[FNZ] Role Madness Star Wars: Disturbance In The Force

[Ratchet]

Only 2 players here would see juliet as a viable target n1 btw.
Ekko and Ratchet.

Qualify this please.

 

[Peroroncino]

Qualify this please.

Ekko accused her of spiting him.
And you only started to scum read her near the end of the day.
Then it turns she died and you just happened to invest her.

 

[Peroroncino]

Around 6 hours since the last post when I got here.
Whats up with that.
No one discussing anything for 6 hours seems strange.

Its 5 am for me and indigo

 

[Ratchet]

Ekko accused her of spiting him.
And you only started to scum read her near the end of the day.
Then it turns she died and you just happened to invest her.

So why would either of us kill her?

 

[Peroroncino]

So why would either of us kill her?

Cause then you would have an excuse not to give us results of your invest.
Ekko just wanted to get a good player who spites him out of the way if he is scum

 

[Ratchet]

Like @Peroroncino you just saw me last game go through all the viable mislynches we had to work out a path to victory.

You know my ethos for night kills.

So why do I kill... Juliet?

 

[Ratchet]

Cause then you would have an excuse not to give us results of your invest.
Ekko just wanted to get a good player who spites him out of the way if he is scum

Okay but how long will this excuse last for? Why not just target any player and claim some results on them if I'm lying about it all? Why specifically go out of my way to claim something that makes me look worse? Think Pero, think.

 

[Peroroncino]

Okay but how long will this excuse last for? Why not just target any player and claim some results on them if I'm lying about it all? Why specifically go out of my way to claim something that makes me look worse? Think Pero, think.

Targetting any other player would make you look worse since everyone would expect you to go after your scum reads which d1 was juliet even though sue barely talked.

 

[Charlie]

@Charlie explain

I used one shot protecting him from incoming hostile action. In case of "damn, i was redirected apparently" or something. Or killshot. Could be that he was shoot by TAC then. Not sure whether by vig or scum. Since 3 people survived kill.


I'm way behind btw. But i visited him so results are good

 

[Peroroncino]

She*

 

[Ratchet]

One argument you could make is "so you can claim you wouldn't do this as scum". Sure. But that means I self resolve anyway. A few more nights of no results and I'm done.

 

[T-Pein™]

Ratchet is scum in my opinion after surviving the night and everyone who was suspicious of him d1 dying.
Lets not forget he wanted pizza to claim yesterday then it turns out phoenix can kill those who claimed.

this is a really good point.
And doctor had only 3 votes on him.
It was a really strange thing to do and with scum flipping with abilities to punish claims it makes sense why he would be so pushy on that.
Since doc is new maybe he assumed he could easily make him claim there.

 

[Charlie]

I used one shot protecting him from incoming hostile action. In case of "damn, i was redirected apparently" or something. Or killshot. Could be that he was shoot by TAC then. Not sure whether by vig or scum. Since 3 people survived kill.


I'm way behind btw. But i visited him so results are good

Not hostile. Negative

 

[Ratchet]

Targetting any other player would make you look worse since everyone would expect you to go after your scum reads which d1 was juliet even though sue barely talked.

Juliet, Indigo, Melkor. Or I could go for other active players like Ekko, Fuji. Lots of options here.

 

[Ratchet]

this is a really good point.
And doctor had only 3 votes on him.
It was a really strange thing to do and with scum flipping with abilities to punish claims it makes sense why he would be so pushy on that.
Since doc is new maybe he assumed he could easily make him claim there.

That would require me.to be scum with Phoenix. Do you believe that to be the case?

 

[T-Pein™]

I used one shot protecting him from incoming hostile action. In case of "damn, i was redirected apparently" or something. Or killshot. Could be that he was shoot by TAC then. Not sure whether by vig or scum. Since 3 people survived kill.


I'm way behind btw. But i visited him so results are good

@Ratchet

was Charlie not aware you had your abilities already upgraded and that they would already not be blocked?
sus usage.

 

[Charlie]

Btw, are we assuming there's only one mafia? With 6 killshots at night?

 

[Ratchet]

@Ratchet

was Charlie not aware you had your abilities already upgraded and that they would already not be blocked?
sus usage.

He was aware, he voted for it.
If he can stop a kill though, then it does mean TAC could have shot me, and Charlie stopped it.

 

[Ratchet]

Btw, are we assuming there's only one mafia? With 6 killshots at night?

I suspect many of those are either fake or low/conditional chance of success. Probably the latter.

 

[Charlie]

@Ratchet

was Charlie not aware you had your abilities already upgraded and that they would already not be blocked?
sus usage.

I knew they can't be blocked. Could be redirected, shoot, blackmailed or whatever