Kidd, I’ll admit doesn’t seem to have been doing anything that would cause serious damage. But Killer actually did do some damage and he didn’t have any “anti feats” I’m aware of to knock him down way below everyone else on the roof. If you are willing to grant Kidd his portrayal I don’t know what Killer has done to not get credit for his one good portrayal. I could understand if he was used as a hype tool or clowned on during the roof fight but he wasn’t.
Does it make sense for Killer to be >>>>> everyone else on the roof to you? That would be an odd choice for Oda to have 4 of the roof fighters be legit and then the 5th to be veteran level. If Kaido and BM would have singled him out as not belonging I would get it.
Some of the Scabbards are apparently YC level (Inu, Neku, Asura, and likely Denjiro). We’ve seen 3 of them against Jack, and Inu looks like Jack’s 1v1.
By portrayal Killer should at least be relative to Sanji.