What, did some new information dropped about Onigashima size? If not then Onigashima is obviously bigger then Marineford.
Nah, I saw
@MarineHQ quote some post from here in another thread.
Found this thread and some of the posts here interesting, and wanted to necro this lmao.
Never understood how people actually believed this
Like straw hats travelled a big portion of the territory on foot within a few days
Even big islands in One Piece are only the size of a small/medium country IRL
Yeah, pixel scaling is obviously BS.
It's how we get nonsense like OP earth dwarfing real earth, continental Alabasta etc.
But really though, IMO the below argument is the most compelling:
Numbers are around 60 Meters & seeing how they roam the Castle, it's obvious that it's Huge
Sanjuan Wolf was 180 M & he was almost as big as Marine HQ Building
Even thematically it's obvious, Onigashima is Portrayed as a Land where Ancient Giants feel like Humans there (Size Relativity)
But in Marineford, it was obvious that Little Oars Jr. looked too big for the place
No need for using Pixels & Panels at all
*****************
I think the islands themselves are comparable.
Comparing just the main buildings...
Onigashima castle can comfortably hold several "numbers"
Marineford is a fort island, of which the building itself is a relatively small central figure. Lets say, the main building is around 10-20% of the total area.
Onigashima castle on the other hand, was almost as big as the island itself. It occupied like half of the area of the island