The Great Guys vs Girls Mafia Round (Sign ups)

[Flower]

Would love if this starts August or sth


Fuck my exams

It likely will.

@Blue I put the player list in the opening post.

 

[Sallucion]

Wait when did I sign up xD
Not even sure I have time in later July/August.

 

[Nana]

Wait when did I sign up xD
Not even sure I have time in later July/August.

Reply = auto sign

Too late my friend

 

[Ratchet]

No idea what this is.

But /in.

 

[hime]

hmm personally i think it would be a lot more enjoyable if roles r created evenly like 1 guy and 1 girl has a copy of the same role with the same wincon (ex: shoot opposite gender's doctor for example)

that way it's still fair to some degree but also contains the element of chaos (bc everyone's an indie essentially and claiming ur wincon is forbidden)

 

[Flower]

hmm personally i think it would be a lot more enjoyable if roles r created evenly like 1 guy and 1 girl has a copy of the same role with the same wincon (ex: shoot opposite gender's doctor for example)

that way it's still fair to some degree but also contains the element of chaos (bc everyone's an indie essentially and claiming ur wincon is forbidden)

Well, let‘s see how the role creation goes. We can always make changes to the setup depending on how things work out.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

How about guys create roles for girls and vice versa.

but then the host distributes them randomly.

That way neither party will make too weak roles and also take the role making seriously.

 

[Flower]

How about guys create roles for girls and vice versa.

but then the host distributes them randomly.

That way neither party will make too weak roles and also take the role making seriously.

Then everyone creates weak roles .

 

[Mashiro Blue]

No idea what this is.

But /in.

We'll be having girls vs boys here waifubro

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Then everyone creates weak roles .

Then host adds certain secret elements before distributing the roles to balance it out.

Everyone is going to go for super kills and omegas at this rate.

The game will end too early.

 

[Flower]

@Dragomir sign up, too.

 

[Sallucion]

@MangoSenpai
@novaselinenever
@Lindltaylor

 

[Peroroncino]

hmm personally i think it would be a lot more enjoyable if roles r created evenly like 1 guy and 1 girl has a copy of the same role with the same wincon (ex: shoot opposite gender's doctor for example)

that way it's still fair to some degree but also contains the element of chaos (bc everyone's an indie essentially and claiming ur wincon is forbidden)

i prefer this instead of the omega kill spam they're going for

 

[Nana]

@MangoSenpai
@novaselinenever
@Lindltaylor

It is been ages since Nova played


He should definitely sign up to this one

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Then host adds certain secret elements before distributing the roles to balance it out.

Everyone is going to go for super kills and omegas at this rate.

The game will end too early.

I think if everyone agrees that they don’t want infinite super kill/omega kill spam then we’re fine lol. Host can take it from there without having to pull their hair out.

 

[Dragomir]

Doing it as a create your own, monster mafia style is needlessly complicated and confusing. It also has a high-risk of being a mess. It'd be better for someone to create a setup beforehand and host it at a later date.

Whoever's down to host should take their time with the setup and make sure it's fun and good. This should be a great game not a chaotic mess.

 

[Peroroncino]

Doing it as a create your own, monster mafia style is needlessly complicated and confusing. It also has a high-risk of being a mess. It'd be better for someone to create a setup beforehand and host it at a later date.

Whoever's down to host should take their time with the setup and make sure it's fun and good. This should be a great game not a chaotic mess.

this

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Let it be a chaotic mess

For something more properly structured and it's "personal" too we already have the User Mafia game

Chaos once in a while won't hurt anybody and it will be a break from routine

 

[Sallucion]

Doing it as a create your own, monster mafia style is needlessly complicated and confusing. It also has a high-risk of being a mess. It'd be better for someone to create a setup beforehand and host it at a later date.

Whoever's down to host should take their time with the setup and make sure it's fun and good. This should be a great game not a chaotic mess.

I think this is the best yeah, but thats my opinion

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Doing it as a create your own, monster mafia style is needlessly complicated and confusing. It also has a high-risk of being a mess. It'd be better for someone to create a setup beforehand and host it at a later date.

Whoever's down to host should take their time with the setup and make sure it's fun and good. This should be a great game not a chaotic mess.

Lol I think some people want a monster mafia game and others like the general idea of the game itself.

Maybe split up the concepts if needed into two games if people want the girls v guys thing to be more serious lol.