[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Dr_Professor83]

@Yo Tan Wa are you really just meant to be the king of the north lol.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

does this look genuine or faking it?
this was after we went bk to melkor from broki

she seems unware that melkor is already hammered and wanted the votes on him to grow to 12

eh

Read her posts she’s made toward me last night and today and tell me what you think.

 

[Emil]

u think kagu and LM could possibly be scum together? i feel like theres red between one of them but not both

wish u wud taken a stronger stance here instead of these safe reads on melkor/kagura that doesnt tell us anything

but then again if u r red, u probabaly already know lynch is getting redirected from melkor to broker. which means if melkor is red too, this would of been the PERFECT moment to just bus him, knowing full well its getting redirected anyway. having this wishy washy stance on melkor tells me ur not aligned with him

so here is my conclusion:
1. if melkor flips scum, im willing to say u r not red
2. if melkor flips town, u will be hard lynched

@Dr_Professor83 thats my take on hime for now

 

[Ratchet]

Am not convinced by the claim, I think. Forgetting actions Night 1, the target choices, they don't actually confirm anything. The best point in his favour is Cooler showing up, but he could easily have some TMI there.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Am not convinced by the claim, I think. Forgetting actions Night 1, the target choices, they don't actually confirm anything. The best point in his favour is Cooler showing up, but he could easily have some TMI there.

I’d need to look again where the cooler wagon was when he called cooler out for being a liar.

 

[Emil]

hime seems to be setting up a melkor/kagura double mislynch

in the event melkor ever flips town, hime needs to be throughouly looked at

 

[Emil]

Am not convinced by the claim, I think. Forgetting actions Night 1, the target choices, they don't actually confirm anything. The best point in his favour is Cooler showing up, but he could easily have some TMI there.

watcher will self resolve eventually

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Imagine Jon Snow, Arya, and Stannis being fake claims lol.

 

[Ratchet]

watcher will self resolve eventually

He says his ability is spent. Like most "power roles", he's claiming 3-shot Watcher. That's what we're getting.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

He says his ability is spent. Like most "power roles", he's claiming 3-shot Watcher. That's what we're getting.

Also just remembered that even if not we are about to all be vanilla soon according to the winter wu.

 

[Ratchet]

Imagine Jon Snow, Arya, and Stannis being fake claims lol.

I mean, Stannis isn't that big all told. He spends most of the time fairly antagonistic.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I mean, Stannis isn't that big all told. He spends most of the time fairly antagonistic.

He’s absolutely massive as a meme tho lol.

 

[Emil]

Vote Lynch Melkor​

vote melkor

Lol
[Vote lynch broker]

those came after we went bk to melkor
eh

 

[Emil]

I mean, Stannis isn't that big all told. He spends most of the time fairly antagonistic.

he was actually pretty hyped in season 2 battle of blackwater bay
he actually kicked ass there until tywin came to save the day

 

[Dr_Professor83]

those came after we went bk to melkor
eh

Phoenix’s logic on the Neeko - Hime switch seemed Town to me lol.

 

[Ratchet]

he was actually pretty hyped in season 2 battle of blackwater bay
he actually kicked ass there until tywin came to save the day

Wasn't it Tyrion who did most of the work?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I also continue to lean on Neeko being not red with the Selmy claim.

 

[Emil]

Phoenix’s logic on the Neeko - Hime switch seemed Town to me lol.

phoenix is the towniest there

ytw and neeko toss ups
ytw self resolves
neeko is an already claimed scum. take his slot with grain of salt

 

[Ratchet]

It's a shame, show had some good moments. Everything Season 5 onwards just goes into the gutter.

Might carry on with the books again, just got DWD left.

 

[Emil]

Wasn't it Tyrion who did most of the work?

they were going to lose despite all tyrion did
joeffry was gna get his ass kicked
cersei was about to kill her kids

actually wuda been a distaster without tywin there