Questions & Mysteries Why couldnt Rock achieve black blade ?

[warsame zaylai]

he is stronger then roger wb shiki etc

but he is a swordsman who didnt have a black blade

even shiki who likely wano or ex samurai swordsman and equal to roger (said in chapter 0) didnt have black blade

even immortal dude (nusjuro) god knows how long did he lived didnt have black blade


is it haki ? is it some magic ? is it some devil contract ?
what is it ?

 

[Flash_Flash]

Is there any proof they tried to achieve it? Why could not Whitebeard have Future Sight?

 

[Yoho]

Because getting a black blade is about more than strength, one has to dedicate their entire being into swordsmanship, become one with their blade body, mind and soul

 

[warsame zaylai]

Is there any proof they tried to achieve it? Why could not Whitebeard have Future Sight?

black blade is said to be the peak of swordsman strength according to that OP magazine

 

[Flash_Flash]

black blade is said to be the peak of swordsman strength according to that OP magazine

And FS is the peak of CoO why could not Wb have FS?

 

[SkySanji]

Why isn't Mihawk's dagger a black blade

 

[warsame zaylai]

Because getting a black blade is about more than strength, one has to dedicate their entire being into swordsmanship, become one with their blade body, mind and soul

so why roger couldnt do it ?
didnt he named his own son after his sword ? he has special relationship with his sword

 

[Flash_Flash]

so why roger couldnt do it ?
didnt he named his own son after his sword ? he has special relationship with his sword

Why were Garp and WB unable to achieve FS?

 

[warsame zaylai]

And FS is the peak of CoO why could not Wb have FS?

we dont know wb full haki power
he likely had FS and roger too. its like me saying why didnt roger and wb had the 3 level of coc (the one can hurt immortal dudes ) ? ofc they do

black blade is a whole different thing

Post automatically merged: Jul 21, 2025

Why were Garp and WB unable to achieve FS?

we dont know wb full haki power
he likely had FS and roger too. its like me saying why didnt roger and wb had the 3 level of coc (the one can hurt immortal dudes ) ? ofc they do

black blade is a whole different thing

 

[Flash_Flash]

we dont know wb full haki power
he likely had FS and roger too. its like me saying why didnt roger and wb had the 3 level of coc (the one can hurt immortal dudes ) ? ofc they do

black blade is a whole different thing

Why wouldn't he? He had a full fleshed flashback though Oden. He also never showed it in MF and no indication he had FS in his prime. It's not like Oda would give another flashback to WB again just to prove he had FS lol. That's pointless and a waste of panels.

Why could not Garp achieve FS though?

Roger having FS doesn't mean WB also had FS lol

 

[warsame zaylai]

Why isn't Mihawk's dagger a black blade

cuz he doesnt fight daggers against top tiers ?

 

[MonsterKaido]

BB is Zoro only unique power up. Hence only Mihawk Zoro's end goal is only one who has it.

 

[warsame zaylai]

Why wouldn't we? He had a full fleshed flashback though Oden. He also never showed it in MF and no indication he had FS in his prime.

Why could not Garp achieve FS though?

Roger having FS doesn't mean WB also had FS lol

wb never showed coc in MF as well
wb and roger never showed the 3 level of coc as well

we didnt see wb fight fully in oden flashback
the only time we see him go all out was the acoc clash

 

[Yoho]

so why roger couldnt do it ?
didnt he named his own son after his sword ? he has special relationship with his sword

His relationship with his sword wasn't that strong, theres a reason only 2 known people in the story got a black blade so if it was just a matter of strength a lot more people would be walking around with one.

Also Ace was born almost 2 years after Rogers death its more likely Rogue named him Ace not Roger

 

[SkySanji]

cuz he doesnt fight daggers against top tiers ?

You just made this requirement up, it is said nowhere

 

[warsame zaylai]

BB is Zoro only unique power up. Hence only Mihawk Zoro's end goal is only one who has it.

why is only unique to them but not others ? makes no sense

 

[Flash_Flash]

wb never showed coc in MF as well
wb and roger never showed the 3 level of coc as well

we didnt see wb fight fully in oden flashback
the only time we see him go all out was the acoc clash

He showed it in his prime in Oden flashback so it's a good proof enough he had CoC coating.
And why would Oda show WB flashback again? If he did not have it then he did not have it. This if and if is pointless unless it's confirmed in the manga. WB was unable to achieve FS just like Garp something you ignored lol.

 

[warsame zaylai]

His relationship with his sword wasn't that strong, theres a reason only 2 known people in the story got a black blade so if it was just a matter of strength a lot more people would be walking around with one.

Also Ace was born almost 2 years after Rogers death its more likely Rogue named him Ace not Roger

im pretty sure roger wanted to name him ace hence why rogue picked the name ace

he had his sword for years wym he didnt have good relationship

 

[MonsterKaido]

why is only unique to them but not others ? makes no sense

Because Zoro is second MC and oda wants to give him something unique to him only.

 

[Flash_Flash]

im pretty sure roger wanted to name him ace hence why rogue picked the name ace

he had his sword for years wym he didnt have good relationship

And Garp and WB were unable to achieve FS.