I respect your opinion. I'm not saying AoT is better than OP though, i just voicing more about my view on AoT in that post compared to my view about OP. I agree on many things you've pointed out, about shallow and boring characters and about how Oda can juggle so much more character compared to Isayama, character design, Oda's creativity and intricacies with world-building and ability building, that Isayama cant touch with his level of juggling, etc.
I also have similar view to you regarding inconsistency in each arc, we have explosive twists but we also have long boring and dull moments. It's just that i emphasize more about AoT's strong points in my post.
Such as story-driven or character-driven moments, imo OP don't have that level of twist, or if OP have those moments then they're not affecting the story as much as AoT's moments affecting the next story phase. Since the member asking hasnt read AoT, i try to explore / emphasize AoT's strong points in longer explanations than exploring OP's strong points.
Hmm how should i put this. AoT focuses on grand scheme of overall plot, the bigger picture, and imo its really succeeded in that regard. Especially with chapter 123, imo by dropping that chapter, Isayama did something that exceeded the readers' expectation regarding AoT's strong point, thats why im okay with mediocre moments AoT keep showing.
While OP focuses on many many things, so it tackles wider responsibilities to satisfy readers, and nowadays i feel like OP fails to do certain things like exceeding the readers' expectations in battle scenes or powerlevels for example. One of OP's main focus is battle scenes and powerlevel, so when Oda seemed way too invested in hyping everyone powerlevel-wise and he don't really give each hype the justice, my personal expectation to this aspect of OP keep decreasing. Since OP tries to focus on battle, but it keeps failing the hype it tries to build.
Not to take anything away from the magical world-building or thousands of characters Oda create with each powers and design of their own though, i really like OP as well with its various strong points, i just didnt explore it longer in the previous post.