[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Ratchet]

Have already discussed this. Could be an intentional inconsistency.

A lot will depend on what hime flips. Will see.

 

[KWEH]

Now that I think about it, Hime probably is neither Cersei nor Joffrey because Voteless/Executioner sounds a lot like Ilyn Payn

 

[Ratchet]

Now that I think about it, Hime probably is neither Cersei nor Joffrey because Voteless/Executioner sounds a lot like Ilyn Payn

He said actor/exec.

 

[KWEH]

He said actor/exec.

Well Actor could be because the Executioner always gets the last laugh or something along those lines

Not that it matters all too much

 

[DoflaMihawk]

U got hammered

Anything u wanna with us in case u had results on someone?

Saw you quoted me and knew immediately I was gonna see this lol

Nah man I was just a dayvig, happy to keep my vote on a claimed Littlefinger.

 

[Ratchet]

The thing working against Hime here is that I'm struggling to see where Phoenix gets all this from if he's just lying about it. Take reaction aside - what's the goal. Will depend on his flip I suppose.

The other dude if that coin is how much do I want to trust a confirmed liar? Not much. But I just feel like Phoenix is probably genuine here.

 

[Ratchet]

If Ilyn Payne flips I'm just stumped tbh. He was so irrelevant even the Lannisters forgot about him at the end.

 

[Underworld Broker]

Saw you quoted me and knew immediately I was gonna see this lol

Nah man I was just a dayvig, happy to keep my vote on a claimed Littlefinger.

Theres no way ur just a simple day vig... who's Victarion in ur opinion then?

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Theres no way ur just a simple day vig... who's Victarion in ur opinion then?

From what I've read so far, Kweh.

15 players left, so 7 green, 2 red, 3 purple, Vic, LF and NK is my assumption for who's left. I don't believe Varys is in this game, there just isn't any room for him, and iirc there's been no mention of Varys until Kweh brought it up. His story seems to change on a dime, and he threw a tantrum when he came near to being hammered. Not green behaviour IMO.

If Phoenix's write-up mentions Varys then I'll have to reconsider though.

 

[Doddsy]

Well Actor could be because the Executioner always gets the last laugh or something along those lines

Not that it matters all too much

I'd say if anything it be cause he's got no tongue and therefore can't speak.

But surely there's not 3 red left still

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Have already discussed this. Could be an intentional inconsistency.

I'm thinking Jeoffrey could be mechanics. As long as Red lives they have the throne/Jeoffrey. Cercie is most important Lanister, unlike Town Gram should have no reason to exclude her when even Roose Bolton made it.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

The thing working against Hime here is that I'm struggling to see where Phoenix gets all this from if he's just lying about it. Take reaction aside - what's the goal. Will depend on his flip I suppose.

The other dude if that coin is how much do I want to trust a confirmed liar? Not much. But I just feel like Phoenix is probably genuine here.

Doesn't feel like Phoenix is lying, and there's also Votelock slip thing from hime that ya guys just didn't pay attention.

How did she ignore Prof and Pot posts that majority already been reached, then bat an eye to my vote lock post that very same page. If she is the last Red she'd have been the lynch today.

 

[Underworld Broker]

From what I've read so far, Kweh.

15 players left, so 7 green, 2 red, 3 purple, Vic, LF and NK is my assumption for who's left. I don't believe Varys is in this game, there just isn't any room for him, and iirc there's been no mention of Varys until Kweh brought it up. His story seems to change on a dime, and he threw a tantrum when he came near to being hammered. Not green behaviour IMO.

If Phoenix's write-up mentions Varys then I'll have to reconsider though.

Hmm i dont think the numbers add up if u look at who already flipped, unless we had 16 town?

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

The Census claim should be genuine from Lord Melkor unless he wanted to get caught in lie later down the line. The balance also make sense with 6-6 Mafia.

15/6/5/2/1/1
30 players with 2 dead at that time. 1 town and 1 purple.
With 5 Red dead, there should be only 1 Red left.

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Hmm i dont think the numbers add up if u look at who already flipped, unless we had 16 town?

Do you think we had more or less town? More town means one less on another team, and less town means towns started with under 50% of the players which is wild.

 

[Underworld Broker]

Do you think we had more or less town? More town means one less on another team, and less town means towns started with under 50% of the players which is wild.

Nvm YTW just explained the math lol

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Do you think we had more or less town? More town means one less on another team, and less town means towns started with under 50% of the players which is wild.

Claim all your abilities pls,

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

The last Purple is advised to claim rn, will help a lot in PoE​

 

[DoflaMihawk]

The Census claim should be genuine from Lord Melkor unless he wanted to get caught in lie later down the line. The balance also make sense with 6-6 Mafia.

15/6/5/2/1/1
30 players with 2 dead at that time. 1 town and 1 purple.
With 5 Red dead, there should be only 1 Red left.

If I was Melk, I'd use the Census to make everyone think red is weaker than they really are. If we're not getting confirmation of all reds dying, the last red could just act like a green without suspicion.

16/7/5/2/1/1 is what we started with IMO

 

[Ratchet]

I'm thinking Jeoffrey could be mechanics. As long as Red lives they have the throne/Jeoffrey. Cercie is most important Lanister, unlike Town Gram should have no reason to exclude her when even Roose Bolton made it.

My counterpoint - Widows Wail should belong to Joffrey.