Should we keep D1 start in the game?


  • Total voters
    12
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Am I correct in saying that Juliet's claim of Sheriff basically confirms she's a Poisoner? Because Wris is either lying about being Poisoned, or Juliet coincidentally happened to target Wris as a role that also investigates out as Poisoner, who also happened to target Wris. My only reservation (and it's not a reservation really, which I'll get to in a sec) would be if there exists a scum role where they know they're targeted by a Sheriff. Wris could then fake claim being Poisoned to push a lynch onto the Sheriff.

A pretty stupid move unless I've misunderstood, because it relies on Wris claiming to be Poisoned before the Sheriff has a chance to claim their supposedly guilty results on Wris, and then almost certainly offers a 1:1 trade for scum because, if the real Sheriff is lynched off, and Wris doesn't die, and this hypothetical role exists, then Wris basically is almost certain to be scum, because why would any Doctor cure a Poisoned player who just led a mislynch on the Sheriff?

It actually feels too easy, but Mafia is a simple game sometimes.

Vote: Juliet
 

Light D Lamperouge

𝖂𝖍𝖆𝖙 𝕮𝖔𝖚𝖑𝖉 𝕳𝖆𝖛𝖊 𝕭𝖊𝖊𝖓
would be if there exists a scum role where they know they're targeted by a Sheriff. Wris could then fake claim being Poisoned to push a lynch onto the Sheriff.
I know that Arso gets told who visited them, experience from the previous game, but not the role just the people. I don't think there's any role that will tell you which roles visited you. And honestly it would be too ridiculous to out yourself this way to get rid of a Sheriff.
 

Emil

Kekko Taro
Am I correct in saying that Juliet's claim of Sheriff basically confirms she's a Poisoner? Because Wris is either lying about being Poisoned, or Juliet coincidentally happened to target Wris as a role that also investigates out as Poisoner, who also happened to target Wris. My only reservation (and it's not a reservation really, which I'll get to in a sec) would be if there exists a scum role where they know they're targeted by a Sheriff. Wris could then fake claim being Poisoned to push a lynch onto the Sheriff.

A pretty stupid move unless I've misunderstood, because it relies on Wris claiming to be Poisoned before the Sheriff has a chance to claim their supposedly guilty results on Wris, and then almost certainly offers a 1:1 trade for scum because, if the real Sheriff is lynched off, and Wris doesn't die, and this hypothetical role exists, then Wris basically is almost certain to be scum, because why would any Doctor cure a Poisoned player who just led a mislynch on the Sheriff?

It actually feels too easy, but Mafia is a simple game sometimes.

Vote: Juliet
juliet said she got "not guilty" on tris so that completely removes the possibility of tris being mafia thats pulling out a play to yeet the actual cop
 
Am I correct in saying that Juliet's claim of Sheriff basically confirms she's a Poisoner? Because Wris is either lying about being Poisoned, or Juliet coincidentally happened to target Wris as a role that also investigates out as Poisoner, who also happened to target Wris. My only reservation (and it's not a reservation really, which I'll get to in a sec) would be if there exists a scum role where they know they're targeted by a Sheriff. Wris could then fake claim being Poisoned to push a lynch onto the Sheriff.
There is no such role.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I know that Arso gets told who visited them, experience from the previous game, but not the role just the people. I don't think there's any role that will tell you which roles visited you. And honestly it would be too ridiculous to out yourself this way to get rid of a Sheriff.
Pretty much exactly my point.
 
As I mentioned earlier, I thought she was on her "scum meta". Like low post count. And she was just talking about you almost the whole phase.

This is why I find it weird that she targeted me instead of you. Or even Fuji.
?

I don't have a scum meta.

In one of my completed tos games I had very low post count on day 1. I was the veteran and I killed the investigator on night 2 or night 3 I can't remember which night it was when I killed the investigator for going on alert and the investigator was also suspecting me for having low post count.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top