[FNZ] Salem of Lies Throne of Lies IV: A Halloween Special

[Zemmi]

@Flower are you 100% certain Midnight wasnt claiming something?

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

My case is there, but sure, let me lay it out clearly:

Firstly, I was trying to game solve. I thought Mid and Zem made contradictory statements which needed clearing up because in games with set mechanics there can only be one truth. Then Tuna tried shading me by saying I was pushing a narrative when I did no such thing. Quite the opposite, if they indeed contradicted each other I would have caught scum that way. Apparently they didn't, though, so I put that topic to rest now. Tuna himself was in a statement vs statement situation just last ToS game with the fake Psychic claim and knows how that works. Yet he didn't understand what I was doing? Bullshit. First red flag.

Then he votes on a wagon I started, despite supposedly scum reading me. When questioned he didn't even explain how both Ultra and me could be scum. He just reiterated what he did so far in the thread. Second red flag.


And then instead of addressing my points, he's just voting me. Third red flag.

Past games are irrelevant what applied then was for that setting and this. I dont see why you are bringing up something very irrelevant and try to make it such. The circumstances in that game were completely different and not similar at all.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

If his post was deleted he is really silenced, since deleting is against the rules.

I also don't think a pretender would have any reason to silence him, so I think that would lean that an actual scum silenced him.

I wish I was the pretender again this game, such a fun role lol.

Now that you mention pretender, I see that role post was very recently added to the role wiki so maybe Drago thought of including it in the game. Hmm interesting.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

It was a summary of what happened. Not a thought process. I wanted you to explain how Ultra and me could both be scum. You didn't.

you said this like 3 times flower. try a different angle because this clearly iant working

yo imma sign off,
who we lynching?

not sure yet lol
give me ideas mang
other than kagura

 

[Flower]

Past games are irrelevant what applied then was for that setting and this. I dont see why you are bringing up something very irrelevant and try to make it such. The circumstances in that game were completely different and not similar at all.

They are. It's another game with set mechanics and rules. In such games there is no in between.

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

They are. It's another game with set mechanics and rules. In such games there is no in between.

Its not the same situation at all not even close.

 

[Zemmi]

Now that you mention pretender, I see that role post was very recently added to the role wiki so maybe Drago thought of including it in the game. Hmm interesting.

I was it last game. That is why I know how it works and I also know they would have zero reason to use it on Ultra.

 

[Flower]

@Flower are you 100% certain Midnight wasnt claiming something?

I'm just working with the thought that it was just Midnight being Midnight. I might be wrong, sure, but I don't see why he would do that unless he wanna get lynched.

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

you said this like 3 times flower. try a different angle because this clearly iant working


not sure yet lol
give me ideas mang
other than kagura

Out of curiousity why kagura

 

[Zemmi]

I'm just working with the thought that it was just Midnight being Midnight. I might be wrong, sure, but I don't see why he would do that unless he wanna get lynched.

I still feel he is shady and I don't like his style of confusing and making town a mess. Kinda annoyed with him, so I am still fully happy to lynch him.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I already said people said we gonna vote inactives. So i changed my vote based of that. I said this multiple times. If they were going to change inactives then the flower vote wont be a thing anyways because she is very active which means i will just waste my vote. I didnt want to waste my vote so i changed my vote.

what do u think about voting someone that is post silence and being persistent about it?

 

[Zemmi]

Can scum actually silence a mate? That would seem very broken.

 

[Flower]

Its not the same situation at all not even close.

Yes, it is.

Imagine this:

It's a Cult game.
Cult has Paladin, but no Sheriff.

But then you have Mid claiming Paladin and Zem claiming Sheriff. But a Sheriff can't be in a Cult game, so Zem is lying.

Or vice-versa and Mid is lying.


It's just like Don saying one of us three was scum. But since we were all Town, it could only have been a lie.


There is no in between here.

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

what do u think about voting someone that is post silence and being persistent about it?

I dont like keeping my vote on people who cant defend themselves. If thats what you are asking. I think its bad overall to vote people who cant defend themselves.

 

[T-Pein™]

what do u think about voting someone that is post silence and being persistent about it?

lets lynch Alibaba then.

 

[Flower]

The fact you aren't comprehending this just makes you seem even less Town. Because a Town would understand that thought process.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I've never played as a indie so I myself don't know how I'd play with such a role. If I had to guess, if I was an Indie, I'd stay more aloof.

I'd not post much at all and meet my daily post requirement that's all.

thats a good way to get urself suspected lmao

Out of curiousity why kagura

because shes probably town and shudnt be considered for a yeet

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

lets lynch Alibaba then.

im still voting him
do u think we can get the numbers
he isnt feeling any pressure rn thats y hes just quiet

 

[ZoroSlaysDragonTuna]

They

Yes, it is.

Imagine this:

It's a Cult game.
Cult has Paladin, but no Sheriff.

But then you have Mid claiming Paladin and Zem claiming Sheriff. But a Sheriff can't be in a Cult game, so Zem is lying.

Or vice-versa and Mid is lying.


It's just like Don saying one of us three was scum. But since we were all Town, it could only have been a lie.


There is no in between here.

I dont understand? When did any of them openly claim anything? Werent one hinting and the other being weird as usual? Either i missed them or again its not claiming its assuming.
In that game 4 people claimed day one. One only claimed after getting caught in saying something untrue.
And two other had the same exact role: both were escort. Both open claimed.
Its not even close i can go on all day to point out how these situations are not even close to being the same.

 

[Zemmi]

The fact you aren't comprehending this just makes you seem even less Town. Because a Town would understand that thought process.

Someone could also find you questioning the situation as fishing until one of them confirmed a claim.