Character Discussion Roger loved his sword

[mugiwalaw]

WSS, swordsman or not swordsman with a sword just show us that Oda's logic is broken, there' no clear indicators

 

[HA001]

WSS, swordsman or not swordsmam just show us that Oda's logic is broken, there' no clear indicators

Yes I mean clearly showing people fighting with a sword coating their sword in haki using named sword attacks with named swords is too vague to call them swordsmen...

 

[Human D Luffy]

It doesnt even matter if Roger is a swordsman or not. Even if I give you that he is, he is still stronger than Mihawk the man who got shook by old whitebeard

Mihawk was never shook by old whitebeard. He just respected WB a lot, thats all.
I think prime WB > Mihawk > Old WB.

 

[MagmaDog]

vista the 1b man could only stall mihawk and mihawk wasn t even looking

glad we gonna see 2 black blades zoro with asura and adv coc against mihawk

Can you not read my friend. The vivre card said equal or superior. Nothing about mihawk holding back

Imagine Roger asking Vista to postpone a fight. But then again we already know what Roger does to top tier swordsman.

No postponing needed

 

[mugiwalaw]

Yes I mean clearly showing people fighting with a sword coating their sword in haki using named sword attacks with named swords is too vague to call them swordsmen...

nah i mean what related to Mihawks title, as the thing goes more developed saddly this title startin to make no more sense.

 

[KageFumi]

Yes
Yes
EoS Zoro 3 permanent black blades > roger none

Lmao, the thread got deleted.

 

[Zowo]

Can you not read my friend. The vivre card said equal or superior. Nothing about mihak holding back

Imagine Roger asking Vista to postpone a fight. But then again we already know what Roger does to top tier swordsman.

No postponing needed

roger was trying mihawk wasn t
not even a yonko can kill mihawk s boredom
zoro with hyriu kaen sents oden flying like a bug if he tries to block it ofc
if not he dies
apparently the most durable creature had to dodge it

 

[Human D Luffy]

Can you not read my friend. The vivre card said equal or superior. Nothing about mihawk holding back

Imagine Roger asking Vista to postpone a fight. But then again we already know what Roger does to top tier swordsman.

No postponing needed

1) Mihawk is the world's strongest swordsman. That title is pretty much indisputable.
2) the vivre card said that vista equal in swordsman with mihawk "in that fight". that can be true too, because clearly mihawk wasn't fighting seriously. i wont even call it a fight because they basically just traded a few blows in total. so you can even argue that vista demonstrated better swordsmanship in that moment, given that mihawk wasnt trying his hardest.

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

What the fuck? Who moved my thread here?? You could at the very least have kept the poll.

 

[Garp the Fist]

What the fuck? Who moved my thread here?? You could at the very least have kept the poll.

Me, we don’t need two threads talking about Roger being a sword loony lol

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

Me, we don’t need two threads talking about Roger being a sword loony lol

Fine lol, but could you at least bring back the poll or add it again?

 

[Garp the Fist]

Fine lol, but could you at least bring back the poll or add it again?

I thought it would come with it tbh, usually merged polls stick around. What was the question and options?

 

[Light D Lamperouge]

I thought it would come with it tbh, usually merged polls stick around. What was the question and options?

Was Roger the biggest sword freak of OP? - the question

The options were
-Yes
-Yes
-EoS Zoro>Roger


Lmao. Thanks.

 

[Saint Figarland Garling]

Yes I mean clearly showing people fighting with a sword coating their sword in haki using named sword attacks with named swords is too vague to call them swordsmen...

Big Mom complies with almost everything you say and why is she not classified as a swordsman?

 

[MagmaDog]

1) Mihawk is the world's strongest swordsman. That title is pretty much indisputable.
2) the vivre card said that vista equal in swordsman with mihawk "in that fight". that can be true too, because clearly mihawk wasn't fighting seriously. so you can even argue that vista demonstrated better swordsmanship in that fight, given that mihawk wasnt trying his hardest.

"MIhawk wasnt fighting seriously at all"

Prove it. Because the man himself says he doesn't hold back. Post some evidence in the manga he wasn't fighting vista seriously.

 

[Zowo]

Big Mom complies with almost everything you say and why is she not classified as a swordsman?

law is by oda himself
and please don t compare big mom with roger
roger has no fruit
only his swordsmanship and haki just like oden ray zoro mihawk etc

 

[Human D Luffy]

"MIhawk wasnt fighting seriously at all"

Prove it. Because the man himself says he doesn't hold back. Post some evidence in the manga he wasn't fighting vista seriously.

now you are just over analyzing a panel, just to prove your point.
after you realized that vista was never equal to mihawk, but only equal swordsmanship "in that fight".... LOL
so is akainu a dog because they called him red dog? LOL
apply logic, don't take every word as it is. that is elementary school tier manga reading dude.

yeah his blade knows no restrain, but you haven't seen him use one named attack... so your conclusion is.....

 

[Saint Figarland Garling]

law is by oda himself
and please don t compare big mom with roger
roger has no fruit
only his swordsmanship and haki just like oden ray zoro mihawk etc

So fujitora if he is a sword user and not swordsman as the image of the manga says and then since he has fruit, it is not under the title of mihawk as you say

 

[HA001]

Big Mom complies with almost everything you say and why is she not classified as a swordsman?

Who said she isn't.

 

[Zowo]

So fujitora if he is a sword user and not swordsman as the image of the manga says and then since he has fruit, it is not under the title of mihawk as you say

Kaku another fruit user is a swordsman
Shyriu king etc
Fuji is no exception klol
He s even based on a blind swordsman from a japanese movie