Character Discussion Who is the strongest strawhat excluding the Monster trio and Jinbei ?

[MarineHQ]

I have a feeling that Brook will fight and beat Who's Who or Perospero, but in both cases they'll be weakened by the Sulong minks/Jinbe respectively, so overall I'd say Franky.

 

[Lightbolt]

Exactly. It's all about the team work.
Something that ppl like Oden failed to understand.

To be fair oden was a monster

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

Luffy admitted it in arlong park that he can't do everything alone‚ but Zoro's and Sanji's fanbase are making it as if Zoro and Sanji would have made it alone as far as Luffy did

Sanji is a cook whos dream is finding all blue if not for luffy and zoro lanji would still be cooking for marines that looked down on him on the chef baratie in some random sea. luffy and zoro are different they both had their dreams set since they were little kids and they both were following their dreams even before they met each other its just happened that their paths crossed and their fates tied together. They both are pillars to each others success yes in a way also sanji is important to them, as important as a cook can be that is. But luffy was chasing his dream to become pirate king and zoro was following his to be the worlds strongest swordsmen unlike different crew memebers that needed pursuing / helping / saving in order for them to actually follow their dreams.
What i am saying is luffy and zoro are not comparable to a mere cook.

 

[Ballel]

To be fair oden was a monster

Yeah but still didn't want help from others. He wanted to do everything on his own

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

But without Luffy the crew wouldn't even exist

Whoa that's harsh.

Luffy admitted it in arlong park that he can't do everything alone‚ but Zoro's and Sanji's fanbase are making it as if Zoro and Sanji would have made it alone as far as Luffy did

Don Le Fishe don't really care.
Chill.
Don Le Fishe go to fish.

 

[Lightbolt]

Yeah but still didn't want help from others. He wanted to do everything on his own

He didn't get to be on the ships of the two strongest pirates for nothing

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2021

Sanji is a cook whos dream is finding all blue if not for luffy and zoro lanji would still be cooking for marines that looked down on him on the chef baratie in some random sea. luffy and zoro are different they both had their dreams set since they were little kids and they both were following their dreams even before they met each other its just happened that their paths crossed and their fates tied together. They both are pillars to each others success yes in a way also sanji is important to them, as important as a cook can be that is. But luffy was chasing his dream to become pirate king and zoro was following his to be the worlds strongest swordsmen unlike different crew memebers that needed pursuing / helping / saving in order for them to actually follow their dreams.
What i am saying is luffy and zoro are not comparable to a mere cook.

I am not sure why my thread turned to a Zoro vs sanji‚ when all I asked is who is the 5th strongest strwahat ? Lol

But anyway Sanji is no mere cook. Ask luffy

 

[Midnight Delight]

Pre wb Ace who fought evenly with Jinbe, yes

That Jinbei was called too weak to be a Warlord by Ben Beckman

 

[Cross_Marian]

It is a wish not based on facts.

Plus technically‚ she doesn't consider herself a female

She considers herself as Oden. It’s not the same case like Kiku. Kiku feels like a woman, Yamato just wants to be called male because Oden was a man, if Oden would have been a female she would call herself so. It’s not a matter of gender in Yamato’s case and she’s been introduced as Kaidos daughter and named so many times ( in social media posts by the staff etc.). Regarding her strength, I have some logical arguments , of course I don’t know the future, so it’s a wish and a theory. Saying Sanji will stay the third strongest is also a wish. We don’t know and we must see what will happen

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

He didn't get to be on the ships of the two strongest pirates for nothing

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2021

I am not sure why my thread turned to a Zoro vs sanji‚ when all I asked is who is the 5th strongest strwahat ? Lol

But anyway Sanji is no mere cook. Ask luffy

1. Luffy
2.Zoro

3. Jinbei
4. Franky
For the 5th strongest 5. Close one between brook and mere cook leaning towards brook.

Cant ask luffy though i think he changed his number will try again later

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Anyone who isn’t saying Franky is a traitor to all manga fans

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

Anyone who isn’t saying Franky is a traitor to all manga fans

Super franky

 

[Lightbolt]

Super franky

You are back on topic finally lol

 

[Ballel]

He didn't get to be on the ships of the two strongest pirates for nothing

Like, he could have asked the daimyos of the other regions to fight Kaido together for example but decided he has to go there on his own, has to face Kaido&Orochi alone and has to save the citizens from being kidnapped by agreeing to that weird dancing naked pact all on his own.
He didn't even want the scabbards to help him in any way, shape or form.

Sure, he was strong, but thats not how you run a country.
Kaido&Orochi were about to wipe his people from existence and Oden wanted to take everything on himself.

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

You are back on topic finally lol

I was always on topic you asked for the 5th strongest strawhat and i said its sanji
:cheers:

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Super franky

Me to all the heretics who don’t worship the cyborg carpenter like he deserves:

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

Me to all the heretics who don’t worship the cyborg carpenter like he deserves:

Hes so handsome
And they say that sanji is better

Super franky is just superior

 

[Lightbolt]

Like, he could have asked the daimyos of the other regions to fight Kaido together for example but decided he has to go there on his own, has to face Kaido&Orochi alone and has to save the citizensfrim being kidnapped by agreeing to that weird dancing naked pact all on his own.
He didn't even want the scabbards to help him in way, shape or form.

Sure, he was strong, but thats not how you run a country.
Kaido&Orochi were about to wipe his people from existence and Oden wanted to take everything on himself.

You saw how the nine of them fared against kaido. Having them sacrifice their life would have amounted to nothing

 

[Dickie D. Dick]

Anyone who isn’t saying Franky is a traitor to all manga fans

Don Le Fishe already made the point that Franky > Simpji.

 

[Afroking]

In my opinion it is Robin,but I can't say that Franky isn't the one highlighted as that person by Oda,since he doesn't make his females fight all that much . In a direct fight I have Robin > Franky.

 

[Jew D. Boy]

Hes so handsome
And they say that sanji is better

Super franky is just superior

Yeah, well, “they” don’t often get anything right, do they??

Don Le Fishe already made the point that Franky > Simpji.