Break Week Onigashima is far bigger than Marineford

[Swallalala]

180M Saunjuan Wolf compared to Marineford

http://imgur.com/a/BxVIWh6

Now Onigashima

http://imgur.com/a/VtrnPbv

The umbrella alone is more than 4 times bigger than Saunjuan

@Fleet Admiral Lee Hung

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

180M Saun Wolf compared to Marineford

http://imgur.com/a/BxVIWh6

Now Onigashima

http://imgur.com/a/VtrnPbv

The umbrella is more than 4 times bigger than Saun

@Fleet Admiral Lee Hung

Go look up any of my Onigashima threads, I’m not repeating myself lol. There have been dozens of panels that show Onigashima as being much smaller than the one panel Yonko fans always resort to lol.

 

[Butters]

Are you guys really discussing sizes in inconsistent piece?

 

[Swallalala]

Go look up any of my Onigashima threads, I’m not repeating myself lol. There have been dozens of panels that show Onigashima as being much smaller than the one panel Yonko fans always resort to lol.

Just because Oda is inconsistent with sizes doesn’t mean Onigashima isn’t that big.

By your logic Katakuri isn’t 509cm tall because he looked smaller when he fought Luffy

 

[Lhulu]

180M Saunjuan Wolf compared to Marineford

http://imgur.com/a/BxVIWh6

Now Onigashima

http://imgur.com/a/VtrnPbv

The umbrella alone is more than 4 times bigger than Saunjuan

@Fleet Admiral Lee Hung

Imagine using pixel-scalling in One Piece.
Oda is too much inconsistent with sizes.

 

[Swallalala]

Imagine using pixel-scalling in One Piece.
Oda is too much inconsistent with sizes.

So Katakuri isn‘t 509cm tall because he looked smaller when he fought Luffy?

 

[Salah WG]

Go look up any of my Onigashima threads, I’m not repeating myself lol. There have been dozens of panels that show Onigashima as being much smaller than the one panel Yonko fans always resort to lol.

Numbers are around 60 Meters & seeing how they roam the Castle, it's obvious that it's Huge
Sanjuan Wolf was 180 M & he was almost as big as Marine HQ Building

Even thematically it's obvious, Onigashima is Portrayed as a Land where Ancient Giants feel like Humans there (Size Relativity)
But in Marineford, it was obvious that Little Oars Jr. looked too big for the place

No need for using Pixels & Panels at all

 

[Butters]

Btw if Onigashima is not that big, it have a lot of floors on it, this already make bigger than MF.

 

[SkySanji]

Five Marinefords would fit inside Onigashima easily, you can hardly even call Marineford an island in comparison.

 

[Sasparan]

60 meter Numbers are roaming in the castle. Onigashima is bigger.

 

[JoNdule]

Onigashima is where giants used to live
It make senses why it's bigger
The skull is way bigger and taller than MF building
Onigashima itself is also bigger than Marineford

 

[Swallalala]

60 meter Numbers are roaming in the castle. Onigashima is bigger.

@Fleet Admiral Lee Hung

 

[zenox]

since zoro cut the horn , let me give my views on this

-this gate can accommodate a number

- kaido's size to that gate

- number's size = oars at marineford , u can scale him to the size of that broken passage ( he can be a little smaller but it doesnt really mater much tbh )

- kaido's size to a horn ( u can even scale momo with it , since he is literally sitting there so there will be no difference in perspectives and angles )

- zoro cutting the horn

so yeah zoro can cut marineford in half with his range and aoe attack

 

[soheilhazrat]

so yeah zoro's can cut marineford in half with his range and aoe attack

He proved that in dressrosa

 

[AkainuTheGrimReaper]

Thousand sunny ship is about 56 meter height. Are you saying Whitebeard ship is smaller than thousand sunny ship ?

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1103703745337217025

 

[Steven]

We have a good calc which puts Oni at 16km.

Spoiler

28px = 42.1m (Height of Sunny's Mast)
103px = 155m (branch)
21px (background) = 155m (branch)
97px (background) = 715m (rock width)

Spoiler

32px = 715m
728px = 16266m

Spoiler

337px = 16266m (Island Width)
30px = 1448m (Horn Width)
269px = 12984m (Skull Width)
166px = 8012m (Horn length)

@Tyki_Mikk @Sentinel @MonsterKaido @Tejas @SkySanji

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

since zoro cut the horn , let me give my views on this

-this gate can accommodate a number

- kaido's size to that gate

- number's size = oars at marineford , u can scale him to the size of that broken passage ( he can be a little smaller but it doesnt really mater much tbh )

- kaido's size to a horn ( u can even scale momo with it , since he is literally sitting there so there will be no difference in perspectives and angles )

- zoro cutting the horn

so yeah zoro can cut marineford in half with his range and aoe attack

Good post. Marineford is like half the size of the rooftop

 

[Elder Lee Hung]

@Fleet Admiral Lee Hung

Marineford fit one hundred thousand troops inside of only the main plaza, including giants. This does not include the city surrounding the HQ, the HQ itself, and the watch towers that surrounded Marineford plaza.

So many people spend all their time comparing thie size of the skull and the Marine HQ Building that they forget that Marineford easily contained 3-4x the men that Kaido/the SHs had at Onigashima, in only one area of Marineford lol.

 

[Finalbeta]

Are you guys really discussing sizes in inconsistent piece?

Yep Oda is likely one of the worst mangaka when it comes to size accuracy

This is also why pixel scaling sucks as a method most of the time

 

[BerserkerLord3000]

a bigger dissapointment yeah