[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dr_Professor83

Dr_Professor83

False Idol
‎
#7,562
#7,562
hime said:
what changed ur read on me btw? all i see is an hr after u null read me, u replied to prof about me having 4 teammates and youve been saying im scummy since

we already established that prof messed up about the 7 member thing so im curious y u still think im scummy? if its the other stuff that prof said then what r ur thoughts on my reply to him? also u too @Dr_Professor83 cuz i dont think u replied to me either and there is no way im going to just be ignored :endthis:
Click to expand...

hime said:
as for the switching sides thing, that was bc inactives just started piling votes on him for no real reason. if i was scum and my team mate fucked up and was being called out by 2 good townie seeming players, i would rather put my vote earlier than later. most ppl r not going to expect scum to try and bus their teammate in the early stages of a wagon since bussing is usually subconsciously thought of as a last resort action. if the person flips red, then its almost like ur "cleared" or at least "half-cleared" for the rest of the game bc u joined the wagon really early on. at least this is coming from my own view and experience

after bringing up the bussing thing, i later admitted that i was probably overthinking things bc its just generally something ive ended up doing a lot in mafia in past games and i went with my best guess on arps alignment
Click to expand...
This thought process makes sense and I give you town points for that process paired out with you still not voting him. I think your response to Ultra looks good paired with this too in hindsight.

This doesn’t sound like a thought process I expect someone to manufacture in retrospect.
hime said:
and yes, i completely "turned on arp" if u could call it that. y should i have any reason to believe arp is not scum when i didnt strongly read him town in the first place and we had someone who copped him saying with 100% confidence that he got a guilty on arp? idk about u but im sure any townie in their right mind would trust the cop result bc the person claiming cop is literally outing themselves to push for the lynch and it was just dp2. obviously there could have been whacky results but if so, y would cop specifically say the result is "100% reliable"? it makes no sense to doubt someone who has made themselves a target and can be that confident in his result (unless he is bluffing and is scum and in that case we would just lynch him next dp)
Click to expand...
I’m ping’d any time someone talks in absolutes when we’re dealing with mechanics bc it sounds like possible tmi. You read Arp strongly enough to defend him on D1. To then spin and not even consider that there could be any shenanigans in the mechanics raises an eyebrow.

You also somewhat “pre flipped” Arp and painted Kagura as a possible teammate defending him which is something I can see scum doing with tmi there if they want to tie someone to a teammate that’s going down.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top