[FNZ] Salem of Lies Round 3 : Town Of Salem

[ALI!]

No? I said, very clearly, "Ekko, how certain are you of this" and he replied "10/10". That tells me, should his rationale hold, he is certain his target is scum. If he's lying there, then he will get lynched after. I then, very clearly once again, said if Ekko tries to wiggle out of this I'll vote him instead. He then tries to wiggle out of it, so I voted him. All of this is in the thread. You, for some reason, are ignoring it so you can haracterise fairly NAI behaviour as scummy.

Yeah but that doesn't prove anything, you could still be scum who saw an open opportunity to mislynch a townie/scum from another faction and if things don't go right, you could easily say I told ekko who assured me he was 10/10 sure.

The move itself is scummy, you don't ever vote people based on a question you ask to someone who's not even town confirmed lol

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

i do still think don's reaction is bad but i wouldnt jump the gun

the new feedback system got me offguard so rip

 

[Ratchet]

cmon ratchet we r nakama

unless u r scum

Sure, but you're still scum.

i can only be escort, exec or jester lol

3 roles which u shud not focus on day 1 mr. ratchet

Why can you only be those? You're not town lol, not even close. Hey, if you're a Jester, I'm giving you your win here.

 

[MistyCatGoddess]

And

vote lynch @Fruitji

to give it some more urgency

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Sure, but you're still scum.
Why can you only be those? You're not town lol, not even close. Hey, if you're a Jester, I'm giving you your win here.

no im town but u arent speaking like a nakama now

i can only be those 3, im asking ur rn, what other role benefits from what i do

100 word essay pls

 

[Ratchet]

Yeah but that doesn't prove anything, you could still be scum who saw an open opportunity to mislynch a townie/scum from another faction and if things don't go right, you could easily say I told ekko who assured me he was 10/10 sure.

The move itself is scummy, you don't ever vote people based on a question you ask to someone who's not even town confirmed lol

The move itself isn't scummy. Ekko was offering a 1:1 trades. 1:1 trades always benefit town. I was following that process, until it no longer appeared prudent to do so. "you could be scum" isn't an argument.

 

[Ratchet]

no im town but u arent speaking like a nakama now

i can only be those 3, im asking ur rn, what other role benefits from what i do

100 word essay pls

Why can you be only one of those 3?

 

[AL sama]

I feel like ekko s chaos is giving scum the easiest d1 of their lifetimes

the chaos he caused for so long is making me read him as town

a scum would really need to be dumb to do such a thing

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

The move itself isn't scummy. Ekko was offering a 1:1 trades. 1:1 trades always benefit town. I was following that process, until it no longer appeared prudent to do so. "you could be scum" isn't an argument.

not if im exec or jester, in that case 1:1 just wasted town's time and got me my win

and if don is town as well then that's even worst cuz we actually lose 2 townies if ur gna yeet don then yeet me

looks pretty bad on u to try and chain that

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Why can you be only one of those 3?

because they r the only roles that benefit from what i did

ur still unable to tell me other role that benefit from it

 

[MistyCatGoddess]

the chaos he caused for so long is making me read him as town

a scum would really need to be dumb to do such a thing

Same and he's allowing other things to slip under the radar. Therefore I am trying to change topic now cause we are going nowhere

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

@Ratchet u said it urself a 1:1 always benefits the majority

why would i, a scum/indie ekko, put myself in a 1:1 scenario to harm my faction

as per ur own logic, it makes no sense for me to be scum

so i can only be town escort, or the only 2 non town roles that benefit from it: exec and jester

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

if u can find me a 4th role that i can be ur welcomed to discuss it

 

[Ratchet]

not if im exec or jester, in that case 1:1 just wasted town's time and got me my win

and if don is town as well then that's even worst cuz we actually lose 2 townies if ur gna yeet don then yeet me

looks pretty bad on u to try and chain that

I have no idea what you are in any scenario.

because they r the only roles that benefit from what i did

ur still unable to tell me other role that benefit from it

You keep saying this, but the "why" is what I'm asking.

@Ratchet u said it urself a 1:1 always benefits the majority

why would i, a scum/indie ekko, put myself in a 1:1 scenario to harm my faction

as per ur own logic, it makes no sense for me to be scum

so i can only be town escort, or the only 2 non town roles that benefit from it: exec and jester

Well that's the issue lol. You initially presented it as a 1:1 trade, and then backed off of it when you needed to substantiate it. That, my friend, is scummy.

 

[AL sama]

Same and he's allowing other things to slip under the radar. Therefore I am trying to change topic now cause we are going nowhere

any thoughts on sallu rhea or x??

btw I've had my bad moments too so what do you think about me??

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I have no idea what you are in any scenario.
You keep saying this, but the "why" is what I'm asking.
Well that's the issue lol. You initially presented it as a 1:1 trade, and then backed off of it when you needed to substantiate it. That, my friend, is scummy.

huh i backed off cuz the host cleared the issue?
what u want me to tunnel him for no reason now?

 

[Ratchet]

huh i backed off cuz the host cleared the issue?
what u want me to tunnel him for no reason now?

Awfully convenient.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Awfully convenient.

agreed but it is what it is

 

[Destroya]

anyway lets ask real questions now

what r the chances which controls nick to AL
or consort roleblocks AL

AL is a good player so is a decent mafia target n1

its possible they roleblocked him which made it come to me, meaning my roleblock failed on don not because he is immune, but because i was roleblocked

its why i was asking if any townie targeted AL, but none said they did
so have to assume only mafia targeted AL, or simply none targeted AL at all

this means:
1. AL got roleblocked by mafia / witch controlling nick
OR
2. Don is immune to roleblocks

pick ur best bet

Now excuse me for talking mechanics because I still don't understand all these roles, but there's no real way to prove Mafia RB'd Al even if we lynch Don, yeah? So we have the possibility that Don is Wolf based on what you're saying, but if we lynch him and he flips Town, option one could be the reality we're in and then we lynched a townie and still didn't obtain anymore additional info, yeah? Like there is a world where the three of you could be Town, it just means Mafia targeted Al, right? There's also a world where you are Jester (doubtful) or Exe (more possible) which makes this Don lynch seem kind of risky and sketchy.

 

[Destroya]

With that being said, I still think we had people jump on the Don wagon fairly easily despite all of this confusion.