware of the BSM’s identity. Gaban is known by nearly everyone, just like Ray and Roger. And if it is Gaban, then the all-black ship would presumably the the Oro Jackson, which would make you wonder how no one recognizes it is such (even if it did get a black paint job) since it’s the most famous ship in the world.

Imo the BSM is Rocks D. Xebec. The fact that Oda is keeping it ambiguous if he died at GV or not means he almost certainly is still alive
It’s not ambiguous, Xebec is stated to have been killed by the WG.

And isn’t it obvious since shanks instantly went to go see Gaban after saying he’s ready to claim the one piece?
 
#12
It’s not ambiguous, Xebec is stated to have been killed by the WG.

And isn’t it obvious since shanks instantly went to go see Gaban after saying he’s ready to claim the one piece?
Ok, so is Shanks on his way to Laugh Tale right now then? Because he should have all 4 RPs if Gaban has the last one
 
#15
God Valley is all the way in the West Blue, and I don’t think Gaban is the BSM. He have no hints of him having an all black ship or any whirlpool abilities, and it would be anticlimactic if Luffy basically got the last RP handed to him on a silver platter
Yeah, Shiryu speculated that Burn Scar might be a World Government man. I doubt that was just a throwaway line. It would make more sense to keep the Road Poneglyph secure in Mary Geoise, so this is probably someone who defected. Hence the all-black sails. Funnily enough, the topic was brought up to another defector (Kuzan).
 

Rej

Holy Simp
#17
ifk if there will be another place they will hold, but the overall next arc should be Lough Tale. It can have a few chapter interlude through another island, but I have my doubts
 
Top