Theory Xebec had Shinobu’s DF

[Monkey D Theories]

The HKs are said to be immortal. However we have one and only one example of a HK aging. Garling.

If he had immortality in God Valley, why is he old now?

What if he didn’t age naturally. We know Shinobu’s DF can permanently age people. What if Xebec had Shinobu’s powers?

Garling fought him, got bested, and was aged into an old man.

Ultimately, I think this would be a deadly power in the hands of someone evil like Xebec. He could mass murder people by decaying them, like Shigaraki Tomura in MHA. This could explain why he was so dangerous and why Garp and Roger were willing to ally to defeat him.

Post automatically merged: Apr 25, 2025

Also maybe Xebec used an advanced decay technique to give Roger his terminal illness.

Externally, Roger didn’t look aged. But what if the fight with Xebec aged his organs, ultimately leading to his early death?

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Peak thread

 

[SkySanji]

We know they have regeneration, we do not know that they don't age.

 

[Monkey D Theories]

We know they have regeneration, we do not know that they don't age.

Saul said they were immortal, so I’m guessing their regeneration makes them ageless.

 

[SkySanji]

Saul said they were immortal, so I’m guessing their regeneration makes them ageless.

And being able to regenerate lethal injuries is a form of immortality, so what Saul said doesn't mean anything.

 

[BigAmmi]

Immortality =/= eternal youth

 

[Nagasaki]

But all the Gorousei are also old, and some information about the lost century is legend even to them, as mentioned a few times. If I'm not mistaken, it was said that Nika was a legend even to them. This implies that only Imu should be immortal and have eternal youth. Sommers is also considerably old.

 

[PurplePretzel]

You could type "Xebec" and get like 1000-5000 views even if you didn't say anything else

 

[HA001]

Xebec is dr hiriluk

 

[Monkey D Theories]

But all the Gorousei are also old, and some information about the lost century is legend even to them, as mentioned a few times. If I'm not mistaken, it was said that Nika was a legend even to them. This implies that only Imu should be immortal and have eternal youth. Sommers is also considerably old.

The thing is, we don’t know when any of those guys became HKs. Given how Imu is giving them immortality, there can probably only be a set number of immortals at a given time.

If you can only become a HK when the position opens up, its possible that Sommers and the Gorosei didn’t become HKs until they were old and an opening came up.

But for Garling, we knew aged while he was a HK. Meaning one of two things:

1. The HKs have a different form of immortality than the Gorosei
2. Garling was aged up somehow

I guess there’s also the third possibility that Garling was demoted after God Valley and was only reinstated as a HK much later.

 

[Dilan]

The HKs are said to be immortal. However we have one and only one example of a HK aging. Garling.

If he had immortality in God Valley, why is he old now?

What if he didn’t age naturally. We know Shinobu’s DF can permanently age people. What if Xebec had Shinobu’s powers?

Garling fought him, got bested, and was aged into an old man.

Ultimately, I think this would be a deadly power in the hands of someone evil like Xebec. He could mass murder people by decaying them, like Shigaraki Tomura in MHA. This could explain why he was so dangerous and why Garp and Roger were willing to ally to defeat him.

Post automatically merged: Apr 25, 2025

Also maybe Xebec used an advanced decay technique to give Roger his terminal illness.

Externally, Roger didn’t look aged. But what if the fight with Xebec aged his organs, ultimately leading to his early death?

Gonna be real this makes no sense.
A character aged normally so Rocks has shinobus fruit. I feel like we are a but smarter than this.

It just means the God knights have regeneration but don't have Immortality. Simple as