[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Ratchet]

Doesn’t it work the exact same way in reverse lol?

Lynch you then check/lynch Ekko for same results.

No because Yo Tan is still in play there. I'm just looking at it from a better angle. Who benefits from this situation now? It's certainly not me, nor is it YTW.

 

[WakandaForever]

Could be abusing her powers or something. Joffrey had a similar role with the execution.

Joffrey makes a lot of sense though since he's a sadistic asshole and someone who literally can 'execute' people as king.

It's not the same context. Claiming four different roles have swords listed as an ability purely to facilitate a Sam Tarly fake claim is one of the stupidest statements I've come across in Mafia. It's a high bar, too.

It is definitely not outside of Grammaton's wheelhouse to try a weird mechanic like this tbh. Unlikely, but if someone were to try it, I could see it being him.

Also it would be stated in Cersri's role that she'd become Queen after Joffrey. What do I even gain by denying her existence knowing I'll be proven wrong very shortly after?

Would it?

This is a bold assumption.

Also, acting like Cersei won't exist knowing that there's a good chance the character will show up as the next royal is actually a distancing technique I wouldn't be surprised to see scum do at all.

Its like trying to do the opposite of tmi

 

[Dr_Professor83]

So if Ratchet does flip town what does that mean for Yo?
This looks bad for Ekko but there's still my alignment invest.

Especially since it seems like I would get the same alignment as a result if it was manipulated or it would've outright failed.

Idk lol. But Wakanda says he didn’t kill. That’s a big kicker even if not 100%.

 

[Doddsy]

Btw @Ratchet since you're still leaning so hard on lore, is there a logical reason for Cersei to have a duel?

It isn't a role that strikes me as fitting her flavour.

Who was Ekko's character btw?

Also who did Ekko duel and kill? I don't think I've gathered that yet?

 

[Ratchet]

Also if the game is ending with my lynch, I'm just conceding here. No need to prolong this. I'm not because... I'm town.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Also if the game is ending with my lynch, I'm just conceding here. No need to prolong this. I'm not because... I'm town.

I don’t believe you’d ever concede until the hammer vote.

 

[Doddsy]

For what it is worth also, Tywin already flipped Lannister GF so YTW having the no kill clear should be fairly reliable unless Wakanda is lying, which wouldn't really benefit him unless they're aligned so fair unlikely.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Who was Ekko's character btw?

Also who did Ekko duel and kill? I don't think I've gathered that yet?

Claims Oberyan. He dueled and killed Pero/The Mountain on D2.

 

[Ratchet]

I don’t believe you’d ever concede until the hammer vote.

I've done it several times. And if my goal is to stall, why not take the YTW lynch two days ago?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

If he’s Cersei he had to duel his own teammate.

 

[WakandaForever]

I mean from my perspective it's pretty obvious. There is no reason for Ekko to still be alive this far. If he flips town what do I do tomorrow? How do I win this? Can someone explain that to me please?

Otherwise have Wakanda target me tonight, flip Ekko and if the game isn't over I'll vote myself first.

I'd rather not target you tonight, or have anyone know who I'm actually targeting.

Think about it - if I target you tonight then scum can just no-kill, which makes it look like you had no option but not to kill lest I track that you have a killing action. Otherwise if scum kills and I track you to a no kill, then you get a YTW-level clear.

I honestly think lynching you today is the best play - even if you flip town. That way we get rid of your bizarre slot, and can clear all of us who you hid behind.

POE becomes pretty simple from that point forward.

 

[Doddsy]

Claims Oberyan. He dueled and killed Pero/The Mountain on D2.

Was Pero under heavy scrutiny at the time, and who was leading the push?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I've done it several times. And if my goal is to stall, why not take the YTW lynch two days ago?

Bc it puts you under scrutiny for an extra several days lol.

 

[Pot Goblin]

Who was Ekko's character btw?

Also who did Ekko duel and kill? I don't think I've gathered that yet?

Ekko claimed Viper that Tyrell fella
Dueled and killed Pero who flippes Red, The Mountain.

Also if the game is ending with my lynch, I'm just conceding here. No need to prolong this. I'm not because... I'm town.

If there's anything I learned as scum is that you should always go down swinging.

 

[Ratchet]

That way we get rid of your bizarre slot, and can clear all of us who you hid behind.

That only works if you can prove I targeted you. If I were roleblocked, I'd never know.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Was Pero under heavy scrutiny at the time, and who was leading the push?

Pero was under heavy scrutiny. Don’t remember who was leading bc most everyone wanted him dead. He wasn’t gonna be the lynch tho bc Arp/Ramsey had a guilty on him.

The whole thing caused 2 scum to die on D2.

 

[Ratchet]

Bc it puts you under scrutiny for an extra several days lol.

No it doesn't. Doesn't change anything.

 

[Doddsy]

Not exactly a lot of options for Ol' Ratchet

Blue - Purple
Ekkologix - Confirmed Duelist. Not The Mountain
Pot Goblin - Purple
WakandaForever - Visited Yo
Kagurashii - Cleared throughout the game by Ratchet
Doddsy - Cleared throughout the game by Ratchet
Dr_Professor83 - Purple
Yo Tan Wa - did not kill Broker confirmed by Wakanda

His only path is to attempt to sell Ekko.

From this point, Ratchet flipping as town hider would also fairly reliably confirm me and Kag.

Wrench in the works for some of these is if NK is also investigation immune which is not unlikely. @Ratchet does your hide mention any specific that you would die if you hid behind scum or is it non specific?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

That only works if you can prove I targeted you. If I were roleblocked, I'd never know.

We can be pretty sure T-Pein was blocked most of those nights.

 

[Ratchet]

From this point, Ratchet flipping as town hider would also fairly reliably confirm me and Kag.

Wrench in the works for some of these is if NK is also investigation immune which is not unlikely. @Ratchet does your hide mention any specific that you would die if you hid behind scum or is it non specific?

Die if I hide behind non-Rebellion.