Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
It was rhetorical. And if you think I’m following your lead, you’re very much mistaken.
It's simple deduction. Of course if you'd rather flip Soul first, then that's your call. You have the information to parse in the quotes yourself, you can arrive at your own conclusions. It'll be the same as mine.
 
It's simple deduction. Of course if you'd rather flip Soul first, then that's your call. You have the information to parse in the quotes yourself, you can arrive at your own conclusions. It'll be the same as mine.
indeed, so why even assume I’m not cognisant of what the PoE situation looks like in the first place? Or at a minimum, would take the trouble to be ahead of EoD?
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
I've given you all the facts to work with. All the scum resides in Odd/Cal/Robin/Reborn/Soul

Odd claims he will die himself, so if he doesn't he gets lynched tomorrow. So you can take him off.

As per Worst's results, one Guilty has to be between Soul and Robin. Hence why common sense would suggest to flip here first.

Then you have Cal/Reborn left over.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
If Odd flips Town Cal would be next I would imagine, as then it'd be looking for the recruit. I can't imagine anyone recruiting Reborn in this context.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
In anyone’s opinion, is there a compelling plsy based reason for robin over reborn specifically? Or are we just number crunching
Yes, Worst's investigations results. They lead to the conclusion that one of Robin or Soul are Guilty. Like I just said, I've already gone over this.
 
The reason I’m asking specifically for a play based reason is we now have an outed indy/scum stating specifically that they have the ability to tamper with these results

might be bs, but have to account for it being true also
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top