Status
Not open for further replies.

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
How positive are you regarding Mango?

Also, where is your mind at currently in terms of reads after seeing those new flips?
I’ve been openly defending him for the past 2 days so I’d say I’m 98% positive about the guy.

PG, Sal, Emi, Juliet, kagu as scum I have some as 50/50 but these 5 I would say are scum
fry would possibly fit a space team. I am not flavour solving this time game all though becuase it's choose your own character and I dont have the patience. MangoSenpai voted JoyGirl day 1 along with Ekko when JG was a nice option on the lynch chopping block and a counterwagon to Ekko's train. We also have - MangoSenpai very content with a willy nilly lynch on just about anyone. As exhibited by T-Pein I've noticed over the years that usually, scum's inital post usually include something along the lines of "so who's the obligatory Day 1 lynch".
this is a tinfoil theory that I threw out there as a way to see if it was possible for mango to even fit the scum bill based off of theme but youve - I feel like your push against mango has been forced cause you haven’t really answered any of my questions regarding him until now. If he’s scum that’s on me for vouching for him but I feel as if your read on him has been insincere
Also didn't like that in one of my read's list MS said I didn't include them and tried to chalk it up to some scum slip, but they were on the list. Lastly, there's the inactivity, but I get the impression that MS is never out of the loop.

TAC was one of the first people to be scum read by pretty much everyone and EKko and T-Pein were all too willing to lynch him. bussing exist, but I want to assume they were going for low hanging fruit first. so TAC as the benefit of my doubt even though their post dont do well for them. Soul is strong town read because he's antagonising a lot of people this game and engaging in needless arguments that would just make people wanna kill him. I also like that he's actively solving and that our reads are pretty similar
that’s funny cause I was just thinking why I wasn’t included in your PoE list. Given you were calling me out as a scum read early game but you didn’t even know the reasoning for it. Felt like that was also a forced read with no merit to begin with.

alright I agree on the town reads there sk and TAC I also have them in my town pile.
 

MUUGEN

呪のろいの王
it's called discussing things muugen. You should try it sometimes, unless you know for a fact 100% he is townie, then please come forward.

Now, I personally town read him hard, but if we gonna go back to the theory that one scum has to be among the 5 players among that list, then it's worth considering our options and discussing things. Especially after the cop said that he sus him, there is no harm in discussion. Either way, only time his name comes down to the table is toward end game when there is few players left. Then paranoia truly kicks in.

Who do you even sus after Pot/Sall being resolved?
discussing things I’ve actually been game solving all game and questioning just about everyone.

at this point in the game it’s not even remotely possible for the guy to be scum in any capacity unless he’s randomly the final indie. His night lynch was responsible for killing ekko for good so he is not purple and pein has been hard outing him as Tucker so he definitely isn’t yellow.

there’s discussing things and talking nonsense which is what we have rn - in that pile if I had to choose a scum like I said it would be Adam out of the 5.

Emi & Juliet would be next on the list.
 
I’ve been openly defending him for the past 2 days so I’d say I’m 98% positive about the guy.

PG, Sal, Emi, Juliet, kagu as scum I have some as 50/50 but these 5 I would say are scum

this is a tinfoil theory that I threw out there as a way to see if it was possible for mango to even fit the scum bill based off of theme but youve - I feel like your push against mango has been forced cause you haven’t really answered any of my questions regarding him until now. If he’s scum that’s on me for vouching for him but I feel as if your read on him has been insincere

that’s funny cause I was just thinking why I wasn’t included in your PoE list. Given you were calling me out as a scum read early game but you didn’t even know the reasoning for it. Felt like that was also a forced read with no merit to begin with.

alright I agree on the town reads there sk and TAC I also have them in my town pile.
I’ve been openly defending him for the past 2 days so I’d say I’m 98% positive about the guy.

PG, Sal, Emi, Juliet, kagu as scum I have some as 50/50 but these 5 I would say are scum

this is a tinfoil theory that I threw out there as a way to see if it was possible for mango to even fit the scum bill based off of theme but youve - I feel like your push against mango has been forced cause you haven’t really answered any of my questions regarding him until now. If he’s scum that’s on me for vouching for him but I feel as if your read on him has been insincere

that’s funny cause I was just thinking why I wasn’t included in your PoE list. Given you were calling me out as a scum read early game but you didn’t even know the reasoning for it. Felt like that was also a forced read with no merit to begin with.

alright I agree on the town reads there sk and TAC I also have them in my town pile.
Eh think what you will about my Mango read but I been discussing them since Day 1. I said to the effect then that I thought they were a possibly indie or town who basically is just enjoying the fluff, but since then my impression of them has changed and they're firmly in the scum pile. When catching up I didn't have time or energy to note everything thing and my initial plan was to catch up on post and then iso, but I haven't gotten to any isoing besides Lethal Banks and Midnight Delight due to the overwhelming number of post. I legit have notes about post without names next to it or others which are just a number with no context. As for yourself, it's just an oversight. you subbed in and I wrote your name in weird spot and so always miss it when going down the player list of who's alive and who's in the game. I think our lynch pool is the same and though I scum read Lanji for reasons unknown I town read you.
 
@Nikamara sorry nika, but i will be stealing your reads since you colored them, and I am too lazy to go back and get everyone name.

Scum list (no particular order after we yeet pot and sall and yes I included indie scum as well):
Pot Goblin
Sallucion
Emi
Kagurashii
Marimo_420
Doddsy
Blue
Ratchet
Juliet
Yo Tan Wa


Null/scum lean pile :
Lethal Banks
MitchMatch
The Ancient Centurion


Null/town lean pile:
Mango Senpai
Muugen


Flower vouched for Muugen, muugen vouch for mango which is why I have these two in the null/town lean list. But not comfortable enough to put them in town list just yet.

Town pile (no particular order, for the exception of me ofcourse, towniest of them all):
Adam
Dr_Professor
Ultra
Worst
Grammaton
Nikamara
Soulkiller
Reborn


Reborn/Adam should be resolved end game if we ever reach that far, but for now I town read both of them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top