General & Others Yamato is NOT the Ace of the Beast pirates

[ImmaIvanoM]

Get it? Yamato isn't part of the Beast pirates so he can't have a position in the beast pirates.

Yamato doesn't have a bounty and is completely unknown tot he outside world. He's directly insubordinate to Kaido and is apparently an Oden fanboy.

Kaido refers to him as an idiot and the beast pirates are a meritocracy so Yamato would have to have WORKED under kaido to get a position in the crew. And yet Yamato is entirely unknown with no bounty so how what would he even have done in the crew.

So no, Yamato is NOT the Ace. Him marrying Charlotte child DOES NOTHING for the alliance since HE'S NOT IN THE CREW so he isn't marrying anyone.

He's strength could easily be attributed to Kaido just beating him up all his life to make him strong but once again, nothing really shows that he's actually in the crew. Kaido's crew isn't Big mom's. You don't automatically join because of blood relation.

 

[Ravagerblade]

Fair enough. But I still want my headcanon to come true.
Btw if Yamato isn't part of the crew, does that also include the younger children of BMP, Flampe, Anana etc...

 

[Fn Lucci]

That's a lot of headcanon. Headcanon would also be calling him Ace when we know jack shit about him.

But I can see two simple things that might compare him: he's being kept alive, and he's clearly a beast in Kaido's image. Kaido did not ask them to attack Yamato, and despite being apparently defiant Yamato fights just like Kaido. If you compare that to Newgate beating Ace and grooming him against his will on some Stockholm shit, it kinda feels similar.

 

[Finalbeta]

Well he might have been in the past

He sure as hell is not part of them anymore, though it could just be a formality that he is still considered as part

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

That's a lot of headcanon. Headcanon would also be calling him Ace when we know jack shit about him.

But I can see two simple things that might compare him: he's being kept alive, and he's clearly a beast in Kaido's image. Kaido did not ask them to attack Yamato, and despite being apparently defiant Yamato fights just like Kaido. If you compare that to Newgate beating Ace and grooming him against his will on some Stockholm shit, it kinda feels similar.

Its not head canon that he has no bounty.

It would staggeringly stupid of law to not even know that a person with a bounty directly affiliated with kaido exists. The mere fact that no one knew about yamato indicates he's no going around pilaging for Kaido like jack. He's not involved in the underworld like king.or queen or Doflamingo. He doesn't even seem to fight for Kaido

So how can he be part of the beast pirates when he does diddly squat for them

 

[Fn Lucci]

We have no idea what's known about him in the world or not, and it's not like people have to know he's Kaido's son if they know of him either.

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

We have no idea what's known about him in the world or not, and it's not like people have to know he's Kaido's son if they know of him either.

Then he's still not in the Beast pirates.

Like if he has a seperate bounty of his own that doesn't reveal his identity then it will be a bounty outside his affiliation with the beast pirates.

We had a war meeting remember? Robin calls out that Kaido has the commander's and the Tobi roppo ONLY as his top men. Robin and Law have no idea that there's a secret commander who has a bounty directly stating he's a beast pirate? Seems unlikely. Seems like the only explanation is that this guy is just not in the crew.

Again, the beast pirates are a meritocracy. Yamato can't have a position in the crew just because he's Kaido's son. He has to have done things for the beast pirates as subordinate of kaido in the real world to have such a position. And so he would have to have a bounty. Which he clearly doesn't have or else Law and Robin are utterly incompetent

 

[Fujishiro]

Get it? Yamato isn't part of the Beast pirates so he can't have a position in the beast pirates.

Yamato doesn't have a bounty and is completely unknown tot he outside world. He's directly insubordinate to Kaido and is apparently an Oden fanboy.

Kaido refers to him as an idiot and the beast pirates are a meritocracy so Yamato would have to have WORKED under kaido to get a position in the crew. And yet Yamato is entirely unknown with no bounty so how what would he even have done in the crew.

So no, Yamato is NOT the Ace. Him marrying Charlotte child DOES NOTHING for the alliance since HE'S NOT IN THE CREW so he isn't marrying anyone.

He's strength could easily be attributed to Kaido just beating him up all his life to make him strong but once again, nothing really shows that he's actually in the crew. Kaido's crew isn't Big mom's. You don't automatically join because of blood relation.

Why is it that everytime i read your posts i can picture you yelling

 

[Balen]

Get it? Yamato isn't part of the Beast pirates so he can't have a position in the beast pirates.

Yamato doesn't have a bounty and is completely unknown tot he outside world. He's directly insubordinate to Kaido and is apparently an Oden fanboy.

Kaido refers to him as an idiot and the beast pirates are a meritocracy so Yamato would have to have WORKED under kaido to get a position in the crew. And yet Yamato is entirely unknown with no bounty so how what would he even have done in the crew.

So no, Yamato is NOT the Ace. Him marrying Charlotte child DOES NOTHING for the alliance since HE'S NOT IN THE CREW so he isn't marrying anyone.

He's strength could easily be attributed to Kaido just beating him up all his life to make him strong but once again, nothing really shows that he's actually in the crew. Kaido's crew isn't Big mom's. You don't automatically join because of blood relation.

Chill out bro, why are you so angry

 

[sanjikun]

I think Ace is Ace tbh. It'd be tacky to have 2 Aces.

 

[Finalbeta]

Chill out bro, why are you so angry

Someone doesn't like Yamato here :3

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

Why is it that everytime i read your posts i can picture you yelling

Chill out bro, why are you so angry

Well this is new.

Anything else?

Post automatically merged: Jun 23, 2020

Someone doesn't like Yamato here :3

Okay what in my post suggests I don't like yamato?

Hehehe? Because I didn't follow community head canon that doesn't make sense? I'm supposed to follow your head canon to show that I like a character?