Status
Not open for further replies.
-The Scum Case on DoctorIndigo-



Sitting comfortably? I have something on my mind to share - a confession, if you will. You see, I haven't been entirely honest. When I received my role for this game, after navigating my way to the website, I saw immediately I was Town. A relief, I must say. Better yet - I was the Rogue One MC, my favourite movie in this franchise. And then I saw I was a Cop. A Cop... of sorts.

I can indeed investigate a player every night. I do certainly receive results. But not alignment. I am an Ability Cop, which tells me the classification of an ability a player uses that Night Phase. For example, if I targeted a Doctor, I would receive "Protective". I received "Your target used a Destructive and a Manipulative effect last night phase" for Juliet. So I can confirm, without any doubt, that she fired.

So first, why? Well, I've played this game for a while, and I like to think I have pretty good insight into setups. The first thing I asked myself after seeing this role is "what purpose does it serve". It's an investigative role that doesn't give clear, defined, this player is town/scum results, but can be used to catch lies and test claims anyway. It's a weaker cop, but then, why is it in the game. I deduced, correctly it would appear, that this means there is no alignment cop in the game. There wouldn't be much reason to have my role be it's own thing if the town had a dedicated role that could check alignment. This is why, when I claimed, I simply said "Cop".

Secondly, and I'll be brief here, there is no reason for me to be lying about this. I clearly got away with implying I was an alignment cop, so you can spare me the pearl clutching.

Finally, how does this pertain to DoctorIndigo? Well, you see, with no alignment cop in the game, or at least no dedicated one, why does a Miller exist? It's conventionally "Bastard" to include a Miller in a game where there is no Cop, because it's a role that affects another. Watchers/Trackers can be affected by Sanity, and at its core, a Miller reverses the sanity of the investigation that targets it, but this isn't how Drago, and many hosts in fact, handle Miller.

Between claiming it today and the fact that there is no need for a Miller to even be in the game, it seems pretty clear to me. DoctorIndigo is Scum.




"Let me summarise.
I'm not an Alignment Cop, I'm an Ability Cop.
There is no Alignment Cop in the game.
A Miller would not exist in the absence of an Alignment Cop."

Now... let the Witch Hunt begin!
So

based off this post alone, and given the fact that Doc claimed that YTW's dead slot just happened to be cop/miller

Is it even possible for both of these slots to be town? Shouldn't be any excuse for not picking a side here unless some solid information comes out.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
Because I was sleeping, Ekko convinced you because

1- You listen to everything he says.
2- He was convinced by my case and told it to you, his lapdog.


No you didnt guess, it was me. I brought it up first. I fucking laid it out for everyone to see.


Ekko asked him because I convinced him. You know what, you're 2 for 2. You're so awesome and all, keep up the great work.
fuji sounds like one of these inventors who get their ideas stolen and watch the theif make millions out of it while he gets no recognition lol
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Fujishiro is definitely not Mafia lol


He saved Tobi Lync
He came forward with lethal when there was no sus on him. Heck, no one was sure he was scum. He got voted to save indigo and there was no other way liable Lynch candidate.

As Mafia he won't defend ratchet so much.


He could be indie though - because I did feel like he is playing both sides lmao

But that could be just me overthinking
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
both TAC and Blue are weird to me right now

both pushing hard for my lynch D2

TAC claims is an indie protector that needs to protect Grogu, saw Ratchet's cop claim and defended him at night, but didn't read that he claimed Jyn Erso. It's weird because TAC should've looked for a character claim there, since his character is an indie that protects a character and not a role. Also, he said he went for Ratchet because he thought could be a cop, but Grogu has nothing to do with a Cop. And TAC knows that, he looks like a good Star Wars fan.

Blue spent the entire day telling the game that if i was alive during NP, my existence alone, Blue would die. Then he said that would happen if anybody tried to attack me, Blue would die in my place. So Blue said he was gonna roleblock me to stop me from killing and maybe turning into Vader, while also making me "useless" so i wouldn't be a target for the mafia anymore. Then at the end of the day, Blue didn't Role Block me at all.

:kayneshrug:
TAC can go tbh
could have a mandalorian fake claim
 
It also raises the question of why would Ratchet *ever* not vote Doc d2 when he apparently came up with an explanation that is insanely convenient, from his standpoint.

I'd also just like to comment that Ratchet's line of thinking in that there's no Alignment Cop can come from him receiving that as a fake claim, and in fact a mafioso would be more likely to think along these trains of thought in general.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
Fujishiro is definitely not Mafia lol


He saved Tobi Lync
He came forward with lethal when there was no sus on him. Heck, no one was sure he was scum. He got voted to save indigo and there was no other way liable Lynch candidate.

As Mafia he won't defend ratchet so much.


He could be indie though - because I did feel like he is playing both sides lmao

But that could be just me overthinking
no its not you overthinking
you are right on the mark
and hes pretty defensive about it too
 
Bruh...
He rolls godfather every game.
If he did it again we riot.
Read my post on him lol. You too @Ekkologix
Hime was one of the people that stood out to me when Banks flipped because she was really keen on the idea that Miller+ Cop mason partners isnt likely and kept her vote on Indigo when Banks and Indigo were almost tied.

LM was active during EOD but his vote remained on Indigo, Phoenix threw scum reads at him most of D1 but didnt really do much with it so he is my prime suspect rn.
Keep in mind Phoenix mentioned LM as a sus read of his a few minutes before he got lynched, back when people were asking him to give us an alternative but didnt puruse it and just let himself die. Feels like an attempt at distancing to me.
 
So

based off this post alone, and given the fact that Doc claimed that YTW's dead slot just happened to be cop/miller

Is it even possible for both of these slots to be town? Shouldn't be any excuse for not picking a side here unless some solid information comes out.
No dude, Indigo is Miller who is masons with YTW who was a cop of some sorts.
 

EkkoLoJinx

How far I'll go...
Read my post on him lol. You too @Ekkologix

Keep in mind Phoenix mentioned LM as a sus read of his a few minutes before he got lynched, back when people were asking him to give us an alternative but didnt puruse it and just let himself die. Feels like an attempt at distancing to me.
i totally forgot the point with phoenix throwing a random scum read on LM

hmm okay

need lm claim today
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Read my post on him lol. You too @Ekkologix

Keep in mind Phoenix mentioned LM as a sus read of his a few minutes before he got lynched, back when people were asking him to give us an alternative but didnt puruse it and just let himself die. Feels like an attempt at distancing to me.
Didn't LM vote phoniex before pero?
 
Read my post on him lol. You too @Ekkologix

Keep in mind Phoenix mentioned LM as a sus read of his a few minutes before he got lynched, back when people were asking him to give us an alternative but didnt puruse it and just let himself die. Feels like an attempt at distancing to me.
I am keeping my eye on melkor
He is naturally scummy.
I think Ratchet is scummier tho.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top