[FNZ] Super Role Madness GimmeMy10McMuffins mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ratchet

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
‎
#2,667
#2,667
Grammaton said:
yes, I would say it doesn’t make sense because if it worked as intended and I burned flower, what’s the exit strategy? And why kill flower who up until this point, listed me as her strongest town read?
Click to expand...
Well you wouldn't be claiming it was you, would you? The last point is sheer WIFOM, not an adminstable defence. Again, look at how it all works together. You said you couldn't have it redirected. Well the form of redirection that would take the action from Flower to Ekko would satisfy that restriction. Surely you appreciate that it's a lot, purely from the mechanical information on the table here, to put it all down to coincidence when it fits this well? Again, swap yourself with anyone else and if you find my reasoning becomes less poor in that context, then the fault isn't my reasoning.

If anyone is disappointed here, it's me, because I feel like I put it all together only to be told that I setup the wrong jigsaw.
 
Grammaton

Grammaton

‎
#2,673
#2,673
Ratchet said:
Well you wouldn't be claiming it was you, would you? The last point is sheer WIFOM, not an adminstable defence. Again, look at how it all works together. You said you couldn't have it redirected. Well the form of redirection that would take the action from Flower to Ekko would satisfy that restriction. Surely you appreciate that it's a lot, purely from the mechanical information on the table here, to put it all down to coincidence when it fits this well? Again, swap yourself with anyone else and if you find my reasoning becomes less poor in that context, then the fault isn't my reasoning.

If anyone is disappointed here, it's me, because I feel like I put it all together only to be told that I setup the wrong jigsaw.
Click to expand...
Your reasoning is poor because it relies on my acting like an imbecile for no strategic gain. If the intent was to not claim it, then why claim it?
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
‎
#2,679
#2,679
Grammaton said:
Your reasoning is poor because it relies on my acting like an imbecile for no strategic gain. If the intent was to not claim it, then why claim it?
Click to expand...
You claimed it because it was redirected, for all I know you think Adam is also scum (not with you) and decide to get some cred from it. Again, you as scum could not possibly anticipate Charlie being able to counter the redirect part. I'm focusing purely on the mechanics here, it fit into place perfectly and now I'm being told it doesn't count because of some other info and that it's all a coincidence. Put yourself in my shoes here - what conclusion would you come to? Focus mechanics over player for this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top