General & Others TOP 5 underrated and overrated characters

Topi Jerami

Topi Jerami

‎
#50
#50
Basically you guys are just doing

Underrated:
1. Character that I like
2. Character that I like
3. Character that I like
4. Character that I like
5. Character that I like

Overrated:
1. Character that I don't like
2. Character that I don't like
3. Character that I don't like
4. Character that I don't like
5. Character that I don't like


But for once, let's actually think what Oda sees in nowadays fandom. Oda would write the list something like this:
Underrated:
1. Akainu (Whitebeard two shotted him :rolleyes:)
2. Fujitora (he is weakest Top Tier!! :rolleyes:)
3. Doflamingo (he is below Crack... who is that guy again who appeared once then got sent flying to another manga?)
4. Jack (Jack the Dragdown!! Jack the Ls!!! :rolleyes: While Oda builds him as the next Kaido. Unkillable. Faced whole island of Natural Born Warriors and their 2 Kings, faced Admiral Fujitora, former Fleet Admiral Sengoku, and Vice Admiral Tsuru, faced thousand years old island sized beast Zunisha, faced Oden's strongest scabbard, Ashura Douji -> no one can put down Jack for real.)
5. Pre TS Zoro (learned advanced CoA before the word "haki" is mentioned, endured 2 Mihawk's attacks and Luffy's pain + his own pain)
 
TheAncientCenturion

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
#51
#51
Topi Jerami said:
Basically you guys are just doing

Underrated:
1. Character that I like
2. Character that I like
3. Character that I like
4. Character that I like
5. Character that I like

Overrated:
1. Character that I don't like
2. Character that I don't like
3. Character that I don't like
4. Character that I don't like
5. Character that I don't like


But for once, let's actually think what Oda sees in nowadays fandom. Oda would write the list something like this:
Underrated:
1. Akainu (Whitebeard two shotted him :rolleyes:)
2. Fujitora (he is weakest Top Tier!! :rolleyes:)
3. Doflamingo (he is below Crack... who is that guy again who appeared once then got sent flying to another manga?)
4. Jack (Jack the Dragdown!! Jack the Ls!!! :rolleyes: While Oda builds him as the next Kaido. Unkillable. Faced whole island of Natural Born Warriors and their 2 Kings, faced Admiral Fujitora, former Fleet Admiral Sengoku, and Vice Admiral Tsuru, faced thousand years old island sized beast Zunisha, faced Oden's strongest scabbard, Ashura Douji -> no one can put down Jack for real.)
5. Pre TS Zoro (learned advanced CoA before the word "haki" is mentioned, endured 2 Mihawk's attacks and Luffy's pain + his own pain)
Click to expand...
That's not fair. I'm a fan of every character but Linlin on the overrated side.
 
Shiroyru

Shiroyru

‎
#52
#52
Topi Jerami said:
Basically you guys are just doing

Underrated:
1. Character that I like
2. Character that I like
3. Character that I like
4. Character that I like
5. Character that I like

Overrated:
1. Character that I don't like
2. Character that I don't like
3. Character that I don't like
4. Character that I don't like
5. Character that I don't like


But for once, let's actually think what Oda sees in nowadays fandom. Oda would write the list something like this:
Underrated:
1. Akainu (Whitebeard two shotted him :rolleyes:)
2. Fujitora (he is weakest Top Tier!! :rolleyes:)
3. Doflamingo (he is below Crack... who is that guy again who appeared once then got sent flying to another manga?)
4. Jack (Jack the Dragdown!! Jack the Ls!!! :rolleyes: While Oda builds him as the next Kaido. Unkillable. Faced whole island of Natural Born Warriors and their 2 Kings, faced Admiral Fujitora, former Fleet Admiral Sengoku, and Vice Admiral Tsuru, faced thousand years old island sized beast Zunisha, faced Oden's strongest scabbard, Ashura Douji -> no one can put down Jack for real.)
5. Pre TS Zoro (learned advanced CoA before the word "haki" is mentioned, endured 2 Mihawk's attacks and Luffy's pain + his own pain)
Click to expand...
Akainu also has a lot of people saying that he can casually punch holes in Kaido/BM.
Fujitora is kinda underrated since people put him below the C3.
Doflamingo is rated just fine on average
Jack is actually overrated. People put him above Cracker for no good reason despite Cracker having better feats.
Lol
 
True God Moe

True God Moe

‎
#53
#53
TheAncientCenturion said:
Underrated
  1. Crocodile
  2. Kizaru
  3. Queen
  4. Mr. Vergo
  5. Sanji
Overrated
  1. Zoro
  2. Pica
  3. Big Mom
  4. Katakuri
  5. Luffy
Click to expand...
I agree on this list. Though Sanji isn't underrated, just cries of 'small group' who thinks that as he still comes at top in popularity polls at 3-4 positions each time and doing great in his fights lately as well too. Expect more feats in Wano as they prepare for war.

Why you think Queen and Kizaru are underrated though?
 
TheAncientCenturion

TheAncientCenturion

I will never forgive Oda
‎‎‎
#54
#54
True God Moe said:
I agree on this list. Though Sanji isn't underrated, just cries of 'small group' who thinks that as he still comes at top in popularity polls at 3-4 positions each time and doing great in his fights lately as well too. Expect more feats in Wano as they prepare for war.

Why you think Queen and Kizaru are underrated though?
Click to expand...
Kizaru gets a bad (well, not bad but not equal) rap because his relevancy hasn't been as high as Akainu's or Kuzan's. For a few years now I've seen him scaled very low, especially compared to his contemporaries. Queen gets it bad for being beaten by O'Lin in his Zoan form, which isn't really fair for him. He didn't use Haki, was throttled by the head/neck, and wasn't using his strongest form.
 
Gol D. Roger

Gol D. Roger

ȶɦɛ քɨʀǟȶɛ ӄɨռɢ
‎
#55
#55
Edward Teach said:
There's a difference between overrating admirals with baseless statements and giving Akainu the position context places him in.

this post will end the Yonko vs Admiral debate and you will find the sense in it if you're a non-biased reader.

Overall, the Yonko are indeed more powerful than the current admirals. however, there should essentially be a single navy man capable of fighting one of them. in every supreme organization we can find that their strongest could fight a Yonko on equal footing. in the Revolutionary Army we got Dragon, among the Warlords there's Mihawk, in the Marine there was Garp and Sengoku. but the last two are much weaker than when they were in their prime days, yet the marine now are more powerful than before as Jinbe stated. how could this be correct if there is not a single man able to stand up to a Yonko among the organization that withstood the strokes of time for hundreds of years ? analyzing the context can clear this out for you.

Who has the highest influence between pirates ? the Yonko
Who has the highest influence between marines ? the Fleet Admiral

Sakazuki is indeed the Marines "Yonko" now and the navy admirals are below that level of strength. The only reason why Garp didn't become an admiral or fleet admiral before Sengoku is because he utterly despise the celestial dragons. Kong could have made Garp the fleet admiral after God Valley incident easily but Garp simply didn't want to. Sengoku on the other hand had no 1v1 fights to usurp the title unlike Sakazuki who took it by his own strength. so that's a direct parallel between Garp and Sakazuki.

During the time skip there was also two big changes Jinbe told Luffy about. Blackbeard becoming Yonko and Akainu becoming FA. yet we see another parallel hinting here between the two status being so much important to be a huge shocking news to the world. standing on top of the pirates and marine hierarchy respectfully. no Akainu won't punch holes on Kaido and Big Mom, admirals didn't stomp Whitebeard, neither the latter did. if we exterminate all these empty squabbles you can find logical verdict.

Yonko > Admiral
Yonko = Flee Admrial

We can end this debate now.
Click to expand...
A fleet admiral is just another admiral with more authority. You don't magically get a boost in power with a promotion. Strength alone doesn't warrant the FA position for an admiral. If the higher-ups in the WG didn't oppose Sengoku's decision to make Aokiji the FA then he'd have been the one to replace Sengoku instead of Akainu despite him being a tad-bit weaker than Akainu in comparison. Even if Garp is willing to become the FA, I don't think he'd be preferred over Sengoku for the FA position. The fleet admiral along with the three admirals exists to counterbalance the 4 emperors.
 
Blackbeard

Blackbeard

‎
#56
#56
Gol D. Roger said:
A fleet admiral is just another admiral with more authority. You don't magically get a boost in power with a promotion. Strength alone doesn't warrant the FA position for an admiral. If the higher-ups in the WG didn't oppose Sengoku's decision to make Aokiji the FA then he'd have been the one to replace Sengoku instead of Akainu despite him being a tad-bit weaker than Akainu in comparison. Even if Garp is willing to become the FA, I don't think he'd be preferred over Sengoku for the FA position. The fleet admiral along with the three admirals exists to counterbalance the 4 emperors.
Click to expand...
We should see about that.
 
True God Moe

True God Moe

‎
#58
#58
TheAncientCenturion said:
Kizaru gets a bad (well, not bad but not equal) rap because his relevancy hasn't been as high as Akainu's or Kuzan's. For a few years now I've seen him scaled very low, especially compared to his contemporaries. Queen gets it bad for being beaten by O'Lin in his Zoan form, which isn't really fair for him. He didn't use Haki, was throttled by the head/neck, and wasn't using his strongest form.
Click to expand...
Hmmm...Good point, but never seen it that bad on that lvl as Kizaru is still heavy respected around even to them and possible could pull have same feats as them after all.

Really? Many actually praised Queen more lately on many websites even here as favorable out of Calamities and said he is the first YC to hurt an Yonko being BM, so hear more good praises than bad about him. Also like you said, he wasn't even using his full power in the fight and still got more to show especially in upcoming stages.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top