Status
Not open for further replies.
i couldve sworn he openly admited to being scum in our chat not sure if he was trolling or not but @Flowa can you confirm or deny this bit? my memory is so fucked and we cant access chat rn

forgot who this was even asked to

lul it wasnt mafia it was indie - your worst enemies haha

indies bitch about being targeted not realizing they do it to themselve keko

we are homies but it pains me say if your town this some lackluster gameplay from you i like the GF mango better that guy knows how to run town like no other.

why did you target flower last cycle and why did you choose myself and sk?

did you really if i did i missed or overlooked it your defense on gramm made me miss it if anything.

thanks any town reads?

my team but fucking cant stand them team of crybabys tbh

hmm you going to off alibro this early or you doing something else rat?

hmmm so is pero actually "culted" now or hmm confused on this tbh ahah i missed d1 so i dont really know much of the towncore stuff outside of the little that was shared with me

lol if youre town i feel bad for you pero you played a longer game as scum haha

did you ask host if you can reply to them?

you were a hard town read no?

burn abilities were NAI in aries game so hard to even say depends on who uses them against who
No clue if that was sarcasm, but he said sth along those lines, yeah.
 

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
Do you have any reason to think I'm scum other than Adam though?
honestly in our chat someone was supposed to question you to get more info out of you and you were supposed to be the main wagon followed by gram - kinda disappointed no one kept up with it i bowed out from this position cause i wasnt even here to witness all of what led you to be a hard scum read but iirc it was only the adam bit but the guy has been getting nothing but blanks sent his way so idk the guy hits softer than a wet noodle.


i personally havent seen anything scummy well havent really noticed anything from you in general blah i guess i will have to iso you and be town leader here.
I took TAC off the list and replaced with MangoSenpai. Instead why don't you tell me why you're town reading:

Nana - the inactive who barely did anything besides townread Ekko and Kagurashii /Emi her replacement who's not done anything particularly townie.
Kagurashii - the person who was fluff posting and then said Pero (who hadn't posted yet) is scum because they've rolled scum before man. this would have been overlooked as a joke had not that been someone else's idea that she piggybacked off of + had not her reaction been weird as hell when questioned about it. in the same breath of arguing whether or not her premise that Pero had been scum in x number of past games recently was right or wrong (which literally had nothing to do with the game but it was like see I'm RIGHT guys) she was saying oh lol my vote was a joke LUUUL ._. More importantly, her first non-first post at #141 simply parroted anti-indie sentiment, which is scum 101 deflection tactics. When asked for clarification by Ekko she immediately backtracks in #147. This also relates to my scum read of Nana at the time because she came in saying I think Ekko and Kagu are town. Like BRUH. WHY? I'll tell you why. They THOUGHT ekko was town. and were trying to align themselves with him. but this get's complicated if I follow the logic of my iso on Emi which made me feel like she bussing Ekko X-x but I haven't caught up yet. If ekko was confirmed scum Emi's glee could have been towncred high + lynching opposing scum. So maybe it all checks out and wasn't a buss. X-x ssorry that got hyfaluting but stick with me.

Yo Tan Wa - hasn't been scum hunting, sheeps easy wagons.
Mugen - I apparently didn't write down why you should be on this list, but I have Null/Scum beside your name in my little notes and that means I had a good reason at some point. Just need to iso you.
Adam - His read are alarmingly different from mine and I'm town.
https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/gimmemy10mcmuffins-mafia.27107/post-2962840

He does a soft read of nana, but chalks it up to paranoia. says T-Pein is being scummy but he thinks is dumb townie, which I think was scum logic and not wanting that "towncore" bs that T-Pein was touting to backfire and most damning of all, refused to read ekko. yeah. CLOSED CASE as far as I'm concerned. Not to mention this gem of defening Kagurashii who I think is scum. https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/gimmemy10mcmuffins-mafia.27107/post-2962908

Sallucion - first post was BAD. they were like oh no I need to catch up and then voted someone who's not even in the game. Seems like they were afraid to ruffle feathers. A walking on eggshells entry into a game if I ever saw it. then there's this gem where he just @TP outta nowhere, and says "yeah I trust you bro" https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/gimmemy10mcmuffins-mafia.27107/post-2967452:suresure: and to make matters worst, the only thing they did besides basically saying "I'm afk guys lul" was asking if the case on Pot Goblin is valid. Just iso them man. not many post to see there.

MitchMatch - I didn't write down anything on them besides "Scum" besides their name XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD I legit don't remember why. Must have been when I was catching up on my phone before falling asleep. Like I said previously. you guys give me 24 hours to read this thread and iso some folks and I'll have the tastiest reads on the market.



3-5 millers??? ._. what gives you that impression?
meh whyd you have to give me a tldr like this.

ill see given your responses and ratchets meta read on you im leaning the same way towards you and as much as i love you adding some excitement and chaos to the game if youre actually town the amp on an indie who could be hostile doesnt read town to me. if you are actually town id refrain from doing as such moving forward.

anywho i never actually gave out reads i said tonally theyve been town cleared rathchet even gave you a synopsis of this

based off of your initials reads you are out of the loop since you are not in the night chat with us which is how those reads were made i dont really have too many of my own reads rn cause im playing from cycle2 as i subbed in midway through d1 and when i actually joined in there was already 2.4k post i am not reading any of d1 unless its an iso on a specific player and threadmarks.

as for nana/emi replaced her and given her last performance she seems to be more analytical and id liek to actually see her contribute before just randomly throwing a ks her way as she proved to be a strong town presence.

kagu im null cause i havent seen much of her

yo was in our night chat and was reading town in there i have bad memory so i forgot what she was actually saying in there and the chat is locked so i cant even access our conversations

well ill wait for you to figure out the reasoning for you trying to get rat to shoot me while im doing my part for town..

sally is my boy but hes been afk since i joined and tbh your read on him is nai cause hes taken a back seat from mafia hes basically a placeholder nowadays which sucks cause he can be a strng player overall if he contribues

mitch as well was in nightchat ehh forgot what he even said cause he was never really around when i was active in there.

Don’t break my heat Muu </3
 

Adam 🍎

Pretty Boy
You do have a point here but if you think pero shot me but failed as he was rbed then why you said this
Maybe i worded myself porly bcs it was late, but considering he was blocked i sus he was the one to do it. Then i remembered you pushibg JG in discord and maybe that spooked her
 
Adam said Dodssly is a fine lynch with no evidence. @Kagurashii I know you're past this page already. Why didn't you find this opportunistic?

Dodssly is a fine lynch target
is this mechanical?
Dodssly is a fine lynch target
adam is saying to lynch doddsy
why is this being ignored btw

vote lynch dodsy
Q for anyone: Why did Ekko ask "wait not adam?". It was in response to Ratchet saying "So Grammaton tried to kill Flower, and it got redirected to Ekko." It's been thousands of messages. Did I miss the part before this where Adam said he tried to kill Flowa or had kills? If not this is a big time slip.
 

Where to start.... where to fucking start, too much stuff going on tbh that it makes my head hurt. All these abilities going off, all these people claiming different things happen. Anyways, now I am caught up. Time to get back to business.

First of all, I would like to acknowledge the greatness of the one and only mighty role Vergil. He is guiding the way for he is our light and savior. Now that is out of the way, time for real talk.

Okay, we have alot of potential scummy candidate this DP. I have alot in my mind that I want to share.

While catching up to last DP I noticed multiple things, some people were very dismissive throwing away their reads due to an indie. You would think a townie would atleast think it over before being this dismissive like Kag, she was so easily dismissive of her reads due to an indie outing an information. I really didn't like it and it pinged me weird, especially after liking her posts during the dp. She somehow managed to go back to my null list. Didn't see townie mentality in the way she handled that.

I also was not the biggest fan of how easy the wagons were switching from pot to ekko last DP. I had both ekko and t-pein on my scum lean list and glad to see both of them are out of the equation but something is just irking me wrong. I really hope I am wrong on this one, but there might be a slight chance ekko is actually townie and that this trickster ability is tricking us with his flip. I think this is very unlikely and saw some discussion regarding it in the criminal chat. So let's just hope he is indeed scum and move along and not give in to paranoia.

Now, looking at the events that transpired into this DP.

-Doddsy was attacked apparently and survived a kill.
-Pero was super attacked and survived it.
-Gramma was attacked and survived a kill.
-Pero claims that he sent two abilities toward Baki and that they did not appear in the WU. Mitch also claimed that he shot ability on baki and it did not show in the WU.
-Baki is 100% sure that Pero is scum.
-Reborn was attacked apparently but reborn claims he can't survive a kill? curious was he redirected or something then?
-Pot was apparently attacked as well and when asked by adam if anything happened to him he claimed that he does not know anything.
-Nika amped a indie because she thought it would be cool.
-There is apparently two miller claims with gram and muugen. I don't know what's the chances we have two miller claim in this game. Flower claimed that she trust Muugen, and I personally town lean gram and have muugen as null currently.
-Reborn claims that someone targeting him is weird and that the only people who would off him off this early would be kag and joygirl since he scum read them.

Now, a person surviving a kill per say is not really indicative to anything, it can be townie or scum. But multiple pople surviving this many kills is alarming and scum is 100% among them. Don't see townies having this much bullet proofs. Now who among those people could possibly be scum? While going through doddsy posts I kinda got some good vibes from him? but still I think he focused too much on defending and never saw him personally scum hunting, does not look good on him. Have him as null.

Pero, surviving a super kill indicates that the dude is some OP role, not sure if op townie role or op scum role and If I am willing to bet, he is probably scum here. Actually, now that I remember, he is also immune to investigation? why the fuck would a townie be immune to investigation? very high chance he is scum here.

Baki might possibly be scum here. Two people outing that they sent ability his way and it did not show up in the WU? very sus stuff.

Pot is scummy as fuck and honestly want to see his flip.

Ripped, I liked his posts as I was catching up but it's not enough to put him in town lean just yet.

QueenEmilia been inactive and she is not the type of player that I would expect to contribute at all in the game, she can be anything from scum to lazy townie.

Yo Tan is probably scum here. I was mason with him last game and he was not like this. Did not read the game, does not scum hunt, and being very low radar.

Joygirl, I am getting some bad vibes from her. This silence is concerning.... she is usually so eager to prove herself as townie and contribute as much as she can. Don't see that here.


I personally would want a lynch on either Pot or Pero here and not really interested in any other lynch at the moment.
 
if you’ve listed elsewhere apologies, but what do your reads look like?
I am feeling better about Adam now also as his role does somewhat lean to his involvement in the discussion yesterday and why he took the stance he did, although I still don't agree with or fully understand his argument.

I understand the Peco tanked that shot but I kind of like him for town still, I don't have the vibe post shot that he was panicked in anyway or anything or even really bothering to mount any form of defence.

I am leaning on voting Pot at the moment, as the game progresses I am finding it a lot different to the GoT game in terms of how Pot played. Others having that opinion also skews that pretty substantially as I am not super familiar with most people here yet.

DocProf, Reborn, SoulKiller, TAC coming across as townie to me as well so far. Ultra I am also probably leaning that way on at the moment at least, although I may be being led astray by cool rabbit gifs.

Wouldn't mind further look into Cal, Kag, Melkor or JoyGirl.

In the meantime because I'm currently highest

Vote Pot
Like last page.

But I am also finding it rather difficult to read a lot of people as I am not familiar with how they play, so ideally I would have more.
 
I thought it would be fun <.< plus if he can shoot ppl on my scum list and potentially help us win faster why not. We can easily lynch him if he doesn't follow through.
...... sigh.

Nika, you know you ain't doing townie a favor by doing this. You also amped ratchet out of all people. Good job.

Can you give me your town reads pls? Make it brief.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top