[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Doddsy]

I feel very good on them lol. Pot is Dany and Blue’s healer claim is proven. Not to mention it makes no sense for Red to have Purple fake claims.

Then Vic’s marriage proposal would make zero sense lol. Nor Pot confirming it before Dofla did lol.

Like you give Red and Purple fake claim and then Dany goes bad and then what?

Not to mention I caught Hime for her trying to keep Purple in the POE so hard.

To clarify, I would only ever suspect a purple of being the NK, if they even exist in the game.

Need to go red first, as we know Cersei exists. No need to get bogged down in NK spec unless the game is still going once Cersei is dead.

Needless to say, if we are looking for a NK all confirms are likely out the window and it's all up in the air.

 

[Pot Goblin]

Obviously this is my first time playing but you seem like a good player, yet you don't seem particularly stressed about the outcome.

It's just odd lol.

Who do you think we should lynch today?

Ratchet, I gave my reasons a bit earlier

 

[Doddsy]

I'm going to say this for the sake of it, any character being alluded to that ends up not being in the game and just some random write up only one is bastard as hell.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Also Varys/Tweet also sent a message to Dany that Pot confirmed getting lol.

 

[WakandaForever]

I feel very good on them lol. Pot is Dany and Blue’s healer claim is proven. Not to mention it makes no sense for Red to have Purple fake claims.

Then Vic’s marriage proposal would make zero sense lol. Nor Pot confirming it before Dofla did lol.

I wasn't around for that period of play but I presume they were whispers, in which case surely Vic just presumed Pot was Dany based on claim or something?

Or was it specifically confirmed to be a mechanic where Vic could actually communicate to Dany, whoever they may be?

 

[Ratchet]

I wasn't around for that period of play but I presume they were whispers, in which case surely Vic just presumed Pot was Dany based on claim or something?

Or was it specifically confirmed to be a mechanic where Vic could actually communicate to Dany, whoever they may be?

The former.

 

[Doddsy]

Also Varys/Tweet also sent a message to Dany that Pot confirmed getting lol.

I would be sure that Dany has to be fairly confirmed in the character sense as Vic had the role to propose to her. Would be dumb for him to have that role but really have to target the NK or something

 

[Pot Goblin]

I wasn't around for that period of play but I presume they were whispers, in which case surely Vic just presumed Pot was Dany based on claim or something?

Or was it specifically confirmed to be a mechanic where Vic could actually communicate to Dany, whoever they may be?

It was confirmed mechanically.
Doffy's WU showed that Vic turned into a serial killer after I rejected his Pissjoy ass.

 

[Ratchet]

If that's the case, Cersei could be a non player role too, no? The writeup even indicates that she just showed up.

Thoughts on this, @Dr_Professor83?

 

[Pot Goblin]

I wasn't around for that period of play but I presume they were whispers, in which case surely Vic just presumed Pot was Dany based on claim or something?

Or was it specifically confirmed to be a mechanic where Vic could actually communicate to Dany, whoever they may be?

Misread it a bit, Vic contacted me first because I made a full buffet claim that I was Daniel. Then the Serial Killer from rejection thing came through.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Game of Thrones Mafia Day 7

Final Vote Count

Dofla 7 - Ratchet, Kagurashii, Wakanda, Blue, Pot Goblin, Hime

As the Iron Captain and King of the Iron Islands trudged up to the gallows, he thought only of feasting in the Drowned God's watery halls with the honourable men he had defeated ...​

Spoiler: Dofla

King Victarion Greyjoy
1x Daykill, Bound by Duty, A Proposal, (Serial Killer)

‘There is no wine so sweet as wine taken from a foe. One day I shall drink your wine, Crow's Eye, and take from you all that you hold dear.’

Congratulations, you are King Victarion Greyjoy, Ironborn Aligned! A fearsome warrior, but something of a dullard, you are compelled by your own sense of honour. Previously serving as your brother Balon’s right hand, you are now resentfully forced to serve your brother Euron, whom you want revenge against. Your third wife was unfaithful to you with him, and you were forced to beat her to death with your bare hands to remove the stain on your honour. You are the Lord-Captain of the Iron Fleet, and one of the finest sailors in the land.

Your brother has now despatched you at the head of the Iron Fleet to locate the Mother of Dragons, Daenerys Targaryen, and bring her, and her dragons to him in the form of a wedding proposal. You of course know your brother better than this, but you will do your duty nonetheless …

The strongest of the Ironborn warriors, you seek to betray your brother and take the dragonqueen for yourself. Just remember, he is always watching …

In this game, you have the following roles:

-1x Daykill (You may kill a player in the game thread at any time. Type Daykill <target> in the game thread. This action cannot be cancelled, so only draw steel if you intend to use it!)

- Bound by Duty (Your brother Euron knows your identity, and you suspect he is in service of dark powers. Nonetheless, you wish to find the queen. You may target a player at night and learn if they are Daenerys Targaryen)

- A Proposal (Once you have located Daenerys, you may write a proposal to her. If she accepts, her followers will potentially desert her, and her win condition will change. You will give her the Iron Fleet, and you will have the means to challenge your brother, as well as the petty lords of Westeros. If she declines …

- Serial Killer (Unfortunately, the Dragonqueen has refused your proposal. With your brother dead, there is no one strong enough to oppose your claim to being the King of the Iron Islands. Henceforth, you are King Victarion Greyjoy, and you have gained a factional kill you may use.

Your win condition has now been updated to the following:

You win when you are the last player remaining, or when you achieve independence for the Iron Islands. It will become clearer how to achieve this as the game progresses, and your story is far from finished ... Now to begin the long voyage home.

It is now Night 7. You have 12 hours to get your roles in. Will begin day as soon as Im able to get free time at work tomorrow.​

Here is the role. It says he has to find Dany. But I’d assume the ability probably fails on non Dany. He even has an ability to check someone for being Dany lol. Therefor we have to have a Dany. Not to mention Purple as a faction is just straight bastard if Dany isn’t real lol.

 

[Doddsy]

Ser Gregor Clegane ‘The Mountain that Rides’
1xStrongman, Resilience, Champion, Rage

‘Some dead man …’

Congratulations, you are Ser Gregor Clegane, Lannister Alliance Aligned! A hulking brute of a man, you stand at nearly 8ft tall and over 30st of muscle. The elder brother of Sandor Clegane, whom you horribly disfigured as a boy, you are now the enforcement arm of Tywin Lannister, and carry out his orders unquestioningly.

Champion (Redacted from flip unless triggerered)- If a member of your team is targeted for a duel, you will represent the Lannister Alliance in combat - you will permanently switch roles with your teammate.

You win when you control the voting majority, and/or nothing can prevent this​

The underlined section of the Mountains flip would be a pretty weird stipulation to have if the duelist was indeed red as well

 

[WakandaForever]

If that's the case, Cersei could be a non player role too, no? The writeup even indicates that she just showed up.

I guess its possible but it'd be VERY unlikely since her possesing the throne is something that an active character (Joffrey) has already done.

I don't actually think Dany or Cersei are non-players though but I'm just flinging shit at the wall.

The former.

Interesting. So Dany isn't confirmed outside of writeups.

Still, as I said above, I'm pretty confident both are real players - a Targaryen Restoration without Dany would be wild and Cersei holds the throne which implies she's real.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Thoughts on this, @Dr_Professor83?

Makes no sense bc the Lannister would all be dead and Pot should have his ass in that chair no?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

If eradicating the Lannisters doesn’t get Pot the chair from them then what possibly could lol?

 

[WakandaForever]

OK Dany is confirmed to exist from that PM reveal.

Moving along.

 

[Ratchet]

If eradicating the Lannisters doesn’t get Pot the chair from them then what possibly could lol?

Maybe the Northmen? It did imply somewhere that they are against her.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

The underlined section of the Mountains flip would be a pretty weird stipulation to have if the duelist was indeed red as well

That’s a hang up. Would mean that it’s just there to trick us.

 

[Doddsy]

The underlined section of the Mountains flip would be a pretty weird stipulation to have if the duelist was indeed red as well

Ehhh, question for the group, it you were the duelist and dueled someone, so it is you v someone, would you consider yourself targeted by the duel?

i.e. if Cersei was the duelist and dueled, would the Mountain then take her place?

The role swap part of it leads me to think no, as if he lost the duel then Cersei would be fucked, no?

 

[Emil]

I will say that I did get Heartsbane last night.
No fancy description or anything just the fact that I recived it.

By the way, I realize this doesn't clear Ratchet as Sam anymore. The other swords we've seen this game I've noticed a trend where the swords begin with the original owners such as how oathkeeper went to Jaime and widows wail went to Joffery.

I look up the original owner of heartsbane and I see that it belonged to Sam Tarly's father first as a family heirloom.

And then I realize that the Tarly house is part of house Lannister. A perfect reason to have Heartsbane. It would be exactly like how Joffery had an ability named after a character. It would fit perfectly in the inconsistencies that Gramm talked about without being bastard. My mistake was assuming that Heartsbane belonged to Sam and Sam only, but looking at the origins tells the truth here. It's not Sam Tarly it's House Tarly who would be Lannister Aligned.


On top of that, Wakanda proved that Yo didn't submit a killing action. Yet someone died. That narrows it down completley.

Ratchet is the lynch today.

now u speaking my language
lets get it
put ur vote