Status
Not open for further replies.
The doc has been kinda low key this game @Dr_Professor83 gimme your thoughts so far bro!
Still getting comfortable with this D1 stuff, but I’ll definitely share my main thoughts floating around rn:

Lind being the 3rd person to claim Miller (even if a different type of Miller) seems like it would be more town indicative than anything else. I’d think fake claiming Miller after two people have already claimed it would be really risky as Scum.

Based on my one game of experience with Light as Scum, I can at least say this would be a very different game for Scum Light than the last one. Last game aside from night actions they were basically a chameleon. This game on the other hand they are drawing loads of attention between claiming Miller and the PR thing. The PR stopping at 5 seems like a really weird fake. If they were going to devise a fake PR I’d think it would be more standard instead of being so unusual.

Cal not RIPping into you for your vote on him seems odd compared to the other game. He doesn’t seem as fiery rn but he also said he hasn’t really read the thread yet so maybe he’ll go rip mode here soon. It just pinged me as odd to see him so laid back based on what I knew coming into this game.

The Mango & Zara thing Idk what to think about. I don’t know either of them and Idk what to think about their conflict either. I’d like to revisit this whole thing with them D2. Mango has been posting really weird but Idk if that’s supposed to mean anything.

Hayumi is like a trillion times more active this game than the other one. I didn’t even get to know them last game they were so inactive lol. I see everyone joking about their active Scum meta but I’m not going to make any judgements on them for that. I’d rather wait and see for myself what I think. But still the difference in activity is staggering lol.

T-Pein is vote switching like crazy. Idk what’s up with that. I don’t feel like that would be a good move as Scum. Seems like Scum wouldn’t want to draw that much attention to themselves for no reason.

Got kind of a weird ping on you for questing why I’d be afraid of an invest as a Newbie which felt weird. I feel like any Miller would be worried about invest results if they didn’t claim Miller. That just seems too common sense to be a concern.

Conquistador seems genuinely Town to me based on that early Miller/invest interaction. I definitely didn’t like Zara wanting them vig’d when I haven’t seen anything Scummy from them yet.

None of this stuff really means much to me in isolation. I hate having to vote someone out with such little to go on, but if I had to pick someone right this second I’d pick Zara mostly for that Conquistador Vig comment. But I’m really glad I don’t have to vote just yet. I still want to keep observing.

I’d prefer something else to compare this stuff to so I can start connecting dots. Y’all think I’m being low activity compared to last game but last game’s D1 I was basically nonexistent and just sheeped Tobi since anything felt better than that Flower push, which felt illogical to me. Today we don’t even have something like that to go on. Last game I didn’t really pick up steam until later into D2 once we started getting some real stuff to go on.

This D1 stuff just really isn’t my speed yet. I like to be able to cross examine information and then come to a conclusion. This feels like stumbling in the dark and hoping in comparison.

Fam, I don't want newbies to feel pressured in their first games. It would drive them away if they learnt we are all secretly assholes lol. No seriously though, I just want them to experience the game more so that they learn to like it.

On that note, I too town read Conquist as I said earlier. I'm just null on Solis and Prof. Prof said previously that he doesn't have much to talk about this phase unlike last game. So I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt and wait until day 2.
Don’t worry lol. I’m plenty cool with trial by fire. Can’t scare me away that easily. I don’t expect anyone to go easy.
 

MangoSenpai

Arbiter of Truth
The Mango & Zara thing Idk what to think about. I don’t know either of them and Idk what to think about their conflict either. I’d like to revisit this whole thing with them D2. Mango has been posting really weird but Idk if that’s supposed to mean anything.

Do you not want to confront me?
 

Do you not want to confront me?
Idk what there really is to confront right now. You’ve been posting pretty weird, mostly just Kars memes besides that whole Zara thing that idk what to make of lol. You also said JoJo’s Part 1 is better than Part 3 I’m pretty sure, which is pretty appalling but probably not Scum indicative.
 
Summary for now:
2 miller claims - Light and Dr_Prof. and I don't scan anything on invests.
Zara has the most votes and Mango thinks Zara is scum who slipped.
Light is being accused of faking a miller claim and faking a post restriction by Dyna
Dyna is alright with a Mango or Hayumi claim
Desto and I think there are only 1 - 2 scum in the game currently. Could be wrong. And others think that's not the case.

And I think that's it so far. You'll have to read up to get a proper read if you want to.
Quoting this here so I can reference it as I read back
 
Buddying all the newbies? Noted.

Conquist is lock Town in my eyes. I don't think solis has reacted to the tiny amount of pressure/interactions they've had all that well, and Prof was actually way more present last game. Everyone gets a bit of the benefit of the doubt at the start, but I'd like Prof to be more active considering his strong rookie debut.
why is conquist lock town?
 

MangoSenpai

Arbiter of Truth
I like Johnathan fine but he’s my least favorite. I do like him as this paragon that you can trace the line back to.

Joseph is best JoJo so far. Then Jotaro. But I’ve only finished parts 1-4 so far.
I dislike Josuke so much I'd like to forget he exist, I've got an irrational disgust for that guy lmao.

And tbf, Koichi basically is the MC of P4 anyway, not a super big fan of Koichi either, but he's way better than Josuke anyway.

Let's kill da hoe
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top