Questions & Mysteries Who was present at the God Valley Incident ?

Rocks D. Buggy

Rocks D. Buggy

‎
#1
#1
Here are all the players we know and potentiel ppl that could've been with them


Rocks Pirates :

- Rocks D. Xebec , ???

- Edward Newgate, 36 yo

- Charlotte Linlin, 30 yo

- Shiki, ???

- Kaido, 17 yo (a guess)

- John, ???

- Silver Axe, ???

- Wang Zhi, ???

- Bakkin, 38 yo

- Shanks, 1 yo

- Buggy, 1 yo


The Pirate-Marine Alliance :

- Monkey D. Garp, 40 yo

- Gol D. Roger, 39 yo

- Silvers Rayleigh, 40 yo

- Scopper Gaban, ??? (my guess he would be younger than Roger and Rayleigh like 30~)


- Tsuru, 38 yo

- Sengoku, 41 yo

- Kong, 50+ yo

- Gorosei , ???

- Monkey D. Dragon, 17 yo

- Sakazuki, 17 yo

- Borsalino, 20 yo

- Jaguar D. Saul, 89 yo

- Sunbell, ???



Any other suggestions who else could've been there or any guess on these ppl's age at the time ?
 
Last edited:
Finalbeta

Finalbeta

Ging Freecss stan
‎
#2
#2
Yeah my money is on Rocks Pirates and Roger Pirates, but I would wonder whom of the marine could have been present and what it occurred.

Until we get a proper flashback we will only be able to merely speculate about the circumstances of that epoch making event.
 
Jew D. Boy

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
‎
#5
#5
Rocks D. Buggy said:
This is a bit tricky cause she says "I retired 40 years ago from being a pirate" and the God Valley Incident happened 38 years ago so unless she unretired and then re-retired she she be from a seperate pirate crew


Also I doubt Rayleigh would date someone from Rocks' crew after defeating them
Click to expand...
We’re splitting hairs with the timeline thing, I think...wouldn’t be uncommon to refer to 38 years in the past as “40 years ago” for shorthand, plenty of people round up when talking about periods of time like that. Either way, she could have been a member of Rocks prior to God Valley; that’s the only prominent crew from that time period we’ve heard about, so while it isn’t impossible that she was with another crew, it still feels unlikely in the context of the story.
 
Jew D. Boy

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
‎
#7
#7
kurwa said:
Only these guys were confirmed to be present at God Valley
Click to expand...
We were purposely given a whitewashed version from Sengoku/Oda in that chapter, I think it’s too early to say that those were definitely the only players. May not necessarily include Shakky as I said above, but it seems unlikely that the biggest battle between the OP world’s strongest fighters only included half a dozen people.
 
Rocks D. Buggy

Rocks D. Buggy

‎
#8
#8
kurwa said:
Only these guys were confirmed to be present at God Valley

No way people like Sengoku were there
he was talking about Garp's accomplishment in God Valley not theirs.

I think it was Roger&Garp vs Xebec, WB, Big Mom, Koido
Click to expand...


yea that's why i said "potentiel" while Sengoku , Tsuru or Kong couldn't be there i don't see why not Dragon , Saka or Saul couldn't be there as Garp subordinates

And Obviously the 2 roger pirates that i'm 100% confident were there are Silvers Rayleigh and Scopper Gaban but even with them the battle is too imbalanced , thus why i made a thread asking who else could be there to help them
 
Rmstorm

Rmstorm

‎
#9
#9
Rocks D. Buggy said:
Here are all the players we know and potentiel ppl that could've been with them


Rocks Pirates :

- Rocks D. Xebec , ???

- Edward Newgate, 36 yo

- Charlotte Linlin, 30 yo

- Shiki, ???

- Kaido, 17 yo (a guess)

- John, ???

- Silver Axe, ???

- Wang Zhi, ???

- Bakkin, 38 yo

- Shanks, 1 yo

- Buggy, 1 yo


The Pirate-Marine Alliance :

- Monkey D. Garp, 40 yo

- Gol D. Roger, 37 yo

- Silvers Rayleigh, 40 yo

- Scopper Gaban, ??? (my guess he would be younger than Roger and Rayleigh like 30~)


- Tsuru, 38 yo

- Sengoku, 41 yo

- Kong, 50+ yo

- Gorosei , ???

- Monkey D. Dragon, 17 yo

- Sakazuki, 17 yo

- Borsalino, 20 yo

- Jaguar D. Saul, 89 yo

- Sunbell, ???



Any other suggestions who else could've been there or any guess on these ppl's age at the time ?
Click to expand...
Roger was 39 years old, he would be 77 years old if he were alive currently. He was only 1 year younger than Garp and Rayleigh.
 
Tyki_Mikk

Tyki_Mikk

‎
#12
#12
Interesting that both Roger and Whitebeard where in similae same age during that time. Also Linlin was a not young as I though, with 30 she was most like a monster back then. As Teenager she already had 500mio,I can see that during that time in God valley Big mom had a bounty around 2-3B and where a solid top tier. Shiki too, only Kaido was a young member back then.

So Xebec most like had during that time 3 top tiers under his control with is really impressiv.
 
Rmstorm

Rmstorm

‎
#13
#13
playa4321 said:
Interesting that both Roger and Whitebeard where in similae same age during that time. Also Linlin was a not young as I though, with 30 she was most like a monster back then. As Teenager she already had 500mio,I can see that during that time in God valley Big mom had a bounty around 2-3B and where a solid top tier. Shiki too, only Kaido was a young member back then.

So Xebec most like had during that time 3 top tiers under his control with is really impressiv.
Click to expand...
Roger had 3 top tiers under his control at 1 point, Rayleigh, Scopper Gaban and Oden.
 
Monet

Monet

‎
#15
#15
no marines big shot other than garb
..
except young current admirals
akainu and Kizaru .
..
roger garb vs xaibeck

Rayleigh vs WB
Scopper gaban vs big mom

young akainu vs young kaidou
they will be both at almost same age that time .

other members or roger pirates + marines vs rest members of rocks
 
J

Jo_Ndule

#16
#16
playa4321 said:
Interesting that both Roger and Whitebeard where in similae same age during that time. Also Linlin was a not young as I though, with 30 she was most like a monster back then. As Teenager she already had 500mio,I can see that during that time in God valley Big mom had a bounty around 2-3B and where a solid top tier. Shiki too, only Kaido was a young member back then.

So Xebec most like had during that time 3 top tiers under his control with is really impressiv.
Click to expand...
Young linlin is low top max
Young wb was mid top tier max
Apprentice kaido is top veteran /low high tier max... he needed saving from Linlin after the battle.
Kaido wasn't even a rookie but an apprentice

I don't think wb and bm had 3 B back then
It will mean they only got 1 B-1.5 B increase for the next 30+ years, doesn't make sense.

WB : 2 B max
Linlin : 2 B max
The weren't captains too.
 
Rocks D. Buggy

Rocks D. Buggy

‎
#17
#17
Monet said:
young akainu vs young kaidou
Click to expand...
it would be insane if we learn that Sakazuki or Dragon are responsible for Kaido's near death experience then BM saving him but I doubt that , Kaido is a monster while Saka/Dragon would be normal humans

Monet said:
no marines big shot other than garb
Click to expand...
I think at least Jaguar D. Saul will be there as all D. seem to be reunited on this God Valley and maybe we could see more of him cause we only saw him briefly with Robin Flashback and Episode 0

Maybe Tsuru as well as she seems the sidekick of Garp

playa4321 said:
So Xebec most like had during that time 3 top tiers under his control with is really impressiv.
Click to expand...
I would say at their peak both Roger Pirates and StrawHat Pirates had better crews

1- Roger Pirates when they reached One Piece with Roger , Rayleigh , Gaban and Oden
2- StrawHat Pirates right now with Luffy , Zoro , Sanji and Jinbei
3- Rocks Pirates 38 years ago with Xebec , Newgate , Linlin and Shiki
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top