[FNZ] Salem of Lies Round 2 - Town of Salem Test Take 2

[Dragomir]

I reread the first few pages to see what the response to Fuji's push on Flower was. Out of everyone who had talked about it, Mel looked the worst to me. I'm not liking her right now.

 

[Xlaw]

I think the way it transpired makes her look better, not worse.

Just saying it's odd is not a read. It's only a statement. Basic statements like those come off as disingenuous and fake as they don't really provide anything. They're CWAC. Contributing without actually contributing.

I would call it an opportunistic . And that's what I said in my earlier post , atleast one of the voter could wanted to hope for wagon to start.
We are starting with day phase..So we will see some people who may are try to wash their hands in wagon..

 

[Dragomir]

I would call it an opportunistic . And that's what I said in my earlier post , atleast one of the voter could wanted to hope for wagon to start.
We are starting with day phase..So we will see some people who may are try to wash their hands in wagon..

I believe that those who put some pushback against the wagon look worse than those who freely join in.

 

[Xlaw]

I believe that those who put some pushback against the wagon look worse than those who freely join in.

You are right with that too, its vice versa ! If Flower is the member of Mafia

 

[Fujishiro]

I reread the first few pages to see what the response to Fuji's push on Flower was. Out of everyone who had talked about it, Mel looked the worst to me. I'm not liking her right now.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

It didn't look like to me you read the last game because I claimed medium very early and in the dead chat I saw you say you think you know who the medium is and you wanted to privately pm Zem on guessing who the medium is.

i didnt read most of it, but i isoed fuji and xlaw on the last game if thats what ur referring to
i mostly read the writeups there

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I don't understand this logic. What do timezones have to do with Xlaw getting suspected?


How easy or hard it is to catch someone is irrelevant. Xlaw made a bad post and deserves to be suspected over it. Him having experience doesn't take that away. And I'm more confused as to how it makes him less likely to be mafia.

he never had to post anything is what im saying
he was not tagged, not forced, never had to save any teammate

his posts were completely by his own free will, in a timezone where everyone is offline and he could just hide in plain sight and we wouldnt know

him posting carefree despite all of this is a good sign more often than not, and while i dont think hes cleared in anyway, i just rather give him benefit of doubt over not because i dont think scum xlaw just ints this hard for no reason

 

[Dragomir]

@Lindltaylor get your butt over here. I want GTH reads on every single player in this game. Chop chop, on the dot.

Or else.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I believe that those who put some pushback against the wagon look worse than those who freely join in.

thats only if the wagon was town and they have tmi on it
we rly dont know flower's alignment yet to tell that, but if she was scum her scummates will not talk about her wagon directly, but instead try to create other wagons

something like what ur doing here, but a bit less obvious, so ur not looking too bad

 

[Dragomir]

he never had to post anything is what im saying
he was not tagged, not forced, never had to save any teammate

his posts were completely by his own free will, in a timezone where everyone is offline and he could just hide in plain sight and we wouldnt know

him posting carefree despite all of this is a good sign more often than not, and while i dont think hes cleared in anyway, i just rather give him benefit of doubt over not because i dont think scum xlaw just ints this hard for no reason

So you're saying that it would have been more beneficial for him as mafia to post when everyone's online as opposed to offline? I don't see how that's the case. He has to make an entrance post at some time. Why does it matter if it's done when ppl are online or offline?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

we agree on mel and trist at least
id like to add krog to them

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

So you're saying that it would have been more beneficial for him as mafia to post when everyone's online as opposed to offline? I don't see how that's the case. He has to make an entrance post at some time. Why does it matter if it's done when ppl are online or offline?

generally speaking its much easier to blend in and fluff an entrance when there r alot of ppl talking and discussing different stuff

entering like this when none is online brings unwanted attention, which what happened to xlaw exactly

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

not to mention when u enter the thread u want atleast one or more of ur scummates active at the time so u guys can power steer that thread to ur liking or make town focus on unimportant stuff

lone wolf is a dead wofl

 

[Dragomir]

thats only if the wagon was town and they have tmi on it
we rly dont know flower's alignment yet to tell that, but if she was scum her scummates will not talk about her wagon directly, but instead try to create other wagons

something like what ur doing here, but a bit less obvious, so ur not looking too bad

I don't think mafia would do that if Flower was one of them. The wagon on her is clearly not meant to be anything serious. There's no need to start creating a counterwagon to save her when she doesn't need that saving. Unless they genuinely believe that the 5 votes on her will accumulate to 10, getting capped off without her even posting, then I don't her buddies doing what you're saying right now.

Truthfully, I think Flower is more likely town than not here based on the response to her wagon. A bit of a premature read since she obviously hasn't said anything yet, but I like it.

 

[Dragomir]

generally speaking its much easier to blend in and fluff an entrance when there r alot of ppl talking and discussing different stuff

entering like this when none is online brings unwanted attention, which what happened to xlaw exactly

not to mention when u enter the thread u want atleast one or more of ur scummates active at the time so u guys can power steer that thread to ur liking or make town focus on unimportant stuff

lone wolf is a dead wofl

Never really looked at it like this tbh. I just enter whenever I want.

 

[Dragomir]

we agree on mel and trist at least
id like to add krog to them

I don't agree on Tris. Why Krogo?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I don't think mafia would do that if Flower was one of them. The wagon on her is clearly not meant to be anything serious. There's no need to start creating a counterwagon to save her when she doesn't need that saving. Unless they genuinely believe that the 5 votes on her will accumulate to 10, getting capped off without her even posting, then I don't her buddies doing what you're saying right now.

Truthfully, I think Flower is more likely town than not here based on the response to her wagon. A bit of a premature read since she obviously hasn't said anything yet, but I like it.

its too early to tell her alignment, but yea i dont think shes in any danger so her mates shouldnt be too worried rn

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Never really looked at it like this tbh. I just enter whenever I want.

its good for scum threadplay and powerwolfing
hard to do alone, but easier with multiple scums

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I don't agree on Tris. Why Krogo?

didnt like krogs vote on zem into doing nothing after and refusing to vote flower with us for w.e reason that was

ik hes done weird stuff and fluff as town b4 but u cant keep giving it free pass everytime

its just an early scum read that could change anytime if his play became more serious

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

anyway im off to sleep we can discuss more later