[FNZ] Role Madness Game 03: One Piece Dressrosa

[Finalbeta]

Different time zone for Kiwi and Jew. Kiwi joined on day 3. It is 18:25 est in Canada so Kiwi Didn't active makes sense and Jew is usually active around 19:00. Jew is also new so I doubt he knows he should claim.

Their behaviour has been terribly suspicious this game. I feel they are both anti-town.

At least mechanically speaking this is what I'm seeing. My last post explains the thing.

Basically each town faction should be composed by 5 members then we might have 4 mafia and 2 indies or 5 mafia and 1 indie.

We already know who the 10 townies are and they haven't claimed yet just like Reborn.

 

[NeutralWatcher]

*it is 6:25 EST in Canada (corrected)

 

[Finalbeta]

Well technically we have 5 Executive and 4 Originals discovered thus far

We don't know Flower's role but she is supposed to be either Original or second indie in case the game has two indies.

It is clear someone is lying here. So they should claim.

 

[NeutralWatcher]

Their behaviour has been terribly suspicious this game. I feel they are both anti-town.

At least mechanically speaking this is what I'm seeing. My last post explains the thing.

Basically each town faction should be composed by 5 members then we might have 4 mafia and 2 indies or 5 mafia and 1 indie.

We already know who the 10 townies are and they haven't claimed yet just like Reborn.

The game started 9:32 pm est and Reborn asked for claim after Kiwi was offline. And Jew has been busy since yesterday and still a newbie.

 

[AL sama]

Sure but in that case the faction kill would be given to the entire group, right? And in that case only giving mafia the ability to kill one person each nights, which happened in all nights thus far except the second one where someone gained the mera

I pointed that out too

anyways beta after seeing how reborn played in the entire game your push on him doesn't make much sense rather its just making you look more scummy so I'd rather lynch you over him

vote lynch finalbeta

 

[Finalbeta]

I pointed that out too

anyways beta after seeing how reborn played in the entire game your push on him doesn't make much sense rather its just making you look more scummy so I'd rather lynch you over him

vote lynch finalbeta

AL try at least to read my reasonings before pushing for this.

You should be experienced enough to find my posts about mechanics fitting.

Kiwi and Jew have to claim because there are too many Executive and Originals here.

 

[AL sama]

The game started 9:32 pm est and Reborn asked for claim after Kiwi was offline. And Jew has been busy since yesterday and still a newbie.

aren't you new too??

 

[NeutralWatcher]

aren't you new too??

This is Jew first mafia game. I have played mafia with Final as host before this game.

 

[AL sama]

AL try at least to read my reasonings before pushing for this.

You should be experienced enough to find my posts about mechanics fitting.

Kiwi and Jew have to claim because there are too many Executive and Originals here.

I've been arguing with you since last day don't you think I've already read them??

yes I m suspecting jew a bit

 

[Finalbeta]

I've been arguing with you since last day don't you think I've already read them??

yes I m suspecting jew a bit

As I said I feel Denim provived scum with no fake claims since TAC didn't reveal character name when he could have and Rej only claimed Trebol because his abilities were fitting in Cavendish.

Also I feel Flower's role wasn't discovered perhaps in that neither TAC nor Rej used it.

So basically we could trust who claimed so far.

 

[Finalbeta]

In this scenario @Reborn @Kiwipom @Jew D. Boy should represent the remaining anti-town

They should claim because we have to catch liars here

 

[AL sama]

As I said I feel Denim provived scum with no fake claims since TAC didn't reveal character name when he could have and Rej only claimed Trebol because his abilities were fitting in Cavendish.

Also I feel Flower's role wasn't discovered perhaps in that neither TAC nor Rej used it.

So basically we could trust who claimed so far.

this isn't making sense after seeing rej's claim beta

 

[Finalbeta]

this isn't making sense after seeing rej's claim beta

It does because he clearly claimed Trebol as a last resource. Not because Denim gave him the fake claim.

Also otherwise how do you explain TAC didn't reveal his character name??

 

[Finalbeta]

Also how can you really believe my Pica claim is fake when I even thoroughtly worded it like the host did and explained my ability in detail?

 

[AL sama]

It does because he clearly claimed Trebol as a last resource. Not because Denim gave him the fake claim.

trebol is quite a big and risky claim if not provided as safe claim I can't see him taking thar big of a risk

also no one countered him

Also otherwise how do you explain TAC didn't reveal his character name??

in my opinion it was simply to confuse town

 

[Finalbeta]

trebol is quite a big and risky claim if not provided as safe claim I can't see him taking thar big of a risk

also no one countered him

He had no other choice but to claim something though. You are forgetting this crucial detail.

 

[AL sama]

Also how can you really believe my Pica claim is fake when I even thoroughtly worded it like the host did and explained my ability in detail?

I've seen many do that even more detailed

 

[Finalbeta]

in my opinion it was simply to confuse town

Lol AL he isn't so good at this game.

he would have insta claimed his character name if that could of saved his ass.

 

[AL sama]

He had no other choice but to claim something though. You are forgetting this crucial detail.

nope no one countered him which means trebol isn't in the game

don't you find it weird??

how lucky can someone get with that type of big claim??

 

[AL sama]

He had no other choice but to claim something though. You are forgetting this crucial detail.

he can't change?? lol