Character Discussion Why do people see any problem with Sanji and Pudding?

#1
When I first read whole cake island, I thought they looked cute together and it didn't even occur to me that some people would find pudding's age problematic. I was flabbergasted to see the comments of some people just because she is 16 and sanji 21.

Just look at Pudding:



Does that look like a child to you? She has the same exact character model as all adult females in the series... Sanji is turned on by all of the other girls but he is supposed to magically feel nothing towards her? Last time I checked, physical attraction is visual.

When Sanji saw her for the first time, he reacted like he usually does, of course he would be attracted to her.




I saw lots of people calling him a pedo.... Do these people even know the meaning of the word they're using? Pedos are into kids. They get turned on by the appearance of a prepubertal child's body. If they saw pudding, they would feel nothing. Meanwhile most normal men who are attracted to the appearance of a grown woman, would be attracted to pudding, because that's what her body looks like.

As far as personality wise, she was far from innocent. She allegedly seduced and tricked countless men and got them assassinated before Sanji. Are people forgetting those details? Not to mention that these people are also severely lacking in historical contextualisation. One piece is believed to be set between 1300's and 1500's. Age of consent wasn't even a thing at that time, if you looked grown up, you were seen and treated as an adult by society. Most were seen as adults at 14-15 ish. People were already working, fighting wars and getting married as teenagers in this historical period. Applying modern logic and morals to the past is ridiculous.


Also let's not forget that not every country is America, culture and laws are different everywhere. In the vast majority of the world, the age of consent varies from 14-16 as you can see:




In my country, guys in their early twenties dating older teen girls (16-17) is pretty normal. So I didn't bat an eye until I saw Americans going crazy over it.
 

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
#10
When I first read whole cake island, I thought they looked cute together and it didn't even occur to me that some people would find pudding's age problematic. I was flabbergasted to see the comments of some people just because she is 16 and sanji 21.

Just look at Pudding:



Does that look like a child to you? She has the same exact character model as all adult females in the series... Sanji is turned on by all of the other girls but he is supposed to magically feel nothing towards her? Last time I checked, physical attraction is visual.

When Sanji saw her for the first time, he reacted like he usually does, of course he would be attracted to her.




I saw lots of people calling him a pedo.... Do these people even know the meaning of the word they're using? Pedos are into kids. They get turned on by the appearance of a prepubertal child's body. If they saw pudding, they would feel nothing. Meanwhile most normal men who are attracted to the appearance of a grown woman, would be attracted to pudding, because that's what her body looks like.

As far as personality wise, she was far from innocent. She allegedly seduced and tricked countless men and got them assassinated before Sanji. Are people forgetting those details? Not to mention that these people are also severely lacking in historical contextualisation. One piece is believed to be set between 1300's and 1500's. Age of consent wasn't even a thing at that time, if you looked grown up, you were seen and treated as an adult by society. Most were seen as adults at 14-15 ish. People were already working, fighting wars and getting married as teenagers in this historical period. Applying modern logic and morals to the past is ridiculous.


Also let's not forget that not every country is America, culture and laws are different everywhere. In the vast majority of the world, the age of consent varies from 14-16 as you can see:




In my country, guys in their early twenties dating older teen girls (16-17) is pretty normal. So I didn't bat an eye until I saw Americans going crazy over it.
That map is not up to date.
Since 2019, with a few changes in the law, in Brazil, you need to be AT LEAST 16 years old to get married, with still a few requirements, like permission of the legal responsible for the minor, etc.
:pepelit:

Aside from that, people just grab every opportunity they can take to hate on the character. It's nothing new. Sanji just lives rent free on these people's heads.
:stealthblack:
 
#13
I also think they look cute together. The fact that Pudding loves Sanji and that he is 100% confident of this when she is around allows him to express the best of himself, which is exactly what love is about. However, the fact that Pudding is only 16 takes people to think that she isn't really in love, and that she is just one of the many girls that at that age easly falls for the bigger, adult man.
Should blame Oda for making Pudding only 16 yrs old.
I mean why just don't make her same age of Sanji?
Anyway the age gap is slight; 2 years and she'll be 18 and Sanji 23, and then noone will complain anymore.
 
Last edited:
#15
If I see you going around hitting on 16…155..14 yr olds… you will be shot
Then go to the country whose flag you have on your pfp and do a mass shooting there.

Just remember that 29 year old Hancock wanted to marry a 17 year old kid. :handsup:
tbh same logic applies. She never looked at him with the eyes she'd look at a kid. He was physically grown up and strong enough to defeat the strongest warriors in her clan. Hell, he had a six pack and a facial scar. She saw him as a dangerous invader at first and then she saw him as a powerful ally. People need to stop treating 18 as a magical number. In that time period and universe, there's no such concept of age of consent.
 
Last edited:
#18
We see a 21 year old going for 16 year old as pedophiles because they're at such different stages in life. 21 year olds have access to things that they use to take advantage of the child (yes, child). So from our perspective Sanji is a predator, according to his personality Sanji would be attracted to 16 year old girls were he a real person. Obviously things are different in the OP world, but yeah if someone is attracted to someone who is mentally or physically underdeveloped, the last thing I would do, personally, is defend them.
 
Top