[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Underworld Broker]

This is definitely for the Dead.

How would it work in this setup? Basically smth to take out the NK?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

which makes u vic lmao

 

[KWEH]

My opinion on the sword is, Gramma loves putting red herrings into games so unless I see someone flip zombie or thereabouts ima just discard it as such

 

[LethalBanks]

Sooo Lethal claimed after the night where he shot Melkor ya? In which case I don't see why scum would block him of all people unless they already knew his role which is a big IF.

Can somebody double check the Tywin flip and see if it says anything about results getting messed with or something? Because otherwise I don't think we can let Lethal off the hook.

Well I wasn't going to claim when the vig was alive was I lol. I was heavily in POE but wasn't even around to answer the queries.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

I used a Voyeur shot on him which lets me see what roles were used on my target that night. Other than mine, no roles were used on my target that night. Also Melkor didn't confirm getting visited by you apparently. So that's two people (one of them scum, fair enough) denying that you visited him at all.

they didnt plan it ahead in the chat
red team is total shambles

 

[KWEH]

do u get to learn the role of who u recruit/join chat with them

why havent u tried pot goblin lol
or cal

Oh, also I'm not told anything about my recruitment target apart from "recruitment was unsuccessful"

 

[KWEH]

Well I wasn't going to claim when the vig was alive was I lol. I was heavily in POE but wasn't even around to answer the queries.

Sure, my point is why would scum block you if you hadn't even claimed Backup Vig yet

 

[LethalBanks]

In this game, you have the following roles:

- Godfather (Your word will be considered final in the event of any factional dispute)

- 1x Bulletproof (You will survive the first regular killing action you are targeted with)

- Investigation Immunity (You will return favorable results to investigations attempting to unearth your alignment or role. Your alignment will appear as Rebellion Aligned, and your role as a Census)

- Alert Townie ( You will learn the identity of any visiting player)

- 2x Political Instinct (Once per cycle, you may enlist me to provide you with a hint regarding crafting a fake claim for you or your team)

- 2x Framer/Lawyer (You may target a player, and if they are non-mafia, they will investigate as Lannister Alliance Aligned, and if they are mafia, they will investigate as Rebellion Aligned. Does not work on Investigation Immune players)

- 1x Census (You may receive the current alignment split from me at any time)

@KWEH

I'm going with the unlikely block. Why would I shoot myself in the foot claiming a result that is so easily disproven through 2 players knowledge?

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

How would it work in this setup? Basically smth to take out the NK?

No idea but it is there for some purpose, in the show it was to counter the Dead.

 

[LethalBanks]

Sure, my point is why would scum block you if you hadn't even claimed Backup Vig yet

Fair point but do we know that it was scum itself to block me?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Aside from Tyrion, Dany, Jon Snow - I'm struggling to think of who else would fit. Jorah, maybe?

euron
and kweh is vic

or maybe... just maybe... has to look for littlefinger? is varys even interested lol

maybe olenna tyrell? cersei?

 

[KWEH]

they didnt plan it ahead in the chat
red team is total shambles

I agree that Lethals line of play as scum doesn't make any sense here, but I'm aware that botches happen and that Lethal is definitely the man for it as well.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Pein was being blocked every night so he didn’t have the chance of transferring the sword. Now it’s gone and you mean to say that it’s the only thing which can possible kill the NK? I think the mechanism to pass the sword won’t be easily blockable if the sword was meant to be passed and kept alive to make that kill. I just think it’s for flavour.

 

[KWEH]

Fair point but do we know that it was scum itself to block me?

We don't, but what does it matter? Why would anybody else block you if you're unclaimed?

The only thing I could see is a town Jailkeeper being on you that night but afaik nobody claimed as much, and also I recall T-Pein trying to pass swords to people which didn't work so I'm assuming the JK if they exist aren't town to begin with.

 

[Underworld Broker]

How would a framer work in that situation, lets say LM might've targeted Lethal, would he still show up on that kinda results, or not for the sake of "framing"? I think LM did try to go for lethal previous day and if he was his teammate he wouldve added him to his fake visits instead of him not being there, no?

 

[KWEH]

Like you're telling me they'd block you over T-Pein the claimed BG, or me who's been coming up with investigative results every day? Sorry, I don't see it.

 

[Underworld Broker]

@DoflaMihawk do u have anything to say to the current discussion?

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Pein was being blocked every night so he didn’t have the chance of transferring the sword. Now it’s gone and you mean to say that it’s the only thing which can possible kill the NK? I think the mechanism to pass the sword won’t be easily blockable if the sword was meant to be passed and kept alive to make that kill. I just think it’s for flavour.

It is an ability not a flavour,

 

[KWEH]

The thing giving me pause is that Melkor also didn't think to tell us that Lethal visited him, so there appears to be no coordination going on here at all if Lethal is scum. I'd call it unlikely if it weren't for the fact that I've seen and perpetrated worse botches than that myself.

 

[Ratchet]

why havent u tried pot goblin lol

He has.

it might be soulkiller ur looking for

He says it should be Littlefinger.