Questions & Mysteries Which side won at Marineford?

[Waxy]

I'm having trouble understanding which side (Marine or WB (pirates)) won the war.

 

[Sigran101]

I'm having trouble understanding which side (Marine or WB (pirates)) won the war.

The Whitebeard pirates goal was to rescue Ace, and they failed because Ace was killed. Also Whitebeard died and the Marines had no major casualties. So the marines won the war.

 

[BuggyDGod]

Win:
BB pirates: got op DF from WB and lots of fame.

Neutral:
Marines: Killed wb pirates and Ace while losing lots of fodder. Not a win since at the end WB confirmed one piece existed and ignited the pirate era further.

Biggest losers

WB Pirates- Literally loss everything and almost entirely wiped out soon after.

 

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

Neither side really won tbh
WBP however were the ultimate losers of this war

 

[Herrera95]

There are no winners in war.

Besides a motherfucker called Teach.

 

[SkySanji]

Blackbeard won

Whitebeard would have won if Ace wasn't such an idiot

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

Winners: Shanks and BB Pirates.

Neutrals: Marines and Warlords.

Losers: WB Pirates (fail to rescue and lost their captain)

 

[Waxy]

Winners: Shanks and BB Pirates.

Neutrals: Marines and Warlords.

Losers: WB Pirates (fail to rescue and lost their captain)

How did Shanks win anything

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Winner:
Blackbeard Pirates - Left with no casualties, Level 6 Prisoners, and the Gura Gura no Mi.

Neutrals:
Marines - Had casualties but ended up killing Whitebeard and Ace

Losers:
Whitebeard Pirates - Lost Ace and Whitebeard and was the beginning of the downfall of the entire armada.

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

How did Shanks win anything

Stop the war entirely.

 

[Egghead]

Everyone lost.

 

[TEACH D TEACH]

Blackbeard won

Whitebeard would have won if Ace wasn't such an idiot

If Ace doesnt stop and Shanks shows up while hes alive... do Marines stop or they still try to kill him/fight WBP/RHP (i guess theyd fight lol)/BBP

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

Winners: BB Pirates. Teach got what he wanted + a shit ton of street cred, with no casualties btw.

Clear losers: WB pirates. Literally lost everything.

 

[Chiji_]

Not only did the WB pirates lose their captain but they lost one of their top commanders, whom they set out to rescue in the first place. None of the Marines best people were lost, only one admiral was wounded but not fatally, the fleet admiral and the marine hero didn’t even lift a finger against the WB pirates (outside of Garp punching Marco once). The warlord characters either under performed or actively fought against the Marines, only Doffy and Kuma did their job honestly and even they could have probably did more, Moriah tried but ☠️. This was absolutely a marine victory.

 

[MonsterKaido]

--Depends on what you mean by winning and losing. If WBP were destroyed completely then marines would have been winners 100%. They did manage to take their captain down so its somewhat of a win like 30%.

--WBP were losers in terms of their goals. TBF theres a good chance WBP would have retired in near future or WB could have died to sickness