Character Discussion Who is the strongest strawhat excluding the Monster trio and Jinbei ?

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Franky, but in the end it doesn't matter. Even Usopp, the weakest SH is surpassing his father who's YC2.

Post automatically merged: Feb 17, 2021

It's 2005 all over again....... @Kishido

Anyway, the ranking is:
1. Luffy
2. Zoro
3. Sanji
4. Yamato
5. Jinbei
6. Franky
7. Brook
8. Robin
9. Usopp
10. Chopper
11. Nami

Sanji will never drop to 4th whether you like it or not.

Agree with most of these but Robin and Chopper are stronger then Brook. And Usopp's weaker then Nami.

 

[Lunaria]

Seems to be Franky but if Brook really ends up fighting Who’s Who, it will make things confusing. Who’s Who is supposed to be slightly stronger than Sasaki, based on their portrayal.

Franky, but in the end it doesn't matter. Even Usopp, the weakest SH is surpassing his father who's YC2.

Post automatically merged: Feb 17, 2021

Agree with most of these but Robin and Chopper are stronger then Brook. And Usopp's weaker then Nami.

Shanks’ YC2 is Lucky Roo.

 

[Jo_Ndule]

EXCLUDING M3 and Jinbe.
Jinbe is part of the M3 (fanmade concept btw, but we know its supposed to mean strongest 3...).

excluding Zoro, Luffy and Jinbe its very likely Sanji.
it could be Franky too though, I give you that.

Stop being a troll sometimes

Luffy
Zoro Sanji Jinbei
Franky
..

Franky can never be above Sanji.
RS Sanji > DJ Sanji > Base Sanji ~ Franky

 

[trav]

Franky can never be above Sanji.

what a strange statement to make when Franky already IS above Sanji.

 

[Nolimittweezy]

Based on Yamato being Kaido's daughter‚ she is obv strong‚ but she has no feats to support it. If nami manages to strike ulti‚ then Yamato ohko'ing ulti is even less impressive.

This is such a dumb take since Nami’s attacks are quite powerful

 

[Pan D. A. Man]

Sanji for the moment.

But if Yamato joined right now she would funnily replace him until he shows better feats because even portrayal wise it's like that for now.

I can't see Sanji letting himself be that with Yamato. He prides himself on protecting women, so he would be automatically be stronger on times to help and save her even. Sanji still in M3, that won't ever change.

Post automatically merged: Feb 17, 2021

What the fuck is a Monster Trio?

Anyway, excluding Luffy, Zoro, and Jinbei, the obvious answer is Sanji.

Nah, Jimbei or Franky.

Post automatically merged: Feb 17, 2021

and normal sanji fans is rarity everywhere..

Everyone I talk to look fine, so far I only seen Zoro side of things been harassing them even in fanclub there. So I wouldn't put them on same scale as you guys. There can certain moments, but posting here on forcing Sanji in poll he isn't here is truly rent free in their minds lol.

Post automatically merged: Feb 17, 2021

typical tranji boys. They complain about "toxic" fandom but they ironically do the same thing they complained about.

Post automatically merged: Feb 16, 2021

and also this. The tranji fans like to play victim after their feeling got hurt

Tranji? Lol your truly toxic one if your saying like that and you do realize your being more homophobic with that statement than trying to hurt others. Not good look. Nothing I stated to you was toxic unlike you being quick to insult those if they disagree with you. Doesn't matter your feelings when it is set on status between Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji have always been.

 

[Lightbolt]

This is such a dumb take since Nami’s attacks are quite powerful

Nami's most powerful attack is a non haki infused lightning that takes ages to use...who is the strongest character that this would work on ?. Pre time skip strawhats survived enel's non haki lightning

 

[langitbarat]

Yamato, then.

At some point of time, Jinbe matched Ace in a 5 days long fight.
Roughly the same Ace matched base Yamato.
Safe to say hybrid Yamato is stronger than Jinbe, especially since she has better ancestry & younger.

EoS : Luffy > Zoro > Sanji > Yamato > Jinbe > Franky > Robin > Brook > Chopper > Nami > Usopp

 

[Bullet]

Obviously Franky
Don't know how Brook is even getting mentioned
Robin has a chance to be above Franky but not Brook

 

[Jailer]

Robin is just a bad match up for Brook, speed means nothing to her df she had Hakuba at her mercy. Unless he uses his soul/ice to somehow set himself free to some extend but idk.

 

[Bullet]

Yamato,

Shouldn't you be a strawhat first to be the strongest non monster trio strawhat?

 

[langitbarat]

Shouldn't you be a strawhat first to be the strongest non monster trio strawhat?

Yup. That's why I answered the question below that.

If Carrot joins, she will be between Robin and Brook.

 

[Lightbolt]

Yamato, then.

At some point of time, Jinbe matched Ace in a 5 days long fight.
Roughly the same Ace matched base Yamato.
Safe to say hybrid Yamato is stronger than Jinbe, especially since she has better ancestry & younger.

EoS : Luffy > Zoro > Sanji > Yamato > Jinbe > Franky > Robin > Brook > Chopper > Nami > Usopp

But that was pre whitebeard

Robin is just a bad match up for Brook, speed means nothing to her df she had Hakuba at her mercy. Unless he uses his soul/ice to somehow set himself free to some extend but idk.

If it is a direct matchup‚ can Brook or Robin even beat monster chopper one on one ? Pre timeskip at sabaody‚ sentomaru didn't seem concerned about the other strawhats‚ he got only concerned when he saw monster chopper

 

[langitbarat]

But that was pre whitebeard

Yes, and all three didn't have much jump in powers (they already have their df/power). We can even say that Jinbe able to match Ace because of matchup (fire vs water), whereas base Yamato match Ace just fine without elemental advantage.

If we saw hybrid yamato vs ace, then jinbe > yamato.

 

[Jailer]

But that was pre whitebeard

If it is a direct matchup‚ can Brook or Robin even beat monster chopper one on one ? Pre timeskip at sabaody‚ sentomaru didn't seem concerned about the other strawhats‚ he got only concerned when he saw monster chopper

Monster Chopper is his strongest form, intimidating but they can beat him. Robin can just spawn her giant limbs to strain him, one breaj for Chopper to break free is to swtich back and forth between his forms. While Brook is too fast for Monster Chopper and could probably use some freezing attack to slow him down.

 

[ShinichiMugi]

Altough in my ranking i put Jinbei above Sanji,i think Sanji will soon surpass Jinbei,because Sanji is younger and can improve more. And around a few chapters ago,i would have put Jinbei above Zoro's too! Because Jinbei has more experience than both Zoro and Sanji. But now that Zoro is fighting Kaido,that is giving him more experience so i decided to put him above Jinbei. But Sanji is destined to surpass Jinbei too,very soon.

 

[Finalbeta]

Altough in my ranking i put Jinbei above Sanji,i think Sanji will soon surpass Jinbei,because Sanji is younger and can improve more. And around a few chapters ago,i would have put Jinbei above Zoro's too! Because Jinbei has more experience than both Zoro and Sanji. But now that Zoro is fighting Kaido,that is giving him more experience so i decided to put him above Jinbei. But Sanji is destined to surpass Jinbei too,very soon.

Well I agree about Sanji being soon stronger than Land Jinbe. Thanks to the RS...

Overall the fact is Zoro has never unleashed Asura and there's virtually no reason why he doesn't bear it anymore, so it has most likely been a long long time since Zoro surpassed the Fishman.

 

[executor partner]

Monster Trio doesn't even exist. There are only two monsters in the SH crew and they are the ones who founded the crew and also the only ones fighting against two Yonko in the rooftop in a "Battle of monsters".

I'd say after these two and Jimbei the strongest has to be Franky, the man is an engineering genius after all and he doesn't rely on dad's tech to boost his durability like someone else we know.

 

[PurpleSwordsman]

Luffy
Zoro/Sanji
Jinbei/Franky
Robin/Brook
Chopper
Nami/Usopp

 

[Hiragaro]

Why is Chopper in the poll?!